Menzies v Vaycay Trading Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-000935

[2020] NZHC 618

BETWEEN

CAROLYN JOY MENZIES

Plaintiff

AND

VAYCAY TRADING LIMITED

First Defendant

LEONARD BOURTON

Second Defendant

Hearing: 21 October 2019

Counsel:

J Burt for the Plaintiff

D Bennington for Second Defendant

Judgment:

24 March 2020

Reissued:

9 April 2020


REISSUED JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SARGISSON


This judgment was delivered by me on 9 April 2020 at 1.00 p.m. pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date.......................................

Solicitors:

MacDonald Lewis Law, Auckland Duncan Cotterill, Auckland

J Burt, Auckland

MENZIES v VAYCAY TRADING LTD [2020] NZHC 618 [9 April 2020]

Introduction

[1]    The plaintiff, Carolyn Menzies, is the sole director of the first defendant, Vaycay Trading Ltd. She holds half of the shares in Vaycay. The second defendant, Leonard Bourton, holds the other half of the shares.

[2]    Vaycay ceased to trade in December 2017. Ms Menzies seeks an order under the Companies Act 1993 placing Vaycay into liquidation on the grounds that:

(a)Vaycay is unable to pay its debts (s 241(4)(a)); and/or

(b)It is just and equitable that Vaycay be put into liquidation (s 241(4)(d)).

[3]    Mr Bourton opposes the application. Instead, he seeks an order under s 174 that Ms Menzies sell her shares in Vaycay at fair value to Vaycay. He also says that:

(a)He is prepared to introduce funds into the company to trade it out of insolvency if Ms Menzies is removed as the director; and

(b)He has the support of a majority of creditors and hopes they will agree to arrangement compromising their debt or the time for its payment.

Background

[4]    In January 2015, Vaycay was incorporated under the Companies Act. From August 2015 to June 2017, Ms Menzies and Mr Bourton had a domestic relationship and lived together. In June 2017, Mr Bourton moved out. Since then, the relationship between the two deteriorated. Vaycay ceased trading in December 2017.

[5]    On 5 November 2018, the Family Court granted Ms Menzies’ application for a temporary protection order against Mr Bourton. On 8 April 2019, a final protection order was granted against Mr Bourton.

[6]    On 17 May 2019, Ms Menzies filed a statement of claim seeking an order placing Vaycay into liquidation. Mr Bourton opposed the application, filing a statement of defence on 17 July 2019. A hearing was scheduled for 21 October 2019.

[7]    Ms Menzies served a notice to cross-examine defence witnesses, all of whom were creditors of Vaycay.  Three working days’ notice was given in accordance with r 9.74 of the High Court Rules 2016. However, on 18 October 2019, Mr Bourton filed a memorandum for adjournment of the 21 October 2019 hearing on the basis that only one of the deponents would be available for cross-examination. Most of the deponents live on the South Island and one was overseas at the time. Accordingly, three working days was not sufficient to enable the deponents to reschedule their…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Menzies v Vaycay Trading Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 618
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carolyn Menzies, the sole director of Vaycay Trading Ltd, applied to the High Court of New Zealand for an order placing the company into liquidation. The company had ceased trading in December 2017. Mr Bourton, the other shareholder in Vaycay, opposed the application and instead sought an order that Ms Menzies sell her shares in Vaycay at fair value. The court had to decide whether Vaycay was unable to pay its debts and/or whether it was just and equitable for the company to be put into liquidation. The court also had to consider whether an alternative remedy under s 174 was available and if it was a better option than liquidation.

The court found that Vaycay was unable to pay its debts as it had ceased trading, its debts exceeded $800,000, and its assets were insufficient to cover its liabilities. The court also found that it was just and equitable to put Vaycay into liquidation due to the breakdown in the relationship between the shareholders, which had led to a lack of trust and cooperation. Mr Bourton had refused to provide Vaycay's financial records to its agents and had failed to disclose the location of assets belonging to Vaycay. The court concluded that Vaycay should be put into liquidation as it was not clear that the alternative remedy under s 174 would be a better option than liquidation, and s 174 did not guard against liquidation on the grounds of the company's inability to pay its debts.

The court ordered that Vaycay Trading Ltd be put into liquidation and appointed Christopher Carey McCullagh and Stephen Mark Lawrence, insolvency practitioners of Auckland, as liquidators. The liquidators were to apply to the court for approval of their overall remuneration at the conclusion of the liquidation. The plaintiff, Ms Menzies, had a prima facie entitlement to costs on a 2B basis, but the court had an overall discretion in the matter. Mr Bourton had already filed a memorandum as to costs, and if the plaintiff wished to file a memorandum in reply, she had until 20 April 2020 to do so.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.