Middeldorp v Avondale Jockey Club Inc

Link copied
Case Copied 38 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA237/2019
 [2020] NZCA 13

BETWEEN

VINCENT JACOB MIDDELDORP
Appellant

AND

AVONDALE JOCKEY CLUB INCORPORATED
Respondent

Hearing:

13 November 2019

Court:

Goddard, Brewer and Gendall JJ

Counsel:

P W David QC and C D Boswell for Appellant
G M Coumbe QC and D A C Bullock for Respondent

Judgment:

12 February 2020 at 11.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed in part.  We make a declaration that the decisions to suspend Mr Middeldorp from the Committee of the Avondale Jockey Club Inc were not authorised by the Club’s Rules and were unlawful.

BThe appeal is otherwise dismissed.

CThe respondent must pay the appellant usual disbursements.  Apart from that, we make no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Goddard J)

Introduction

  1. Mr Middeldorp is a member of the Avondale Jockey Club Inc (the Club).  He has been a member of the Club since 1982.  He was elected to its Committee in October 2013.  Mr Middledorp was a vociferous opponent of decisions made by the Club in relation to the closure of its training track, among other matters.  This brought him into conflict with the Club’s officers and the majority of the Committee.  That conflict in turn led to Mr Middeldorp filing judicial review proceedings in the High Court raising three issues in relation to the governance of the Club:

    (a)He challenged decisions made by the Committee on two occasions, in November 2016 and December 2017, suspending him from office as a Committee member.

    (b)He challenged decisions made by the Committee in July/August 2017 declining 14 applications for membership of the Club.

    (c)He sought declarations that the Committee has operated from 2014 onwards without the required number of members and has breached the Club’s Rules (Rules) in relation to elections to the Committee.

  2. In the High Court Gordon J found that the Committee did not have the power to suspend a Committee member under the Club’s Rules.[1]  The suspensions of Mr Middeldorp were therefore unauthorised and unlawful.  However, the Judge declined to grant a declaration to that effect, having regard to a number of factors including delay in seeking judicial review, and Mr Middeldorp’s conduct.  Mr Middeldorp appeals from the refusal to grant a declaration. 

    [1]Middledorp v Avondale Jockey Club Inc [2019] NZHC 901, [2019] NZAR 738 [High Court decision].

  3. Mr Middeldorp also appeals from the findings made by the High Court that:

    (a)the Committee acted lawfully in declining the 14 membership applications; and 

    (b)the Committee did not breach the Rules by operating with fewer than 10 members, and conducting elections for Committee membership in a manner that departed from the requirements of the Rules.

Summary of outcome on appeal

  1. We have concluded that the High Court erred in declining to make a declaration that the suspensions of Mr Middeldorp were not authorised by the Rules, and were unlawful.  The Committee purported to impose a sanction on Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Middeldorp v Avondale Jockey Club Inc and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZCA 13
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Middeldorp v Avondale Jockey Club Inc was an appeal in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, concerning the governance and management of the Avondale Jockey Club Inc (the Club). The Club had faced financial difficulties since the early 1990s, and had been supplementing its income by leasing some of its facilities to the Auckland Council for use as sports fields and to the operator of the Avondale market. The appellant, Vincent Jacob Middeldorp, was a member of the Club since 1982, and was elected to its Committee in October 2013. Middeldorp strongly opposed the decisions made by the Club in relation to the closure of its training track, which brought him into conflict with the Club's officers and the majority of the Committee. Middeldorp filed judicial review proceedings in the High Court, raising three issues in relation to the governance of the Club.

The court had to decide whether the Committee had the power to suspend a Committee member under the Club's Rules, and whether the suspensions of Mr Middeldorp were authorised and lawful. The court also had to decide whether the Committee acted lawfully in declining the 14 membership applications, the operation of the Committee with fewer than 10 members, and the process adopted for conducting elections for Committee membership.

The court concluded that the High Court erred in declining to make a declaration that the suspensions of Mr Middeldorp were not authorised by the Rules, and were unlawful. The Committee purported to impose a sanction on Mr Middeldorp that it had no authority to impose under the Rules. The court found that the High Court's reasoning for declining to grant a declaration was insufficient to displace the starting point that relief should normally be granted in such circumstances. The court also found that the High Court did not err in dismissing Mr Middeldorp's challenges to the decisions made by the Committee in relation to the 14 membership applications, the operation of the Committee with fewer than 10 members, and the process adopted for conducting elections for Committee membership. The court made a declaration that the decisions to suspend Mr Middeldorp from the Committee were not authorised by the Rules and were unlawful. The appeal was otherwise dismissed, and the respondent was required to pay the appellant usual disbursements. Apart from that, the court made no order as to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established