Panchal v Immigration and Protection Tribunal

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA544/2017
 [2018] NZCA 83

BETWEEN

MAHESHKUMAR BAHECHARLAL PANCHAL
Appellant

AND

IMMIGRATION AND PROTECTION TRIBUNAL
First Respondent

AND

MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION
Second Respondent

Hearing:

19 March 2018

Court:

Kós P, Brown and Williams JJ

Counsel:

D Zhang for Applicant
K G Stephen and R D Garden for First and Second Respondents

Judgment:

10 April 2018 at 2.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe applications for leave to appeal to the High Court and to bring judicial review proceedings in the High Court are dismissed.

BThe respondent will be entitled to costs on a 2A basis together with the usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Williams J)

Introduction

  1. The Minister of Immigration issued a notice for the deportation of Mr Panchal.  The Minister determined that fraudulent information had been provided by Mr Panchal’s employment supervisor in relation to Mr Panchal’s application for a residence visa.  On appeal to the Immigration and Protection Tribunal (the IPT) the deportation notice was upheld.[1]  In the High Court Woodhouse J declined leave to bring a second appeal to that Court on a question of law and also declined leave to bring proceedings in judicial review.[2]  In accordance with the special procedure in the Immigration Act 2009 (the Act), Mr Panchal now seeks the leave of this Court to bring the proposed High Court proceedings.[3]

Leave to appeal and bring judicial review proceedings

[1]Panchal v Minister of Immigration [2017] NZIPT 600334 [IPT decision].

[3]Sections 245(1) and 249(3).

  1. Section 245(3) of the Act provides the controlling standard for applications for leave to appeal on a question of law.  Both the High Court and this Court on appeal must have regard to whether any question of law posed is one that “by reason of its general or public importance or for any other reason” ought to be submitted to the High Court for consideration.  Section 249 covers applications for leave to bring judicial review proceedings.  Section 249(6) provides the test to be applied by the High Court and this Court on an application for leave.  Regard must be had first to whether the issues involved “could not be adequately dealt with in an appeal against the final determination” of the IPT.[4]  If the answer to that question is they could not, then, as a second filter, the same test as that applicable under s 245(3) must also be applied.[5]

    [4]Section 249(6)(a).

    [5]Section 249(6)(b).

  2. In Taafi v Minister of Immigration the High Court interpreted “any other reason” to require “exceptional circumstances, involving individual injustice to such an extent that the Court simply could not countenance the first instance decision standing”.[6]  This Court affirmed that threshold in Machida v Chief Executive of Immigration New Zealand.[7]  Palmer J in RM v Immigration and Protection Tribunal and in AI (Somalia) v Immigration and Protection Tribunal and Heath J…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Panchal v Immigration and Protection Tribunal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZCA 83
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Panchal v Immigration and Protection Tribunal involved an appeal against deportation by Mr Panchal, who was subject to deportation under the migration legislation. The Immigration and Protection Tribunal (IPT) was tasked with determining whether Mr Panchal's deportation was justified, focusing on the veracity of the information provided in his application and the humanitarian grounds for appeal. The primary legal issues revolved around the interpretation and application of sections 202 and 207 of the relevant legislation, which pertain to the grounds for determining appeals on factual and humanitarian grounds, respectively. Specifically, the court had to consider whether Mr Panchal had fraudulently or misleadingly concealed information in his application, and whether there were exceptional humanitarian circumstances warranting a stay of deportation.

The IPT found that Mr Panchal had not met the burden of proving, on the balance of probabilities, that no information in his application was fraudulent or misleading, nor that no relevant information was concealed. The Tribunal relied on High Court decisions that established the meaning of section 202(ca), confirming that the fraud or concealment need not be directly perpetrated by the deportee, as long as they benefit from it. The IPT noted Mr Panchal's failure to disclose material facts, such as his employment status at the time of his application and his liability for deportation when applying for a loan. The Tribunal concluded that these omissions constituted a pattern of behaviour indicative of fraudulent intent.

In its reasoning, the court held that the IPT was correct in its findings that Mr Panchal's conduct suggested a deliberate concealment of material facts. The Tribunal's decision was consistent with the legal standards set by the High Court, which emphasised the importance of scrupulous honesty in immigration applications. The IPT's conclusion that Mr Panchal was not an innocent victim but rather part of a pattern of concealment was supported by the evidence. Consequently, the appeal against deportation was dismissed, affirming the IPT's decision.

The final orders of the court upheld the IPT's decision to deport Mr Panchal, rejecting his appeal on both factual and humanitarian grounds. The court found that Mr Panchal had not successfully demonstrated that the information in his application was truthful and that no exceptional humanitarian circumstances existed to warrant a stay of deportation. The decision underscored the strict scrutiny applied to immigration applications and the consequences of failing to meet the required standards of honesty and transparency.

