Philpott v Noble Investments Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA200/2013
CA274/2013
[2014] NZCA 104

BETWEEN

SHAYNE PHILPOTT
First Appellant

NEW ZEALAND TRUSTEE SERVICES LIMITED
Second Appellant
COLIN PETER STOKES
Third Appellant
FAY EUNICE RICHARDSON
Fourth Appellant
BURNSIDE TRUSTEES LIMITED
Fifth Appellant
GREGORY ROBERT SMITH
Sixth Appellant

AND

NOBLE INVESTMENTS LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

17 March 2014

Court:

Stevens, White and French JJ

Counsel:

W J Palmer and J M Silcock for Appellants
P B McMenamin for Respondent

Judgment:

28 March 2014 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for an extension of time to bring an appeal in CA200/2013 is granted.

BThe application for an extension of time to apply for the allocation of a hearing date and to file the case on appeal in CA274/2013 is granted.

CThe two appeals are consolidated.

DThe appellants are to file and serve the case on appeal, attend to any other outstanding matters, including security for costs, and seek a fixture for the hearing of the consolidated appeals within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

EAny cross-appeal by the respondent is to be filed and served within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

FAll questions of costs, in respect of both applications, are reserved pending the outcome of the appeals.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by White J)

  1. The appellants are seeking to pursue appeals against two High Court judgments relating to caveats they lodged to protect certain interests asserted over various Lots in a subdivision being undertaken by the respondent, Noble Investments Ltd (Noble).[1]

  2. The first judgment, delivered by Associate Judge Osborne on 28 June 2012, contained orders that two caveats should not lapse, but also reserved leave to the parties to apply in relation to the following matters:

    (a)a condition that one of the caveats should lapse insofar as it affected one Lot;

    (b)the ability of Noble to have the proceeding brought on for the making of orders that the caveats, insofar as they related to “the balance of land” in four specified Lots, “should lapse” in the event that a “spine road” vested in the Christchurch City Council and Noble had registered certain easements;

    (c)the ability of Noble to apply to the Court for an order that the caveats lapse in relation to titles for land unaffected by stormwater drainage in the event that Noble demonstrated to the caveators or the Court that a route for stormwater drainage from one Lot had been secured other than over the caveated property;

    (d)a requirement that the parties meet to consult as to outcomes which would resolve all or some of the issues raised, including but not limited to certain specified issues; and

    (e)the adjournment of the application to 3 December 2012.[2]

    [2]Subsequently brought forward for mention to 4 September 2012 (shortly after the anticipated vesting of the spine road)…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Philpott v Noble Investments Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZCA 104
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, the appellants, comprising Shayne Philpott and others, sought to appeal against two High Court judgments made in relation to caveats they had lodged over certain lots in a subdivision being developed by Noble Investments Limited (the respondent). The first judgment, delivered on 28 June 2012, preserved the validity of two caveats but reserved several conditions for further application, including the potential lapse of one caveat in relation to a specific lot, the lapse of the caveats concerning four lots if certain conditions were met, and the lapse of the caveats over land unaffected by stormwater drainage under certain circumstances. The second judgment, delivered on 5 March 2013, modified the terms of the first judgment and dismissed some of the appellants' applications. The appellants filed an application for an extension of time to appeal the first judgment and an appeal against the second judgment. The respondent opposed the application for an extension of time.

The primary legal issues before the court were whether the appellants were entitled to an extension of time to appeal the first judgment and whether the appeals against the first and second judgments should be consolidated. The court considered the interrelated nature of the two judgments, the lack of clarity about the necessity of an appeal against the first judgment at the time, the potential for prejudice to the respondent if the appeals were not consolidated, and the overall context of the proceedings. The court found that the close relationship between the two judgments and the potential for overlap in the appeals justified consolidating the appeals and granting the extension of time.

