Marac Finance Ltd v Vero Liability Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2011-404-003346 [2014] NZHC 1974

BETWEEN

MARAC FINANCE LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND

VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing: 19 June 2014

Appearances:

R J Hollyman and T P Mullins for Plaintiff
C T Walker for Defendant

Judgment:

20 August 2014

JUDGMENT OF COURTNEY J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Courtney on 20 August 2014 at 3.30 pm

pursuant to R 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar / Deputy Registrar

Date………………………..

MARAC FINANCE LTD v VERO LIABILITY INSURANCE LTD [2014] NZHC 1974 [20 August 2014]

Introduction

[1]      In a previous judgment I held that Marac Finance Ltd had suffered losses from unauthorised lending by one of its senior managers for which it was entitled to be  indemnified  under  the  Commercial  Crime  policy it  held  with Vero  Liability Insurance Ltd.1    In this judgment I determine the quantum of that indemnity.  The issue turns on the effect of an endorsement to the policy that limited indemnity to the period after 8 February 2006.

[2]      There had been unauthorised advances for some time before 8 February 2006 but an endorsement to the policy meant that Vero was only liable to indemnify for losses sustained after 8 February 2006.   However, the borrower repaid more after

8 February 2006 than Marac advanced.  Marac maintains that the repayments made after that date should be treated as repaying the advances outstanding at the start of that period. If that is right the indemnifiable loss will exceed the sum insured of $1m. But Vero contends that the repayments are to be treated as only reducing advances made after 8 February 2006.  If that is right Marac there will not have suffered any indemnifiable loss.

[3]      This issue raises the following questions:

(a)      Did  the  endorsement  require  the  loss  to  be  calculated  only  by reference  to  the  advances  and  repayments  made  after  8  February

2006?

(b)Was the account under which the advances were made operated as a current account to which the rule in Clayton’s case applied or did each advance correspond to a particular repayment?

[4]      There is also an application by Marac for indemnity costs.   In my earlier judgment I held that Vero’s refusal to appoint an investigative specialist was a breach of the policy and  Marac’s  loss  was  its  legal  costs  in  the proceedings.   After  I

delivered my decision I became aware of the line of authority indicating that, in

1      Marac Finance Ltd v Vero Liability Insurance Ltd [2013] NZHC 2525, [2014] 2 NZLR 93.

general, litigation costs are not recoverable as damages.2   I raised this with counsel at the second hearing; the point had not yet been identified by Vero in the notice of appeal already filed in respect of my first judgment.   Mr Hollyman accepted that, ultimately, Marac could not recover its legal costs as damages and indicated that Marac would instead make a claim for indemnity costs under r 14.6 of the High Court Rules.

Has Marac sustained a loss for which…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Marac Finance Ltd v Vero Liability Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 1974
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Marac Finance Ltd, a commercial finance company, sought to recover losses from Vero Liability Insurance Ltd, its insurer, under a Commercial Crime policy. The dispute arose from unauthorised advances made by a senior Marac manager, Grant Atkinson, to a motor vehicle dealer, Rapson Holdings Ltd. The central issue was the calculation of Marac's indemnifiable loss under the policy, particularly in light of an endorsement limiting indemnity for losses sustained more than 48 months before discovery. The court needed to decide whether the endorsement required the loss to be calculated only by reference to the advances and repayments made after a specific date, and whether the account in question operated as a current account, applying the rule in Clayton's case.

The court concluded that the endorsement was an exclusion clause and not a limitation on the basic promise of indemnity. It found that the 464768 account was a revolving credit facility, operating as a current account where repayments were applied against the oldest advances, in line with the rule in Clayton’s case. Consequently, repayments made after 8 February 2006 were treated as reducing the balance that existed at that date, resulting in Marac’s loss exceeding the sum insured of $1 million. Marac was awarded $1.1 million in damages, plus interest at the rate of 5% from the date the proceedings were issued. In terms of costs, Marac was entitled to indemnity costs for the expense of an investigative specialist, as Vero had breached the policy by refusing to appoint one. However, the court found that Marac's refusal to pursue arbitration, despite Vero's breach of the arbitration clause, did not justify indemnity costs. Costs were to be payable on a 2B basis for the liability trial, with specific exceptions for costs related to the quantum trial and certain disbursements.

The final orders included damages of $1.1 million plus interest, costs on a 2B basis for the liability trial and costs memoranda, with specific exceptions for certain disbursements and costs related to the quantum trial. Leave was reserved for further directions if counsel could not agree on necessary calculations.