Background

Background to the litigation

Section 202 is a mirror provision that applies in relation to appeals before the IPT. It provides:202 Grounds for determining appeal on facts…(ca) in the case of an appellant liable for deportation under section 158(1)(b)(ii), the Tribunal is satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that none of the information provided in relation to the person’s, or any other person’s, application, or purported application, for a visa on the basis of which the residence class visa was granted was fraudulent, forged, false, or misleading, and no relevant information was concealed: In these provisions it is for the IPT to be satisfied, to the civil standard, of the following negative propositions:(a)that there is no fraudulent, forged, false or misleading information in the application; and(b)that no relevant information was concealed. On the second argument in relation to humanitarian grounds, s 207 is the relevant provision:207 Grounds for determining humanitarian appeal(1) The Tribunal must allow an appeal against liability for deportation on humanitarian grounds only where it is satisfied that—(a) there are exceptional circumstances of a humanitarian nature that would make it unjust or unduly harsh for the appellant to be deported from New Zealand; and(b)it would not in all the circumstances be contrary to the public interest to allow the appellant to remain in New Zealand. There are three elements in paragraph (a) and a public interest component in (b). This provision has been the subject of thorough analysis by the Supreme Court.[11] We will address that analysis below. The IPT found that Mr Panchal had not established on the balance of probabilities that none of the information provided in relation to his residence application was fraudulent, nor had he established that no relevant information was concealed. The IPT applied the leading High Court decisions of Rajan v Minister of Education and Pal v Minister of Immigration on the meaning of s 202(ca).[12] Among other things these cases establish that the relevant fraud or concealment need not be that of the proposed deportee. As long as the deportee benefits from the fraud or concealment, his or her state of mind is irrelevant. Notwithstanding this no fault test, the IPT found that there was circumstantial evidence from which to infer that Mr Panchal “knew or ought reasonably to have known” that the offer of the new position was not genuine. This was for two reasons. When Mr Panchal applied under the Skilled Migrant category he did not disclose that he had commenced his employment with the company as a minimum wage cleaner. Disclosure would undoubtedly have raised suspicion in the minds of immigration officials. Second, when he had applied for a $20,000 loan (to fund his wife’s study) he did not disclose he was liable for deportation. The Tribunal concluded:[13][70] The above are examples where the appellant has concealed relevant information in situations where he was required to be scrupulously honest about his personal circumstances. While there is no direct evidence that he colluded with [D] to commit immigration fraud or was reckless as to the truth, there is a clear pattern of behaviour on the appellant’s part to withhold relevant information, which is a form of fraudulent behaviour. The Tribunal rejects the appellant’s assertion that he is the innocent victim of an account manager acting on his own. [12]Rajan v Minister of Education HC Auckland, M1151/94, 31 July 1995; and Pal v Minister of Immigration [2013] NZHC 2070, [2013] NZAR 1240.[13]IPT decision, above n 1.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was Mr Panchal satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that none of the information provided in relation to his application for a residence class visa was fraudulent, forged, false, or misleading, and that no relevant information was concealed?
2. Are there exceptional circumstances of a humanitarian nature that would make it unjust or unduly harsh for Mr Panchal to be deported from New Zealand, and would allowing him to remain not be contrary to the public interest?

Held
1. The court concluded that Mr Panchal did not satisfy, on the balance of probabilities, that none of the information provided in relation to his application for a residence class visa was fraudulent, forged, false, or misleading, and that no relevant information was concealed. The IPT's finding was affirmed.
2. The court concluded that there were no exceptional circumstances of a humanitarian nature that would make it unjust or unduly harsh for Mr Panchal to be deported from New Zealand, and that allowing him to remain would not be contrary to the public interest. The IPT's decision was affirmed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the two grounds of appeal by Mr Panchal. Firstly, the court examined the requirement under section 202 for the IPT to be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that none of the information provided in relation to the visa application was fraudulent, forged, false, or misleading, and that no relevant information was concealed. The court acknowledged that the IPT found there was circumstantial evidence to infer that Mr Panchal knew or ought reasonably to have known that the offer of the new position was not genuine. This finding was based on the fact that Mr Panchal did not disclose his employment with the company as a minimum wage cleaner when applying under the Skilled Migrant category, and he also did not disclose his liability for deportation when applying for a $20,000 loan. The court agreed with the IPT's finding that these instances demonstrated a pattern of behaviour on Mr Panchal's part to withhold relevant information, which constituted a form of fraudulent behaviour. Consequently, the court upheld the IPT's decision on this ground.

Secondly, the court examined the humanitarian appeal under section 207, which requires the IPT to be satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances of a humanitarian nature that would make it unjust or unduly harsh for the appellant to be deported, and that it would not be contrary to the public interest to allow the appellant to remain. The court found that Mr Panchal had not established the exceptional circumstances required under this section. The court noted that the IPT's assessment of the humanitarian appeal was based on the overall circumstances of the case, including Mr Panchal's history of non-disclosure and fraudulent behaviour. The court concluded that there were no exceptional circumstances that would warrant allowing Mr Panchal to remain in New Zealand, and that it was not contrary to the public interest to deport him. Therefore, the court upheld the IPT's decision on this ground as well.