General Marine Services Limited v The Ship 'Luana'

Link copied
Case Copied 3 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA35/2012
[2012] NZCA 374

BETWEEN  ROGER WILLIAM O'BYRNE
Applicant

AND  THE WAIMAKARIRI DISTRICT COUNCIL
Respondent

Hearing:         17 July 2012

Court:             Glazebrook, White and Simon France JJ

Counsel:         Applicant in Person
E D Peers and E M Ritchie for Respondent

Judgment:      21 August 2012 at 4.00pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for special leave to appeal against a refusal to extend the time for appealing against conviction is dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

BThere is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Simon France J)

  1. Mr O’Byrne was charged under the Building Act 2004 with erecting a hay shed without a building consent. He was represented by counsel and pleaded guilty. He was fined $7,500 and court costs of $130.[1]  On appeal the fine was reduced to $6,000.[2]

    [1]Waimakariri District Council v O’Byrne DC Rangiora CRI-2009‑061‑1116, 21 October 2009, Judge Bisphan.

    [2]O’Byrne v Waimakariri District Council HC Christchurch CRI-2009‑409‑188, 29 April 2010, Fogarty J.

  2. Mr O’Byrne then sought leave to appeal his sentence to this Court. The High Court declined leave,[3] and the matter came to this Court by way of an application for special leave.[4]  By then it was apparent that Mr O’Byrne, now acting for himself, wished to challenge his conviction.  He considered he should not have pleaded guilty because he had available to him the statutory defence of necessity.  Special leave was declined, with Mr O’Byrne being informed he would need to return to the High Court to seek an extension of time to appeal his conviction.

    [3]O’Byrne v Waimakariri District Council HC Christchurch CRI-2009‑409‑188, 13 August 2010, Fogarty J.

  3. Mr O’Byrne has now done that.  Chisholm J reviewed the arguments Mr O’Byrne would make, and concluded they lacked merit.  Accordingly, an extension of time was declined.[5]  Mr O’Byrne again sought leave to appeal to this Court.  Chisholm J declined the application.[6]  Mr O’Byrne then sought special leave to appeal to this Court.

    [5]O’Byrne v Waimakariri District Council [2011] NZAR 777 (HC).

    [6]O’Byrne v Waimakariri District Council HC Christchurch CRI-2011‑409‑65, 13 December 2011, Chisholm J.

  4. Shortly before the scheduled hearing of this application, and after submissions had been filed, this Court of its own motion raised the issue of jurisdiction.  Mr O’Byrne was unprepared for this and time was given for him to file submissions on the point.  The Council accepted that the Court’s minute[7] raising the issue accurately stated the law and did not wish to be further heard.

    [7]      O’Byrne v Waimakariri District Council CA35/2012, 16 July 2012.

  5. Mr O’Byrne filed written submissions. Whilst he has addressed the criteria relevant to a s 144 Summary Proceedings Act 1957 application,  he has not been able to advance matters in relation to whether there is jurisdiction in a situation where  an extension of time has been refused by the High Court.

  6. The issue has arisen previously in Taufoou…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read General Marine Services Limited v The Ship 'Luana' and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 374
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of General Marine Services Limited v The Ship 'Luana', the Court of Appeal of New Zealand was presented with an application for special leave to appeal against a refusal to extend the time for appealing against conviction. The applicant, Roger William O'Byrne, had previously been convicted under the Building Act 2004 for erecting a hay shed without a building consent. After initially pleading guilty and being fined, O'Byrne sought to appeal his sentence and later his conviction. His attempts to extend the appeal time were consistently denied by the High Court, leading to his application for special leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal. The legal issues at the core of this case centred on the jurisdiction of the Court of Appeal to grant special leave to appeal when the High Court had already declined to extend the time for appeal, and whether the statutory defence of necessity could have been available to O'Byrne at the time of his conviction.

