Marac Finance Ltd v Vero Liability Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-003346 [2013] NZHC 2525

BETWEEN MARAC FINANCE LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 22-24, 26 and 29 April 2013

Appearances:

R J Hollyman and T P Mullins for Plaintiff
C T Walker and Z A Fuhr for Respondent

Judgment:

26 September 2013

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 26 September 2013 at 4.00 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date………………………….

MARAC FINANCE LTD v VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LTD [2013] NZHC 2525 [26 September 2013]

Table of Contents

Para No.

Introduction  [1]

The Policy  [5]

The history of the Rapson account

Lending to motor vehicle dealers  [12]

Lending to Rapson  [15] Mr Atkinson becomes involved  [21] Proposals for restructuring the Floorplan debt  [30]

Did Mr Atkinson act dishonestly in lending to Rapson under the
464768 account?

What is dishonesty in the context of the policy?  [47]

Mr Atkinson’s authority to lend  [51] The 464768 account is established  [54] Lending under the 464768 account  [56] Did Marac know about the lending?  [61] Did Mr Atkinson act dishonestly?  [68]

Did Mr Atkinson act with the clear intent of causing loss to Marac?      [77] The meaning of “clear intent”  [78] The US, Canadian and United Kingdom cases  [83] Which approach should be adopted in New Zealand?  [94] Did Mr Atkinson act dishonestly with the clear intent of causing

Marac loss?  [104]

Did Marac sustain direct financial loss consequent on Mr Atkinson’s
acts of dishonesty?

Direct financial loss consequent on dishonest acts  [110]

The effect of endorsement 4  [112]

Calculation of loss  [122]

Breach of condition 5.9 – failure to appoint an investigative

specialist  [126]

Summary and result  [135]

Introduction

[1]      Between 2003 and 2008 a senior manager employed by Marac Finance Ltd, Grant Atkinson, lent substantial sums to a motor vehicle dealer, Rapson Holdings Ltd.    The  lending  was  effected  through  a  dealer  floorplan  facility  account  (the

464768 account) and letters of credit.   Marac claims that Mr Atkinson was not authorised to make the advances and concealed the existence of the account from its Board.   By the time the account was investigated in January 2010 Rapson owed Marac $4.432m which it could not repay.1

[2]      Marac made a claim under its Crime Insurance policy with Vero Liability Insurance Ltd.  The policy covers direct financial loss consequent on dishonest acts of employees committed with the clear intent of causing loss to Marac.   Vero has refused to indemnify Marac.  It says that the claim does not fall within the operative clause of the policy because Mr Atkinson’s lending is properly characterised as bad business judgment rather than dishonesty and that he did not act with the clear intent of causing loss to Marac.  Further, Vero maintains that Marac cannot prove any loss consequent on acts done by Mr Atkinson after February 2006, which is required by an endorsement to the policy.

[3]      In this proceeding Marac sues Vero for indemnity of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marac Finance Ltd v Vero Liability Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 2525
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Marac Finance Ltd brought an action against Vero Liability Insurance Ltd, seeking indemnity for losses it suffered as a result of dishonest acts of its employee, Mr Atkinson. Vero refused to indemnify Marac on the basis that the claim did not fall within the operative clause of the policy and that Marac could not prove any loss consequent on acts done by Mr Atkinson after February 2006, as required by an endorsement to the policy. Marac also alleged a breach of policy condition 5.9, which requires Vero to appoint an investigative specialist upon notification of a loss. Marac claimed its actual costs in bringing the proceeding as a result of Vero’s failure to appoint an investigator. The court concluded that Marac was entitled to indemnity for losses sustained as a result of Mr Atkinson’s dishonest acts. The court found that Marac did not know about the nature and level of lending to Rapson and was not in a position where it ought to have known. The court found that by at least 2005, Mr Atkinson realised that he had acted beyond his authority. An honest person would have revealed the problem to their superior. Mr Atkinson acted dishonestly by omitting reference to the 464768 account in his meeting notes, omitting reference to the 464768 account in a report that was meant to summarise the Rapson position, directing junior staff to suppress arrears of interest on the account, lying to Marac’s internal auditor about the account, and never mentioning the account to Mr Flood. The court found that intent to cause loss is a question of fact to be inferred from the available evidence, including subjective statements of the employee and circumstantial evidence. The fact that an employee did not desire loss to the employer, whilst a relevant piece of evidence, does not preclude a finding of intent. The evidence showed that the advances made from mid-2005 were made with knowledge that they would cause Marac loss, and intending that outcome. The court found that Marac’s claim therefore fell within the operative clause. The court found that Vero breached its obligation under condition 5.9 to appoint an investigative specialist. This caused Marac loss, being its solicitor/client costs of this proceeding. The court reserved leave to seek a telephone conference to address any other issues that the parties require direction on.