Marsman v Nijkrake

Link copied
Case Copied 5 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA267/2008
[2009] NZCA 461

BETWEENWILLEM ROBERT MARSMAN, UTA BLEIDISTEL AND THK TRUSTEES LIMITED


Appellants

ANDROLAND JOHANNES NIJKRAKE


Respondent

Court:Glazebrook, Hammond and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:D J King and C N King for Appellants


S A Barker and B R Balderstone for Respondent

Judgment:7 October 2009 at 4.00 pm

(On the Papers)

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe Court had jurisdiction to award usual disbursements, despite the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules.

BThe matter is referred to the Registrar to fix the amount of the witness fee disbursements in terms of r 53H(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Glazebrook J)

Introduction

  1. On 23 February 2009, we dismissed an appeal by the appellants against a decision of Associate Judge Gendall sustaining a caveat: in [2009] NZCA 30. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent’s costs and “usual disbursements”.

  2. The respondent seeks to have the appellants meet the full amount of invoices rendered by his expert witness, Ms Peters, in connection with the appeal.  These total C$11,824.39 (about NZ$18,000). 

  3. In a memorandum of 18 March 2009, the appellants maintain that there is now no jurisdiction to order an unsuccessful party to pay a successful party’s expert witness costs as a disbursement.  Alternatively, they argue that the amount that they should pay with regard to Ms Peters’ fees should be reduced.

Relevant provisions

  1. Rule 53H of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005 (the Court of Appeal Rules) provides as follows:

    53H     Disbursements

    (1)     The Court may direct the Registrar to exercise the Court’s powers to order a party (“party A”) to pay another party (“party B”) disbursements.

    (2)     If the Court orders party A to pay party B usual disbursements, the order—

    (a)   encompasses—

    (i)     party B’s disbursements as defined in rule 48H(1) of the High Court Rules; and

    (ii)     party B’s counsel's reasonable travelling and accommodation expenses; and

    (b)is taken to empower the Registrar to fix the types and amounts of disbursements if the parties are unable to agree on them.

  2. Section 8(1) of the Judicature (High Court Rules) Amendment Act 2008 repealed r 48H of the High Court Rules (referred to in r 53H of the Court of Appeal Rules) and substituted, on 1 February 2009, r 14.12.  Rule 14.12, which is similar to r 48H, provides: 

    14.12   Disbursements

    (1)     In this rule,—

    disbursement, in relation to a proceeding,—

    (a)means an expense paid or incurred for the purposes of the proceeding that would ordinarily be charged for separately from legal professional services in a solicitor’s bill of costs; and

    (b)includes—

    (i)     fees of court for the proceeding:

    (ii)     expenses of serving documents for the purposes of the proceeding:

    (iii)    expenses of photocopying documents required by these rules or by a direction of the court:

    (iv)    expenses of conducting a conference by telephone or video link; but

    (c)does not include counsel’s fee.

