Malthus v Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2021-404-2234

[2022] NZHC 407

IN THE MATTER of the Charitable Trusts Act 1957

IN THE MATTER

of the Laura Fergusson Trust

BETWEEN

SOPHIA GRACE MALTHUS

First Applicant

FRIENDS OF LAURA FERGUSSON TRUST INCORPORATED SOCIETY
Second Applicant

VICTORIA MARY CARTER
Third Applicant

AND

LAURA FERGUSSON TRUST INCORPORATED

Respondent

Hearing: 28 February 2022

Appearances:

P J Dale QC and V Fletcher for the Applicants

B Keown and D Scholes for the Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated
K Laurenson and A B Lawson for the Attorney-General

Judgment:

17 March 2022


JUDGMENT OF HINTON J


This judgment was delivered by me on Thursday 17 March 2022 at 4.00 pm pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar  Date:………………………….

Counsel/Solicitors:

P J Dale QC, Barrister, Auckland TGT Legal, Auckland

Bell Gully, Auckland Crown Law, Wellington

MALTHUS v LAURA FERGUSSON TRUST INCORPORATED [2022] NZHC 407 [17 March 2022]

[1]                 There are two proceedings before the Court, filed one after the other, which arise essentially out of one dispute. The applicant in the first-filed proceeding, Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated (LFT), seeks to partly strike-out and/or stay the second proceeding.

[2]                 Both proceedings concern the operation of LFT, an entity under the Incorporated Societies Act 1908 and a registered charity. LFT was formerly synonymous with the Laura Fergusson rehabilitation centre, a well-known and much-loved facility in Great South Road that provided care to disabled people. The confidential and controversial closure and sale of that facility triggered the proceedings.

Background

[3]                 LFT emerged out of the Laura Fergusson Trust for Disabled Persons (the National Trust), which was established by deed dated 25 May 1967. LFT itself was established in 1969 to support disabled persons under the Laura Fergusson name in the Auckland region. Other entities were set up in Wellington and Christchurch. (These continue to provide residential and rehabilitation services for disabled people.)

[4]                 The National Trust deed has a sole object: “to assist disabled persons in the solution of their residential problems”.

[5]                 LFT’s constitution (and rules) on the other hand has 14 objects including: assisting disabled persons to provide rehabilitation services and residential accommodation; carrying out associated research and marketing; sponsoring related activities of others and entering into joint ventures and partnerships to achieve LFT’s objects.

[6]                 LFT has a long history. The Laura Fergusson facility provided residential accommodation, rehabilitation, respite and other services to the disabled community for some 50 years.

[7]                 The Board of LFT took the decision in October 2019 to close down the Laura Fergusson facility, cease provision of its existing services, and sell the Great South

Road property. LFT says that decision was unavoidable and that services could not be provided on a sustainable basis. There was widespread public interest and concern regarding that decision by the Board, including a petition organised by David Seymour, leader of the Act Party. The sale nonetheless proceeded and recently settled.

[8]                 The formation of the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Malthus v Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 407
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand was presented with two proceedings filed by the Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated (LFT) and the Friends of Laura Fergusson Trust Incorporated Society, both seeking declarations regarding the charitable trust's operations and compliance with the Charitable Trusts Act 1957. The LFT sought a declaratory order that it did not hold assets on trust with the sole object of the Laura Fergusson Trust for Disabled Persons, as settled by deed on 25 May 1967, and sought to strike out and stay the Friends' proceeding. The Friends sought declarations that LFT was in breach of the Charitable Trusts Act, held the proceeds of sale as a constructive trustee for beneficiaries of LFT, and held proceeds of donations for the sole object of the National Trust. The Friends also sought a declaration of breach of contract by LFT for refusing to allow new members to join LFT and an inquiry by the Attorney-General into LFT under section 58 of the Charitable Trusts Act.

The court had to decide whether the fourth cause of action in the Friends' proceeding, which alleges breach of contract by LFT for wrongly declining membership applications, discloses a reasonably arguable cause of action. The court also had to decide whether it was just to stay the Friends' proceeding pending the resolution of LFT's proceeding.

The court found that the fourth cause of action, although pleaded imperfectly, was sufficiently pleaded to avoid a strike-out. The court considered that the Friends were entitled to seek an order framed in the way they had, and that the question should not be as framed by LFT. The court also found that it was just for the two proceedings to be heard together or consolidated rather than for the Friends' proceeding to be stayed. The court reasoned that the Friends were the driver behind both proceedings, and that the LFT proceeding, although issued first in time, was clearly in response to the issues raised by the Friends. The court further found that the Friends should have the opportunity to be heard as a party rather than as an intervener, and that it was reasonable for the Friends to have the ability to appeal.

The court dismissed the application to strike out the fourth cause of action, and dismissed the application to stay the Friends' proceeding. The court granted leave to substitute the first applicant in the Friends' proceeding and allocated a one-hour case management conference to the two proceedings. The court encouraged mediation or some form of alternative dispute resolution between the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.