Millstone Grazing Limited v Myoak Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2016-441-25 [2016] NZHC 1760

BETWEEN

MILLSTONE GRAZING LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

MYOAK HOLDINGS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing:

29 July 2016

(On the papers)

Appearances:

J Haig and H Gordon for Applicant
N Farrands for Respondent

Judgment:

29 July 2016

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      Millstone Grazing Limited (Millstone) was successful in sustaining a caveat lodged over land owned by Myoak Holdings Limited (Myoak).  It now seeks costs in the absence of agreement between the parties.

The arguments

[2]      Millstone relies on the ordinary principle that costs follow the event, and submits there are no reasons why the Court should not follow the general principle provided by r 14.2(a) of the High Court Rules, that a party who fails on an interlocutory application should pay costs to the party who succeeds.   Millstone submitted that its application to sustain the caveat can be likened to an interlocutory application which, in the absence of special reasons, costs on the application are to

be fixed when the application is determined and thereby become payable.1

[3]      Myoak opposes costs being awarded.  It submits the question of costs should

be  reserved  until  the  merits  of  Millstone’s  case  is  tested  and  the  proceeding

1      High Court Rules,r 14.8.

MILLSTONE GRAZING LTD v MYOAK HOLDINGS LTD [2016] NZHC 1760 [29 July 2016]

determined.   It notes the Court may yet conclude that Millstone has no caveatable interest.  In support of its opposition, Myoak drew on a number of cases where this Court has taken the view that it was more appropriate to reserve the question of costs until the outcome of the substantive proceedings were known or, alternatively, that costs should lie where they fall.2

[4]      Myoak further submitted the relief granted to Millstone was based on a low threshold which inherently involves preserving the present position until the issue can  be  fully determined  on  its  merits.    It  was  critical  of  Millstone  not  having expeditiously pursued  its  claim,  and  submitted  that  it  was  appropriate  in  those circumstances for any question of costs to be held over until the substantive matter was decided.

[5]      Myoak expressed concern that Millstone having sustained the caveat would be unmotivated having regard to the merits of the substantive dispute to diligently advance the substantive proceeding.  In the circumstances, Myoak submitted it was more appropriate for each party to bear its own costs.

[6]      In response to Myoak’s objection to an award of costs, Millstone submitted the cases relied upon turned on their individual circumstances, and that there were features in those cases justifying the non-award of costs which are not present here. Millstone rejected the suggestion it has been tardy in prosecuting its claim.  It points to the steps it has taken to sustain the caveat, that it has complied with timetable

orders throughout, and that it intends to file its claim by mid August.

2      Sia-Fox v Jubilee Management Ltd HC Wellington CIV-2010-454-377, 2 August 2010; Thomas v Thomas HC Christchurch CIV-2011-409-002514, 24 April 2012; Wakenshaw…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Millstone Grazing Limited v Myoak Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 1760
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Millstone Grazing Limited successfully sustained a caveat over land owned by Myoak Holdings Limited and now seeks costs following the parties' inability to agree. The case was heard and determined by Mander J on 29 July 2016. The primary issue before the court was whether Millstone should be awarded costs in light of its successful application to sustain the caveat. Millstone argued that it should be awarded costs in accordance with the general principle provided by rule 14.2(a) of the High Court Rules, which states that a party who fails on an interlocutory application should pay costs to the party that succeeds. Myoak opposed the award of costs, arguing that the question of costs should be reserved until the merits of Millstone’s case are tested and the proceeding is determined. It noted that the court may yet conclude that Millstone has no caveatable interest and drew on cases where the court had taken the view that it was more appropriate to reserve the question of costs until the outcome of the substantive proceedings were known.

The court held that the issue of costs is to be determined on the basis of the success of the parties as it relates to the discrete application before the court. The court found that the issue for it in deciding whether to sustain the caveat was quite different from the ultimate decision that would be required on the substantive proceeding. The court found that it was appropriate that in the ordinary way costs should follow the event in favour of the successful party. The court categorised the proceedings as 2B, noting that the present case raised issues of relative complexity with a factual background of some depth involving earlier litigation between the parties. The court found that the modest claim by Millstone to reflect the steps taken to bring the matter on for hearing was not unreasonable. The court found that no allowance should be made for second counsel, as the instructing solicitor acting on behalf of Millstone was called upon during the hearing only in an attempt to provide clarification of factual background in relation to matters not covered by the affidavit evidence. The court found that the reasonable cost of sealing orders could be recovered by the successful party.

The court ordered that costs be paid by Myoak in the sum of $10,258 and disbursements of $1,280.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established