    relevant issue, in relation to a…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marsman v Nijkrake and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2009] NZCA 461
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Court of Appeal of New Zealand considered an appeal by Willem Robert Marsman, Uta Bleidistel, and THK Trustees Limited (the appellants) against a decision by Associate Judge Gendall that sustained a caveat. The appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs and "usual disbursements." The respondent sought to have the appellants meet the full amount of invoices rendered by his expert witness, Ms Peters, in connection with the appeal. The appellants argued that there was no longer any jurisdiction to order an unsuccessful party to pay a successful party's expert witness costs as a disbursement, or alternatively, that the amount they should pay with regard to Ms Peters' fees should be reduced. The Court of Appeal addressed the appellants' contention that the repeal of rule 48H of the High Court Rules eradicated the Court's jurisdiction to make an order that a party pay to another party any disbursements covered by rule 53H(2)(a)(i) of the Court of Appeal Rules. The Court held that the repeal of an enactment, including regulations, does not affect an enactment in which the repealed enactment is referred to. Instead, a reference in an enactment to a repealed enactment is a reference to an enactment that replaces or responds to the repealed enactment. Therefore, the Court found that the reference in rule 53H of the Court of Appeal Rules to the repealed rule 48H of the High Court Rules is now a reference to the substituted rule 14.12. The Court concluded that the appellants were liable to pay the usual disbursements as ordered, and that the matter should be referred to the Registrar to fix the amount of the witness fee disbursements in terms of rule 53H(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of Marsman v Nijkrake involves a dispute over the costs of an expert witness in an appeal. The appellants, Willem Robert Marsman, Uta Bleidistel, and THK Trustees Limited, had previously appealed against a decision of Associate Judge Gendall, which was dismissed by the Court of Appeal on 23 February 2009. As part of the dismissal, the appellants were ordered to pay the respondent's costs and "usual disbursements." The respondent, Roland Johannes Nijkrake, is now seeking to recover the full amount of invoices rendered by his expert witness, Ms Peters, in connection with the appeal. These invoices total C$11,824.39 (approximately NZ$18,000). The appellants argue that there is no jurisdiction to order them to pay the successful party's expert witness costs as a disbursement or that the amount they should pay should be reduced.

The matter came before the Court of Appeal of New Zealand as an appeal from a decision of Associate Judge Gendall. The initial appeal was dismissed on 23 February 2009. The respondent subsequently sought to recover the full amount of expert witness fees from the appellants. The appellants contested the respondent's claim, arguing that there was no jurisdiction to order them to pay the expert witness fees as a disbursement. The Court of Appeal addressed this issue and confirmed that the Court had jurisdiction to award usual disbursements, despite the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules. The matter was then referred to the Registrar to fix the amount of the witness fee disbursements in terms of r 53H(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules eradicate the Court's jurisdiction to make an order that a party pay to another party any disbursements covered by r 53H(2)(a)(i) of the Court of Appeal Rules?
2. Should the amount that the appellants should pay with regard to Ms Peters' fees be reduced, and if so, what is the appropriate quantum of the fee?

Held
1. The Court had jurisdiction to award usual disbursements, despite the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules.
2. The matter is referred to the Registrar to fix the amount of the witness fee disbursements in terms of r 53H(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court began by considering the argument put forward by the appellants that the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules eradicated the Court's jurisdiction to make an order that a party pay to another party any disbursements covered by r 53H(2)(a)(i) of the Court of Appeal Rules. The Court rejected this argument, noting that Section 22 of the Interpretation Act 1999 states that the repeal of an enactment does not affect an enactment in which the repealed enactment is referred to. Instead, a reference in an enactment to a repealed enactment is a reference to an enactment that (with or without modification) replaces or responds to the enactment repealed. The Court held that the reference in r 53H of the Court of Appeal Rules to the repealed r 48H of the High Court Rules is now a reference to the substituted r 14.12. Therefore, the Court had jurisdiction to award usual disbursements, despite the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules.
The Court then considered the argument put forward by the appellants that the amount that they should pay with regard to Ms Peters' fees should be reduced. The Court held that the full amount of Ms Peters' fee will be recoverable, provided that it is reasonable and not disproportionate in terms of r 14.12(2)(d) and (3). The Court noted that r 14.12(3) contains an additional safeguard that was not contained in r 48H. This strengthens the argument that any reduction to the actual disbursement cost must be because of one of the factors set out in r 14.12, which, like r 48H, is clear and makes no reference to having to pay a contribution only. The Court therefore referred the matter to the Registrar to fix the amount of the witness fee disbursements in terms of r 53H(2)(b) of the Court of Appeal Rules. The ratio decidendi of this decision is that the repeal of r 48H of the High Court Rules does not eradicate the Court's jurisdiction to make an order that a party pay to another party any disbursements covered by r 53H(2)(a)(i) of the Court of Appeal Rules, and that any reduction to the actual disbursement cost must be because of one of the factors set out in r 14.12.