North Holdings Development Ltd v WGB Investments Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2013-404-3622 [2014] NZHC 1175

BETWEEN

NORTH HOLDINGS DEVELOPMENT

LIMITED AND NORTH HOLDINGS INVESTMENT LIMITED, CATCHLAY INVESTMENTS LIMITED, OMAHANUI HOLDINGS LIMITED, GRD MARKETING LIMITED, PE GA INVESTMENTS LIMITED, SOOK JIN SUSAN LEE, RJA INDUSTRIAL LIMITED, KGH HOLDINGS LIMITED,

MARK JOHN PEVATS, NORMA JOYCE PYLE AND ROGER NOEL PYLE, MARK JOHN PEVATS, NORMA JEAN PYLE AND ROGER NOEL PYLE, DAVID GREGORY CARR AND LYNETTE MAREE DUNCAN, SIX SEVEN LIMITED, HSIU-YEN WANG AND GONG-LIANG JOU

Applicants

AND

WGB INVESTMENTS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: On the papers

Counsel:

A E Hansen for Applicants
K McDonald for Respondent

Judgment:

30 May 2014

JUDGMENT OF KATZ J (Costs)

This judgment was delivered by me on 30 May 2014 at 3:00 pm

Pursuant to Rule 11.5 High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:           Heimsath Alexander, Auckland

Kevin McDonald & Associates, Auckland

NORTH HOLDINGS DEVELOPMENT LIMITED & ORS v WGB INVESTMENTS LIMITED [2014] NZHC

1175 [30 May 2014]

Introduction

[1]      North Holdings Development Limited (“North Holdings”) is the developer of an industrial/commercial park known as Northgate Park, near Marsden Point, in the Whangarei District.  North Holdings and the other applicants together own all of the lots in Northgate Park, other than the two lots owned by the respondent, WGB Investments Ltd.

[2]      The applicants applied for orders modifying a restrictive land covenant which had been lodged by North Holdings against the titles to the lots in the Northgate Park development.  The need to modify that covenant arose as a result of a zoning change. In particular, Northgate Park was formerly zoned for heavy industrial purposes. It is now zoned for “mixed use” activities.  The covenant, however, reflected the previous zoning.   It required all buildings to “be constructed to a high standard and high quality  in  new  building  materials  in  a  manner  in  keeping  with  a  high  quality industrial estate”.  The main amendment sought by the applicants was to change the words  “industrial  estate”  to  “mixed  use  development”.    This  would  bring  the covenant   into   line   with   the   new   zoning.   WGB   Investments   opposed   that modification.

[3]      By Judgment dated 4 April 20141  I granted the application to modify the covenant.  I held that there were strong grounds in favour of the Court exercising its discretion to modify the covenant.  There would be little or no detriment to WGB Investments in the covenant being modified, as it has secured a certificate of compliance for its current (industrial) plans. Conversely, there would be clear detriment to the applicants in the covenant remaining in its existing form, as they would be unable to develop their properties, as of right.

[4]      I reserved the issue of costs.  The applicants have now filed a memorandum in which they seek an award of 2B scale costs.  The respondent opposes any award

of costs and submits that costs should lie where they fall.

1      North Holdings Development Limited & Anor v WGB Investments Limited [2014] NZHC 670,

4 April 2014.

Should costs be awarded in favour of the applicants?

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read North Holdings Development Ltd v WGB Investments Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1175
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

North Holdings Development Limited, along with several other applicants, sought to modify a restrictive land covenant registered against their titles, which had been imposed by North Holdings itself. The covenant required buildings to be constructed to a high standard and high quality in new building materials in a manner in keeping with a high quality industrial estate. The modification sought was to change the words "industrial estate" to "mixed use development" to reflect the new zoning of Northgate Park. WGB Investments Limited, which owned two lots in the development, opposed the modification. The High Court of New Zealand initially granted the application to modify the covenant, finding that there would be little detriment to WGB Investments in the covenant being modified and significant detriment to the applicants if the covenant remained in its existing form.

The applicants then sought an award of 2B scale costs, claiming that they had made numerous efforts to obtain WGB Investments' agreement to the modification of the covenant prior to the hearing, which, if accepted, would have avoided costs to all parties. WGB Investments opposed any award of costs, arguing that the costs should lie where they fall and relying on the principle that in cases where an applicant seeks to remove or modify the respondent’s existing contractual rights, the unsuccessful party is entitled to an award of costs. WGB Investments also cited cases where the courts found that the successful party should bear the costs.

The court considered the nature of the proceedings, noting that unlike in ordinary civil litigation, a party opposing the extinguishment or modification of a covenant starts from the position of being "in the right" by seeking to protect their existing legal rights. Therefore, the usual rule that costs follow the event does not apply. However, the court found that WGB Investments' opposition was not unreasonable enough to warrant an award of costs against it. Instead, the appropriate course was for costs to lie where they fall. The applicants' application for costs was dismissed, and costs were to lie where they fell.