The Court of Appeal examined the jurisdictional requirements under section 144 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957, noting that special leave to appeal is only available if an appeal has already been heard in the High Court. The Court referenced previous cases, Taufoou v Department of Labour and Tocker v Police, which established that jurisdiction is triggered by the final decision of the High Court, not by interlocutory matters. In this case, since the High Court had already declined to grant an extension of time, the Court of Appeal found that it lacked jurisdiction to hear the application for special leave. The applicant's arguments did not sufficiently address the jurisdictional issue, focusing instead on the merits of his case. Consequently, the application was dismissed for lack of jurisdiction.

The Court of Appeal's decision was grounded in the established legal principles regarding the scope of its jurisdiction. Given the clear precedent and the finality of the High Court's decision to decline the extension of time, the Court concluded that it did not have the authority to entertain the application. As a result, the application for special leave to appeal was dismissed. Additionally, since the matter of costs had not been raised by the respondent, and the jurisdictional issue was not apparent until raised by the Court, no order was made regarding costs. This decision reinforces the importance of adhering to jurisdictional limits and the procedural requirements for appeals in New Zealand's legal system.

Background

Background to the litigation

Roger William O'Byrne was charged under the Building Act 2004 with erecting a hay shed without a building consent. He pleaded guilty in the District Court, Rangiora, and was fined $7,500 and ordered to pay $130 in court costs. The fine was later reduced to $6,000 on appeal. O'Byrne subsequently sought leave to appeal his sentence to the Court of Appeal, but this was denied. He then attempted to challenge his conviction on the basis of the statutory defence of necessity. This Court denied special leave to appeal his conviction, directing him to seek an extension of time to appeal in the High Court. O'Byrne sought such an extension, but it was declined by Chisholm J. He again sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal, which was also declined. This led to the current application for special leave to appeal the refusal of an extension of time.

The matter initially came before the District Court, Rangioma, where O'Byrne pleaded guilty to the charge of erecting a hay shed without a building consent. He was fined $7,500 plus court costs of $130. The fine was reduced to $6,000 on appeal. O'Byrne then sought leave to appeal his sentence to the Court of Appeal, but this was denied. When he sought to challenge his conviction by appealing against the refusal to extend the time for appealing against conviction, the High Court declined to grant an extension of time. O'Byrne sought special leave to appeal this decision to the Court of Appeal, which was also declined. The Court of Appeal raised the issue of its jurisdiction on its own motion and, after O'Byrne filed submissions, declined the application for special leave to appeal on the basis of lack of jurisdiction.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the Court of Appeal have jurisdiction to grant special leave to appeal the refusal of an extension of time to appeal a conviction when the High Court has already declined to grant such an extension?
2. In what circumstances does jurisdiction under s 144 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957 arise?

Held
1. The Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to grant special leave to appeal the refusal of an extension of time to appeal a conviction when the High Court has already declined to grant such an extension.
2. Jurisdiction under s 144 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957 arises only when there has actually been an appeal heard in the High Court, and not for interlocutory matters such as the refusal of an extension of time.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the jurisdiction to grant special leave to appeal the refusal of an extension of time to appeal a conviction. The Court noted that the High Court had already declined to grant such an extension, and that the matter was now in the Court of Appeal as a request for special leave. The Court referenced previous cases, Taufoou v Department of Labour and Tocker v Police, which established that jurisdiction under s 144 of the Summary Proceedings Act 1957 only arises when there has been an actual appeal heard in the High Court. The refusal of an extension of time by the High Court is considered the final step available to the applicant, and therefore, the Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction in this case. The Court declined the application for special leave to appeal due to the lack of jurisdiction, and made no order as to costs since the lack of jurisdiction was only raised by the Court itself. The binding legal principle established or applied by the decision is that the Court of Appeal does not have jurisdiction to hear an application for special leave to appeal the refusal of an extension of time to appeal a conviction when the High Court has already declined to grant such an extension.