Melco Property Holdings (NZ) 2012 Ltd v Hall

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA653/2020
 [2021] NZCA 184

BETWEEN

MELCO PROPERTY HOLDINGS (NZ) 2012 LIMITED
Appellant

AND

ANTHONY JOHN HALL
Respondent

Hearing:

16 March 2021

Court:

Collins, Brewer and Dunningham JJ

Counsel:

A C Beck and J M Perry for Appellant
A L Holloway and T A Cunningham for Respondent

Judgment:

14 May 2021 at 10.00 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BThe respondent is awarded costs on a Band A basis.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Brewer J)

Introduction

  1. This appeal challenges an Associate Judge’s refusal to sustain a caveat.[1]

  2. By written agreement dated 6 December 2019, the respondent (Mr Hall) agreed to sell the appellant (Melco) a commercial property.  The settlement date was 1 February 2020.

  3. There was a due diligence clause.  It read:

    19.0Due Diligence

    19.1This agreement is subject to and conditional upon the Purchaser being satisfied that the property is suitable for the Purchaser’s requirements following the Purchaser carrying out due diligent verification of the property, including by way of example and without limitation;

    (a)the value and condition of the property;

    (b)the terms of all encumbrances, rights and interests registered against the property;

    (c)the terms and implications of the zoning or permitted use related aspects of the property and any statutory protection notices or designations on the property;

    (d)compliance schedule requirements under the Building Act 2004;

    (e)the overall financial suitability of the Purchaser’s proposed investment in the property, their ability to obtain necessary finance to complete the purchase and financial suitability of the tenant(s).

    19.2The Vendor shall provide the Purchaser upon request with such information (except insofar as the vendor is legally bound to keep such information confidential) which the Vendor has in respect of the property in order to assist the Purchaser to fulfil this condition.

    19.3The date of fulfilment is fifteen (15) working days following execution of this agreement.

    19.4The parties acknowledge that the conditions in clause 19.1 are inserted for the sole benefit of the Purchaser and at any time prior to this agreement being avoided may be waived by the Purchaser giving written notice of waiver to the Vendor.

  4. The date for fulfilment of cl 19 was 9 January 2020.

  5. Melco neither gave notice of fulfilment[2] nor waived the condition before the close of business on 9 January 2020.

    [2]As required by cl 10.8 of the agreement.

  6. At 5.03 pm, on 9 January 2020, by email to Melco’s solicitor, Mr Hall’s solicitor purported to cancel the agreement on the basis of Melco’s failure to fulfil cl 19.

  7. Melco did not accept the cancellation.  Its position (we will come to the detail later) was that various actions of Mr Hall put him in breach of the agreement so that he was not entitled to cancel.  On 16 January 2020, Melco lodged a caveat against the title to the property to protect its…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Melco Property Holdings (NZ) 2012 Ltd v Hall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] NZCA 184
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Melco Property Holdings (NZ) 2012 Ltd appealed against the Associate Judge’s refusal to sustain its caveat over a commercial property that it had contracted to purchase from Anthony John Hall. The contract was conditional upon Melco carrying out due diligence on the property, including obtaining a seismic stability report, by 9 January 2020. Melco failed to do so and Mr Hall purported to cancel the contract on that basis. Melco responded by lodging a caveat over the property. Melco sought an order under the Land Transfer Act 2017 that its caveat not lapse. The Associate Judge dismissed the application and ordered the caveat to lapse. The appeal was against that decision. The issues on appeal were: (a) whether the Associate Judge’s jurisdiction was a summary one; (b) whether the Associate Judge was wrong to hold that Mr Hall had no obligations of good faith in relation to the agreement, and failed to apply correctly the law relating to fulfilment of conditions. The Court found that the Associate Judge was correct to find that there was not a reasonably arguable case that Melco’s failure to fulfil the due diligence condition was due to Mr Hall’s default. It followed that the Associate Judge was correct to order the caveat to lapse. The appeal was dismissed and Mr Hall was awarded costs on a Band A basis.

Background

Background to the litigation

Melco Property Holdings (NZ) 2012 Limited and Anthony John Hall entered into a written agreement for the sale of a commercial property. The agreement was subject to a due diligence clause, which required Melco to complete due diligence on the property by 9 January 2020. Melco did not fulfil this condition by the deadline, and Hall purported to cancel the agreement on this basis. Melco did not accept the cancellation and instead lodged a caveat against the property to protect its interest. Subsequently, Melco sought to waive the due diligence condition and enforce the agreement, but Hall refused. Melco then applied to the High Court for an order preventing the caveat from lapsing. The application was dismissed, leading to this appeal.

The matter came before the Court of Appeal as an appeal against a decision of an Associate Judge of the High Court. The Associate Judge had dismissed Melco's application to prevent the lapse of its caveat over the property. The grounds of appeal challenged the Associate Judge's jurisdiction, the finding that Hall was not in breach of the agreement, and the conclusion that Hall had no obligation to act in good faith.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Associate Judge have the jurisdiction to determine whether Hall was in breach of the agreement, and if so, was the Associate Judge correct to dismiss the application?
2. Was Hall in breach of his obligations under the agreement by failing to provide reasonable access to the property for due diligence?
3. Did Hall have an obligation to communicate his decision not to extend the due diligence period to Melco?

Held
1. The Associate Judge had the jurisdiction to determine whether Hall was in breach of the agreement, and the Court of Appeal upheld the Associate Judge's decision to dismiss the application to sustain the caveat.
2. Hall was not in breach of his obligations under the agreement by failing to provide reasonable access to the property for due diligence. The Court found it was not reasonably arguable that Melco's failure to confirm or waive the due diligence condition was due to Hall's default.
3. Hall had no obligation to communicate his decision not to extend the due diligence period to Melco. The Court of Appeal upheld the Associate Judge's decision that no such obligation existed and could not be implied in the agreement.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal began by considering whether the Associate Judge had the jurisdiction to determine if Hall was in breach of the agreement. The Court noted that the jurisdiction relating to caveats is summary, but it is not precluded from resolving factual disputes when necessary to determine the issues. The Court of Appeal held that the Associate Judge was correct to exercise his summary jurisdiction and found no error in his decision.

The Court then addressed whether Hall was in breach of his obligations under the agreement by failing to provide reasonable access to the property for due diligence. The Court accepted that there was an implied term requiring Hall to provide reasonable access to the property, but it could not be determined whether Hall breached this obligation based on the evidence presented. However, the Court found it was not reasonably arguable that Melco's failure to confirm or waive the due diligence condition was due to Hall's default. The Court noted that Melco did not have a seismic stability report by the deadline, and there was no evidence that access to the property would have generated such a report before the deadline.

Finally, the Court of Appeal considered whether Hall had an obligation to communicate his decision not to extend the due diligence period to Melco. The Court found that Hall had no such obligation, as he never promised to extend the period and was equivocal as to whether he would. The Court also noted that Hall decided not to extend the period on 9 January 2020, after he had learned of an alternative purchaser.

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal upheld the Associate Judge's decision to dismiss the application to sustain the caveat, finding no error in his determination. The Court also found that Hall was not in breach of his obligations under the agreement and had no obligation to communicate his decision not to extend the due diligence period to Melco.