O'Kane c O'Kane

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2023-404-740

[2023] NZHC 2699

UNDER the Companies Act 1993, section 165

BETWEEN

SEAN MARTIN O’KANE

Plaintiff

AND

SUSAN ANNE O’KANE

First Defendant

LEMON TREE DESIGN LIMITED
Second Defendant

TUTA LIMITED

Third Defendant

On the papers: 27 September 2023

Appearances:

Luke T Meys for the Plaintiff

Simon R Mitchell KC for the First Defendant

Judgment:

28 September 2023


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE C B TAYLOR

Costs


This judgment was delivered by me on 28 September 2023 at 3:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules

…………………………. Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Neilsons Lawyers (L T Meys), Onehunga, Auckland, for the Plaintiff

Broadway Law (Jack Rafiei), Newmarket, Auckland, for the First Defendant

Counsel:
Simon Mitchell KC, Hobson Chambers, Auckland, for the First Defendant

SEAN MARTIN O’KANE v SUSAN ANNE O’KANE [2023] NZHC 2699 [28 September 2023]

Introduction

[1]        The plaintiff withdrew his application for interim relief on 19 May 2023. The matter was set down for a hearing on 24 May 2023.

[2]        Moore J issued a minute dated 22 May 2023 ordering the withdrawal of the plaintiff‘s application and vacating the fixture. The defendant now seeks costs in respect of the plaintiff’s application for interim orders.

[3]        Counsel for the first defendant has filed a memorandum dated 16 June 2023, and counsel for the plaintiff filed a memorandum dated the same date.

[4]The Court apologises as these memoranda have only just been referred to me.

Costs sought by the first defendant

[5]        Mr Mitchell KC, for the first defendant, submits that r 15.23 of the High Court Rules 2016 (the Rules) creates a presumption that a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding will pay costs to the defendant. Mr Mitchell submits that the presumption in r 15.23 obviates the requirement for the defendant to demonstrate the plaintiff acted unreasonably in commencing and then discontinuing the proceeding.1

[6]        Mr Mitchell submits that the category for costs in this proceeding is category 2 and therefore a daily rate of $2,390.00 should apply. He also points to r 14.8 which provides that costs on an opposed interlocutory application, unless there are special reasons to the contrary, must be fixed in accordance with these rules when the application is determined.

[7]        Mr Mitchell is seeking 2B costs, accepting that steps 22-25 of Schedule 3 are applicable:


1      Opus International Consultants Ltd v Colac Bay Vision Ltd & Anor [2015] NZHC 1782 at [21].

1.0 days – commencement of the statement of defence

0.4 days – preparation for first case management conference;

0.4 days – filing memorandum for first case management conference;

0.6 days – opposition to interlocutory application;

1.5 days – preparation of written submissions.

[8]        Mr Mitchell then totals the allocation to 3.9 days at $2,390.00 per day, being a total of $9,321.00.

[9]        Finally, Mr Mitchell submits that as the award of cost is discretionary, the Court should recognise the significant costs incurred by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Kane c O'Kane and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZHC 2699
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of O'Kane v O'Kane involved Sean Martin O'Kane, the plaintiff, and Susan Anne O'Kane, the first defendant, with Lemon Tree Design Limited and Tuta Limited as the second and third defendants. The plaintiff's initial application for interim relief was withdrawn on 19 May 2023, and the matter was set for a hearing on 24 May 2023. The first defendant, Susan Anne O'Kane, sought costs associated with the plaintiff's withdrawn application for interim orders. The central legal issue revolved around the application of costs under the High Court Rules 2016, specifically rule 15.23, which presumes that a plaintiff who discontinues a proceeding will pay costs to the defendant.

The court addressed whether the presumption in rule 15.23 required the defendant to demonstrate unreasonable conduct by the plaintiff in initiating and then discontinuing the proceeding. Counsel for the first defendant argued that the presumption obviated this requirement and sought costs under category 2, at a daily rate of $2,390.00, for various steps in preparing the defence and opposing the interlocutory application. Counsel for the plaintiff contended that the costs claimed were excessive and not warranted given the premature withdrawal of the application and the limited steps completed by the first defendant. The court ultimately decided to award costs to the first defendant, but at a reduced amount of $5,019.00, considering only the costs associated with filing the opposition and preparing written submissions.

Associate Judge Taylor concluded that the first defendant was entitled to costs for filing the opposition to the interlocutory application and preparing the written submissions, but not for the other steps claimed. The court disallowed claims for the preparation of the statement of defence, the first case management conference, and the preparation of the affidavit, finding that either these steps were not completed or their costs were already accounted for in other claimed expenses. The court ordered the plaintiff to pay the first defendant costs of $5,019.00.