Maheta v Skybus NZ Limited (formerly Airbus Express Limited)

Link copied
Case Copied 11 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA27/2021
 [2022] NZCA 516

BETWEEN

DHARMENDRA MAHETA
Appellant

AND

SKYBUS NZ LIMITED (FORMERLY AIRBUS EXPRESS LIMITED)
Respondent

Hearing:

30 August 2022

Court:

Cooper P, Miller and Gilbert JJ

Counsel:

L M Hansen for Appellant
A H Waalkens KC and S M Lapthorne for Respondent

Judgment:

2 November 2022 at 2 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is allowed.

B        We answer the questions of law as follows:

(a)       Did the Employment Court err in holding it had no jurisdiction to order a stay of the Employment Relations Authority’s costs determination, as Mr Maheta had applied for?      

Yes, the Employment Court had jurisdiction to order a stay.

(b)Did the Employment Court err in awarding security for costs to the respondent on the basis that Mr Maheta was not in receipt of legal aid?

Yes, as Mr Maheta was in receipt of legal aid.

CThe respondent must pay costs to Mr Maheta for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Gilbert J)

  1. Mr Maheta was employed as a bus driver by Skybus NZ Ltd from December 2017 until 6 September 2018 when he was summarily dismissed following a number of driving incidents. 

  2. On 6 December 2019, the Employment Relations Authority dismissed Mr Maheta’s claim that he had been unjustifiably dismissed.[1]  The Authority also dismissed his claims that he had been unjustifiably disadvantaged in his employment by being issued with a written warning,[2] being demoted,[3] and placed on unpaid suspension.[4]  Costs were reserved.[5]

    [1]Maheta v Airbus Express Ltd [2019] NZERA 698 at [118].

    [2]At [69].

    [3]At [80].

    [4]At [92].

    [5]At [119].

  3. On 18 December 2019, Mr Maheta filed a statement of claim in the Employment Court electing, pursuant to s 179 of the Employment Relations Act 2000 (the Act), to have the matter heard de novo by the Court.  Mr Maheta, who was then unrepresented, filed an affidavit on 30 January 2020 seeking an order staying any orders the Authority “may subsequently make, and in particular in relation to costs”.  He stated that the Authority had reserved costs and Skybus had then applied for an order exceeding $30,000.  He said that he was opposing the application for costs and was not aware of when the Authority would determine it.  He concluded his affidavit by stating:

    If, eventually, I am required to pay costs to [Skybus], then I acknowledge my liability in law to do so and will try to make arrangements to this end.  Until my proceedings are finalised, however, I would be put in a very harsh position financially if I had to pay [Skybus’s] costs in the Authority, especially if these were to be for anything like the very substantial sum exceeding $30,000 asked for by the company.

  4. On 5 February 2020, the Authority issued its costs determination and ordered Mr Maheta to pay costs of $10,000 to Skybus.[6]

    [6]Maheta v Airbus…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Maheta v Skybus NZ Limited (formerly Airbus Express Limited) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] NZCA 516
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Dharmendra Maheta has appealed against a judgment of the Employment Court which dismissed his challenge to a decision of the Employment Relations Authority. The Authority had dismissed Mr Maheta's claims that he had been unjustifiably dismissed and unjustifiably disadvantaged in his employment by being issued with a written warning, demoted, and placed on unpaid suspension. The Authority also ordered Mr Maheta to pay costs of $10,000 to his employer, Skybus NZ Ltd. The Employment Court refused Mr Maheta's application to stay the Authority's costs determination and ordered him to pay security for costs in the sum of $10,000. Mr Maheta appealed to the Court of Appeal on two questions of law.

The Court of Appeal found that the Employment Court had erred in holding it had no jurisdiction to order a stay of the Authority's costs determination. The Court of Appeal held that the Employment Court had jurisdiction to order a stay as Mr Maheta had elected to have the entire matter heard de novo, and the costs award was inevitable. The Court of Appeal also found that the Employment Court had erred in awarding security for costs to Skybus NZ Ltd as Mr Maheta was in receipt of legal aid. The appeal is therefore allowed.

