O'Byrne v Waimakariri District Council

Link copied
Case Copied 1 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA584/2010
[2011] NZCA 130

BETWEEN  ROGER W O'BYRNE
Applicant

AND  WAIMAKARIRI DISTRICT COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:         31 March 2011

Court:             Glazebrook, Simon France and Lang JJ

Counsel:         Applicant in Person
S C Newell for Respondent

Judgment:      4 April 2011 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

The application for special leave to appeal against sentence is declined.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Simon France J)

Introduction

  1. Mr O’Byrne pleaded guilty to erecting a hay shed without a building consent.  He was fined $7,500 plus costs.  He appealed the sentence.  Fogarty J reduced it to $6,000 plus costs.  Mr O’Byrne then sought leave to appeal to this Court, which was declined.  He now seeks special leave to appeal.

  2. Mr O’Byrne’s position is that he wrongly accepted legal advice to plead guilty. Having now himself looked at the Building Act 2004, he believes that his situation came within the provisions of s 41(1)(c) of the Act which provides a defence where the work is urgent and there is not time to obtain a permit.

  3. It was explained to Mr O’Byrne that to withdraw his guilty plea, he must appeal his conviction.  He will also now need leave to appeal out of time.

  4. No issue is raised about his sentence, which is the only matter actually appealed to date.  The application for special leave must, therefore, be declined.  The respondent does not seek costs.

Solicitors:
Crown Law Office, Wellington for Respondent

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read O'Byrne v Waimakariri District Council and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2011] NZCA 130
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of O'Byrne v Waimakariri District Council, the appellant, Roger W O'Byrne, sought to appeal the sentence imposed upon him by the Waimakariri District Council for constructing a hay shed without obtaining the required building consent. The sentence was initially set at $7,500, plus costs, but this was later reduced to $6,000, plus costs, by Fogarty J. O'Byrne then sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was denied. The Court of Appeal subsequently declined O'Byrne's application for special leave to appeal against the sentence. The appellant argued that he had mistakenly followed legal advice to plead guilty, and having reviewed the Building Act 2004, he believed his situation fell within the provisions of s 41(1)(c) of the Act, which provides a defence where the work is urgent and there is not enough time to obtain a permit.

The primary legal issue before the Court of Appeal was whether O'Byrne should be granted special leave to appeal against the sentence. The Court explained that for O'Byrne to withdraw his guilty plea, he would need to appeal his conviction and obtain leave to appeal out of time. However, no issue was raised about the sentence itself, which was the only matter actually appealed to date. Consequently, the application for special leave had to be declined.

The Court of Appeal, comprising Glazebrook, Simon France, and Lang JJ, found that O'Byrne's application for special leave to appeal against the sentence should be declined. The Court emphasised that the appellant had not raised any issue about the sentence itself, and the application for special leave was based solely on the premise of withdrawing the guilty plea. The Court of Appeal was of the opinion that no special circumstances warranted granting special leave in this case. As a result, the Court denied the application for special leave, and the respondent did not seek costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr O'Byrne pleaded guilty to erecting a hay shed without a building consent. He was fined $7,500 plus costs. He appealed the sentence, which was reduced to $6,000 plus costs by Fogarty J. Mr O'Byrne then sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was declined. He now seeks special leave to appeal. Mr O'Byrne contends that he wrongly accepted legal advice to plead guilty. He has since reviewed the Building Act 2004 and believes his situation falls under s 41(1)(c) of the Act, which provides a defence where the work is urgent and there is not time to obtain a permit.

Mr O'Byrne pleaded guilty in the lower court and was fined. He appealed the sentence, which was reduced by Fogarty J. After the refusal of leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, Mr O'Byrne now seeks special leave to appeal against the sentence.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does Mr O'Byrne have grounds to appeal the refusal of special leave to appeal against his sentence?
2. Should the appeal be allowed despite the requirement to appeal the conviction to withdraw the guilty plea?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal declines Mr O'Byrne's application for special leave to appeal against his sentence.
2. The appeal is not allowed because Mr O'Byrne has not appealed his conviction to withdraw the guilty plea, which is a prerequisite for appealing the sentence in this context.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr O'Byrne, who pleaded guilty to erecting a hay shed without a building consent, was fined $7,500 plus costs. The High Court's Fogarty J later reduced the fine to $6,000 plus costs. Mr O'Byrne appealed the sentence and subsequently sought special leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was declined. The Court's reasoning was that the application for special leave to appeal against sentence must be declined because Mr O'Byrne's grounds for appeal pertained to his decision to plead guilty, which necessitated an appeal of his conviction to withdraw the plea. Since no appeal of the conviction was made, the special leave to appeal against the sentence could not be granted. The Court also noted that Mr O'Byrne's belief that he was within a statutory defence did not alter the requirement to appeal the conviction to challenge the plea. The ratio decidendi here is that to appeal a sentence, the defendant must first appeal the conviction if they seek to withdraw their guilty plea, as the two are interlinked in this context. The Court did not need to depart from or distinguish any prior authority in making this decision, as the requirement to appeal the conviction to challenge a plea is a well-established principle.