IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTAUTAHI ROHE
CIV-2018-409-000649
[2019] NZHC 1179
BETWEEN LUCIA RENATE PFISTERER
Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff
AND
CLAIMS RESOLUTION SERVICE LIMITED
Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant
AND
GRANT SHAND BARRISTERS AND SOLICITORS
Second Counterclaim Defendant
Hearing: 29 April 2019 Appearances:
M S Smith for Defendant/Counterclaim Plaintiff
A R B Barker QC for Plaintiff/First Counterclaim Defendant A B Darroch for Second Counterclaim Defendant
Judgment:
28 May 2019
JUDGMENT OF OSBORNE J
(on interlocutory applications)
Introduction
[1] Lucia Pfisterer had a property which was affected by the Canterbury Earthquake Sequence.
[2] She entered into a contract with Claims Resolution Service Ltd (CRS) for assistance in relation to that claim. When proceedings came to be issued in Mrs Pfisterer’s name, the firm of Grant Shand Barristers and Solicitors (Grant Shand) was retained to represent her.
PFISTERER v CLAIMS RESOLUTION SERVICE LIMITED [2019] NZHC 1179 [28 May 2019]
[3] A point was reached in the litigation where Grant Shand purported to commit Mrs Pfisterer to a settlement with her insurer. Mrs Pfisterer then denied that Grant Shand was authorised to enter into such an agreement on her behalf. Mrs Pfisterer’s relationship with both CRS and Grant Shand came to an end.
[4] By this proceeding, CRS sought recovery of sums it claims it is entitled to under the contract it entered into with Mrs Pfisterer. Mrs Pfisterer denies liability and has counterclaimed against both CRS and Grant Shand asserting misrepresentation, breach of the Fair Trading Act 1986 and breach of fiduciary duty.
The interlocutory applications
[5]In this judgment, I determine a number of opposed interlocutory applications.
[6] Mrs Pfisterer seeks further discovery from CRS and also an order that CRS answer identified interrogatories.
[7] By cross-application, Grant Shand seeks discovery orders against Mrs Pfisterer.
The conduct of the hearing
[8] To enable the parties to make prompt progress on matters to be ruled on, I dealt separately at the hearing with each subject-matter of the applications and gave such rulings as were possible in the course of the hearing itself. Those are reflected in the judgment which follows. In two areas, the Court’s judgment was reserved and those are also contained in this judgment.
Ruling 1
[9] This is the first of a series of rulings on interlocutory applications I am hearing. In the course of his submissions, Mr Smith, for Mrs Pfisterer, has sought leave to have certain aspects of her discovery application adjourned to be brought on later for hearing if necessary. That is done in the light of the very recent receipt by Mr Smith’s instructing solicitors of a bundle of 329 additional documents.
[10] I am satisfied that Mrs Pfisterer should have the opportunity for her solicitors to review those documents before deciding to what extent, if any, it is necessary to pursue further discovery.
[11]There will accordingly be an order in terms of Mr Smith’s road map,
paragraph 3, save that I delete the words sine die.
Ruling 2
[12]…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Pfisterer v Claims Resolution Service Limited and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 1179
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in this case revolved around several interlocutory applications. Pfisterer sought further discovery from CRS and an order that CRS answer identified interrogatories. Grant Shand sought discovery orders against Pfisterer. The Court had to determine the relevance and necessity of the requested documents in relation to the pleaded claims and counterclaims.
The Court ruled in favour of Pfisterer on some of the interlocutory applications but not on others. The Court granted Pfisterer leave to review additional documents before deciding to what extent, if any, it was necessary to pursue further discovery. The Court also ordered CRS to provide supplementary affidavits regarding the production of timesheets. However, the Court did not grant Pfisterer's request for documents evidencing the job description and/or role of Leon Hendren as general manager of the Staples Group Limited and the power or authority of Hendren or any other person who held the position of general manager of the Staples Group Limited/Staples Can Limited to make decisions for and/or to oversee or direct payments of money held or controlled by Earthquake Services Ltd (ESL).
The Court ruled that CRS must make additional discovery of documents evidencing any direct or indirect financial interest CRS and/or its principal Bryan Staples had in ESL or 8D Project Management Limited (8D), as well as documents evidencing any direct or indirect financial benefit CRS and/or its principal Bryan Staples received in connection with the engagement of ESL or 8D by CRS and/or Grant Shand. However, the Court declined Pfisterer's application for documents evidencing consideration of and/or communications in relation to adverse comments about plaintiff experts made in Minutes issued by Justice Wylie in 2014.
The Court ordered both CRS and Grant Shand to file and serve a statement in answer to interrogatories related to undocumented arrangements between Bryan Staples and Mr Shand, which would share in any CRS costs or CRS commission monies that CRS would charge to/receive from clients who CRS and Shand Solicitors both acted for. The Court declined Grant Shand's application for discovery of correspondence, file notes, and other documents concerning Pfisterer's claim against Southern Response held by certain lawyers and documents relating to the demolition of Pfisterer's property and the sale of her property at 123 Fifield Terrace, Opawa, Christchurch.
The Court reserved the costs and disbursements of both sets of applications, to be resolved by agreement or dealt with on the basis of memoranda to be filed (five-page limit in each case) if no agreement is reached.
Orders
Orders of the court
Full text does not contain this section.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Full text does not contain this section.