The court granted the application for an extension of time to appeal the first judgment and the appeal against the second judgment. It consolidated the two appeals and ordered the appellants to file and serve the case on appeal, address any outstanding matters including security for costs, and seek a fixture for the consolidated appeals within 20 working days of the judgment. The court also ordered that any cross-appeal by the respondent must be filed and served within the same timeframe and reserved all questions of costs pending the outcome of the appeals.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case concerns two appeals brought by Shayne Philpott and others (appellants) against Noble Investments Limited (respondent). The appellants sought to protect their interests over certain Lots in a subdivision being undertaken by Noble through the lodging of caveats. The first judgment, delivered on 28 June 2012, contained orders that two caveats should not lapse but reserved leave to the parties to apply in relation to various matters, including conditions for the lapse of one of the caveats, the ability of Noble to have the proceeding brought on for making orders that the caveats should lapse in certain circumstances, and a requirement for the parties to consult on outcomes to resolve issues raised. The appellants did not exercise their right to appeal against the first judgment within the prescribed time. The second judgment, delivered on 5 March 2013, added a further condition to the orders relating to the lapsing of one of the caveats, amended various aspects of the matters covered in the first judgment, and dismissed applications made by the appellants in respect of those matters. Dissatisfied with both judgments, the appellants filed an application for an extension of time to file an appeal against the first judgment and an appeal against the second judgment. The appellants also applied for an extension of time to apply for the allocation of a hearing date and to file the case on appeal in respect of their appeal against the second judgment.

The appellants filed an application under rule 29A of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 for an extension of time to file an appeal against the first judgment and an appeal against the second judgment. Noble opposed the appellants' application for an extension of time to appeal against the first judgment. The application was set down for hearing in the Court of Appeal on 16 September 2013. The appellants also applied under rule 43(2)(a) of the Rules for an extension of time to apply for a hearing date and to file a case on appeal in respect of their appeal against the second judgment. This application was granted by the Court of Appeal on 19 August 2013. The hearing of the appellants' rule 29A application in respect of the first judgment was adjourned to 26 November 2013 due to ongoing settlement negotiations between the parties. The appellants filed a further application under rule 43(2)(a) for an extension of time to apply for the allocation of a hearing date and to file the case on appeal on 25 September 2013. This application was set down for hearing on 26 November 2013 with the rule 29A application. The applications were adjourned for a new hearing date to be allocated due to a change in Noble's legal representation.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the application for an extension of time to bring an appeal against the first judgment should be granted.
2. Whether the application for an extension of time to apply for the allocation of a hearing date and to file the case on appeal in respect of the appeal against the second judgment should be granted.
3. Whether the two appeals should be consolidated.
4. Whether any cross-appeal by the respondent should be allowed and, if so, within what timeframe.
5. Whether all questions of costs, in respect of both applications, should be reserved pending the outcome of the appeals.

Held
1. The application for an extension of time to bring an appeal against the first judgment is granted.
2. The application for an extension of time to apply for the allocation of a hearing date and to file the case on appeal in respect of the appeal against the second judgment is granted.
3. The two appeals should be consolidated.
4. Any cross-appeal by the respondent should be allowed and must be filed and served within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.
5. All questions of costs, in respect of both applications, are reserved pending the outcome of the appeals.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal granted both applications for extensions of time, finding that the appeals against the first and second judgments were closely interrelated. The second judgment was described as "supplementary" to the first, with the orders made in the second judgment dependent on those made in the first judgment. The Court held that it would not be appropriate to consider the appeal against the second judgment without also considering the first judgment, as the appeal against the second judgment would inevitably involve aspects of the first judgment. The Court also noted that the appellants had not exercised their right to appeal against the first judgment within the time set by the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, but the Court was satisfied that the long delay should be excused given the close interrelationship between the two judgments. The Court further found that the respondent's concerns about prejudice did not warrant a different outcome. Consequently, the Court consolidated the two appeals and directed the parties to file and serve the case on appeal, attend to any other outstanding matters, and seek a fixture for the hearing of the consolidated appeals within 20 working days of the date of this judgment. The respondent was directed to file and serve any cross-appeal within 20 working days of the date of this judgment. All questions of costs were reserved pending the outcome of the appeals.

In reaching its decision, the Court applied the principles of judicial discretion in relation to extensions of time and consolidation of appeals. The Court considered the interrelationship between the two judgments, the nature and scope of the orders made in the first judgment, and the need to consider both judgments together in one appeal hearing. The Court also took into account the respondent's concerns about prejudice, but ultimately found that they did not warrant a different outcome. The Court distinguished this case from prior authority by finding that the close interrelationship between the two judgments justified the grant of both extensions of time and the consolidation of the appeals.