Menzies v Vaycay Trading Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 18 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE

CIV-2019-404-000935

[2020] NZHC 1413

BETWEEN

CAROLYN JOY MENZIES

Plaintiff

AND

VAYCAY TRADING LIMITED

First Defendant

LEONARD BOURTON

Second Defendant

Hearing: 4 June 2020

Counsel:

J Burt for the Plaintiff

D Bennington for Second Defendant

Judgment:

6 July 2020


COSTS JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE SARGISSON


This judgment was delivered by me on 6 July 2020 at 11.00 a.m. pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar Date.......................................

Solicitors:

MacDonald Lewis Law, Auckland Duncan Cotterill, Auckland

J Burt, Auckland

MENZIES v VAYCAY TRADING LTD [2020] NZHC 1413 [6 July 2020]

Introduction

[1]    This is an application for costs by the plaintiff, Ms Menzies, the sole director and half-share shareholder of the first defendant, Vaycay Trading Ltd.

[2]    On 9 April 2020, I gave judgment in the plaintiff’s favour on an application to liquidate Vaycay.1 Her application was opposed by the second defendant, Mr Bourton, the other half-share shareholder. In my judgment, I indicated that Ms Menzies had a prima facie entitlement to costs on a 2B basis, but I allowed the parties an opportunity to file costs memoranda.

[3]    In her costs memorandum, Ms Menzies seeks indemnity costs of $46,316.06 against both defendants jointly and severally. For comparative purposes, she submits that 2B scale costs and disbursements would be $20,793 and $1,523.57 respectively. Mr Bourton opposes any award of costs; he submits that costs should lie where they fall.

Background

[4]    Vaycay ceased to trade in December 2017. Ms Menzies sought an order under the Companies Act 1993 placing Vaycay into liquidation on the grounds that it was unable to pay its debts and that it is just and equitable to put it into liquidation.      Mr Bourton opposed the order essentially on the ground that the majority of Vaycay’s creditors would rather wait for their money from a company that is no longer trading than pick up any crumbs, so to speak, left over by a liquidator.

[5]    In his statement of defence, Mr Bourton put forth an affirmative defence that a remedy other than liquidation was appropriate and reasonably available in this case. He noted the availability of, and sought in his statement of defence, relief under s 174 by way of an order requiring Ms Menzies’ 50 per cent shareholding to be transferred to Vaycay. However, Mr Bourton never formally made an application for an order under s 174. Instead, as the matter progressed, Mr Bourton’s position changed to


1      Menzies v Vaycay Trading Ltd [2020] NZHC 618. The judgment was originally published on 24 March 2020, but I later recalled and reissued it on 9 April 2020.

seeking time from the Court to give him an opportunity to pull together a creditor’s compromise as an alternative to liquidation.

[6]    On that basis, Mr Bourton submitted at the hearing that the Court should not exercise its discretion in putting Vaycay into liquidation, or at least not just yet.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Menzies v Vaycay Trading Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NZHC 1413
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carolyn Joy Menzies, the sole director and half-shareholder of Vaycay Trading Ltd, applied for the company's liquidation on the grounds that it was unable to pay its debts and that it was just and equitable to put it into liquidation. The application was opposed by Leonard Bourton, the other half-shareholder. The plaintiff sought indemnity costs of $46,316.06 against both defendants jointly and severally, while Mr Bourton opposed any award of costs. The court held that Ms Menzies, as the successful party, was entitled to costs. The court considered whether costs should be awarded against both defendants and if so in what amount, and whether their liability should be joint and several. The court found that the liquidator of Vaycay Trading Ltd (in liq) is liable to pay the actual and reasonable costs of Ms Menzies' application for liquidation, being a total of $46,316.06. Mr Bourton is liable to pay increased costs and disbursements in the total amount of $28,554.47. The liability for costs under the orders is joint and several in the amount of $28,554.47.

This case involved an application for costs by the plaintiff, Ms Menzies, who sought indemnity costs of $46,316.06 against both defendants jointly and severally. The background of the case involved the company Vaycay Trading Ltd, which ceased to trade in December 2017. Ms Menzies sought an order under the Companies Act 1993 placing Vaycay into liquidation on the grounds that it was unable to pay its debts and that it was just and equitable to put it into liquidation. Mr Bourton opposed the order, essentially on the ground that the majority of Vaycay's creditors would rather wait for their money from a company that was no longer trading than pick up any crumbs left over by a liquidator. The court found that Ms Menzies, as the successful party, was entitled to costs. The court considered whether costs should be awarded against both defendants and if so in what amount, and whether their liability should be joint and several. The court found that the liquidator of Vaycay Trading Ltd (in liq) is liable to pay the actual and reasonable costs of Ms Menzies' application for liquidation, being a total of $46,316.06. Mr Bourton is liable to pay increased costs and disbursements in the total amount of $28,554.47. The liability for costs under the orders is joint and several in the amount of $28,554.47.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.