Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited v Hall

Link copied
Case Copied 82 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND MASTERTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA WHAKAORIORI ROHE

CIV-2020-485-000040

[2022] NZHC 1180

BETWEEN

MELCO PROPERTY HOLDINGS (NZ) LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

ANTHONY JOHN HALL

Defendant

Hearing: 09 - 13 May 2022

Appearances:

A.C. Beck and J Perry for the Plaintiff

A.L Holloway and T.A Cunningham for the Defendant

Judgment:

25 May 2022


JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J


MELCO PROPERTY HOLDINGS (NZ) LIMITED v ANTHONY JOHN HALL [2022] NZHC 1180 [25 May 2022]

Table of Contents

Introduction.......................................................................................................... [1]

Background Facts................................................................................................ [4]

Caveat Proceedings............................................................................................ [42]

The Supreme Court decision settled the applicable principles to be applied here      [47]

Melco’s Claim..................................................................................................... [48]

Issues................................................................................................................... [53]

Relief Sought...................................................................................................... [54]

Discussion........................................................................................................... [56]

Implied terms..................................................................................................... [61]

An implied term in this case?........................................................................... [72]

Breach of implied terms.................................................................................... [82]

Nexus between the default and fulfilment of the condition............................ [96]

Specific Performance....................................................................................... [108]

Second Cause of Action- Misleading and deceptive conduct – breach of s 9 of the FTA........................................................................................................................... [115]

Estoppel............................................................................................................ [134]

Damages Claim................................................................................................ [103]

Result................................................................................................................ [167]

Orders............................................................................................................... [169]

Costs.................................................................................................................. [170]

Introduction

[1]    The Plaintiff (Melco) in this proceeding seeks specific performance of an Agreement for Sale and Purchase dated 6 December 2019 (the Contract) of a commercial property at 5 Parliament Street, Lower Hutt (the Property) which contract was concluded between it as purchaser  and  the  Defendant,  Anthony John Hall  (Mr Hall) as vendor.

[2]    The Contract contained a due diligence clause under which Melco had to be satisfied the property was suitable for its requirements or waive compliance. Mr Hall purported to cancel the Contract when, after the close of business on the date for fulfilment of the due diligence condition, Melco had neither given notice of fulfilment nor waived the requirement. Melco did not accept cancellation. Rather, Melco maintained that Mr Hall’s actions at the time put him in default of his obligations under the Contract so that he had no right to cancel it. Melco lodged a caveat against the title to the property to protect its claimed interest. Mr Hall entered into an agreement with a third party to sell the property at a higher price. That agreement came to an end because it was conditional on Melco removing its caveat within 5 working days which did not happen. Instead, Melco purported to waive the due diligence condition and sought settlement under its Contract. Mr Hall refused. Melco then applied to the High Court for an order under s 143 of the Land Transfer Act 2017 that its caveat not lapse. In that application, the issue as to whether the caveat lapsed turned on whether Mr Hall validly terminated the Contract.

[3]    In the various caveat proceedings (the Caveat Proceedings) that followed, ultimately the Supreme Court ordered that Melco’s caveat not lapse. I will address those caveat proceedings shortly. In the meantime, the present substantive proceeding addressing Melco’s overall claim under the Contract proceeded to a hearing before me from 9 May 2022 to 13 May 2022. This judgment addresses Melco’s substantive claim opposed throughout by Mr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited v Hall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZHC 1180
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited v Hall was a legal dispute between the Plaintiff, Melco Property Holdings (NZ) Limited, and the Defendant, Anthony John Hall. The Plaintiff sought specific performance of an Agreement for Sale and Purchase of a commercial property in Lower Hutt, while the Defendant argued that the Plaintiff had failed to fulfill a due diligence condition within the specified timeframe. The case involved multiple legal issues, including the implication of terms, breach of implied terms, misleading and deceptive conduct under the Fair Trading Act, and estoppel.

The Court found that an implied term existed in the Contract, requiring the Defendant to provide reasonable access to the Property for the Plaintiff to conduct due diligence. The Court also found that the Defendant breached this implied term by failing to provide access to the Property on 8 and 9 January 2020, which substantially impeded the Plaintiff's ability to fulfill the due diligence condition. The Court held that the Defendant's conduct had a material effect on the Plaintiff's ability to perform the condition, and thus, the Defendant could not rely on the non-fulfillment of the condition to avoid the Contract.

The Court granted specific performance of the Contract, as the Plaintiff demonstrated that damages would not be an adequate substitute for the unique nature of the property in question. The Court dismissed the Plaintiff's claim for damages, as it had not been properly particularized or supported by evidence. The Court also noted that the merits of the Plaintiff's alternative claims under the Fair Trading Act and estoppel were not necessary to determine, given the success of the primary breach of contract claim.

The final orders included an order for specific performance of the Contract, with a settlement date of 20 working days from the date of the judgment, and a reservation of costs for later consideration.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established