The Court of Appeal orders that Skybus NZ Ltd must pay Mr Maheta's costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Dharmendra Maheta was employed as a bus driver by Skybus NZ Limited (formerly Airbus Express Limited) from December 2017 until he was summarily dismissed on 6 September 2018. Mr Maheta filed a claim with the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) asserting that he was unjustifiably dismissed and unjustifiably disadvantaged by various employment actions. The ERA dismissed all of Mr Maheta's claims on 6 December 2019 and reserved costs. On 5 February 2020, the ERA determined that Mr Maheta should pay $10,000 in costs to Skybus. Mr Maheta filed a statement of claim in the Employment Court on 18 December 2019, electing to have his case heard de novo. He also filed an affidavit on 30 January 2020 seeking a stay of any costs orders pending the outcome of his Employment Court proceedings. On 3 September 2020, Skybus filed a cross-application for security for costs. The Employment Court determined both applications on 18 December 2020, finding it had no jurisdiction to grant a stay and ordering Mr Maheta to pay security for costs in the amount of $10,000.

Mr Maheta filed a claim with the ERA, which dismissed his claims on 6 December 2019. The ERA reserved costs and subsequently determined on 5 February 2020 that Mr Maheta should pay $10,000 in costs to Skybus. On 18 December 2019, Mr Maheta filed a statement of claim in the Employment Court, electing to have his case heard de novo under section 179 of the Employment Relations Act 2000. He also filed an affidavit seeking a stay of any costs orders. Skybus filed a cross-application for security for costs on 3 September 2020. The Employment Court determined both applications on 18 December 2020, finding it had no jurisdiction to grant a stay and ordering Mr Maheta to pay security for costs in the amount of $10,000. Mr Maheta appealed the Employment Court's decision to the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, which allowed the appeal on two questions of law.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the Employment Court err in holding it had no jurisdiction to order a stay of the Employment Relations Authority's costs determination, as Mr Maheta had applied for?
2. Did the Employment Court err in awarding security for costs to the respondent on the basis that Mr Maheta was not in receipt of legal aid?

Held
1. The Employment Court erred in holding it had no jurisdiction to order a stay of the Employment Relations Authority's costs determination, as Mr Maheta had applied for. The Court had jurisdiction to order a stay.
2. The Employment Court erred in awarding security for costs to the respondent on the basis that Mr Maheta was not in receipt of legal aid. Mr Maheta was in receipt of legal aid, so no order for costs could be made against him unless there were exceptional circumstances.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Mr Maheta was employed by Skybus NZ Ltd and was dismissed on 6 September 2018. He filed a claim with the Employment Relations Authority (ERA) which was dismissed on 6 December 2019. Costs were reserved. On 18 December 2019, Mr Maheta filed a statement of claim in the Employment Court and sought a stay of the ERA's costs determination. The ERA issued its costs determination on 5 February 2020, ordering Mr Maheta to pay costs of $10,000 to Skybus. On 18 December 2020, the Employment Court determined Mr Maheta's stay application and Skybus's cross-application for security for costs. The Employment Court held it had no jurisdiction to order a stay and granted Skybus's application for security for costs, ordering Mr Maheta to pay $10,000.

The Court of Appeal allowed Mr Maheta's appeal on two questions of law. First, the Court held that the Employment Court had jurisdiction to order a stay of the ERA's costs determination. Mr Maheta elected to have the entire matter heard de novo by the Employment Court, which included a challenge to the ERA's costs determination. The Court found that it was not necessary for Mr Maheta to make a separate election under s 179 of the Employment Relations Act 2000 in respect of the costs determination. Since the costs award was inevitable and made long before the stay application was determined, it would have been pointless to require a fresh application to be made.

Second, the Court held that the Employment Court erred in awarding security for costs to Skybus on the basis that Mr Maheta was not in receipt of legal aid. Mr Maheta had received a grant of legal aid on an interim basis on 13 November 2020, which continued until the Legal Services Commissioner determined Mr Maheta's application for legal aid for the whole of the proceedings. An "aided person" under the Legal Services Act 2011 is a person who is granted legal aid under the Act, which includes a person who is granted legal aid on an interim basis. Therefore, Mr Maheta was in receipt of legal aid, and no order for costs could be made against him unless there were exceptional circumstances. The Court found that the Employment Court's error in this regard was sufficient to allow the appeal.