Macalister Todd Phillips Bodkins v AMP General Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

For a Court ready (fee required) version please follow this link

IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND

SC 13/2006
[2006] NZSC 105

BETWEENAMP GENERAL INSURANCE LIMITED


Appellant

ANDMACALISTER TODD PHILLIPS BODKINS


First Respondent

ANDGRAEME MORRIS TODD


Second Respondent

Hearing:20 October 2006

Court:Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping, McGrath and Anderson JJ

Counsel:M A Gilbert, S Hunter and N Till for Appellant


E D Wylie QC for Respondents

Judgment:8 December 2006 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A.The appeal is allowed.

B.Judgment is entered for the appellant on the respondents’ claim.

C.No award of costs is made.

REASONS

Para No

Elias CJ, Blanchard, Tipping and McGrath JJ  [1]
Anderson J  [40]

ELIAS CJ, BLANCHARD, TIPPING AND McGRATH JJ

(Given by Blanchard J)

[1]       AMP General Insurance Ltd was the professional indemnity insurer of a law firm, Macalister Todd Phillips Bodkins.  One of the partners, Mr Todd, acted as the legal adviser to the Walker Family Trust.  The trustees were Mr Todd and a member of the family, Mr L P Walker.  The trust carried out several property developments in Central Otago.  In about April 1995 it settled the sales of the units in one of the developments (Towne Place).  It is common ground that at that time Mr Todd negligently failed to advise that the trustees were personally liable under s 57(3) of the Goods and Services Tax Act 1985 for the GST output tax incurred in relation to those sales.

[2]       The GST of $50,486.10 arising from the Towne Place sales was not able to be paid out of the proceeds because there was no surplus after the net purchase moneys were paid to the mortgagee of the property, the Bank of New Zealand.  The bank had priority over the Commissioner of Inland Revenue in relation to the proceeds.[1]

[1]Rob Mitchell Builder Ltd (in liq) v National Bank of New Zealand Ltd (2004) 21 NZTC 18,397 (CA).

[3]       The sales of the trust’s other properties later proved insufficient to enable the trustees to pay this amount and certain other moneys owing by the trust to the Inland Revenue Department for unpaid income tax, PAYE and ACC levies, a total of about $128,000 plus accruing penalties.

[4]       The trustees eventually settled with the IRD for a total amount of $102,000 of which Macalister Todd paid $72,000 on behalf of Mr Todd and Mr Walker paid $30,000.  Because the trust had no remaining assets, the trustees were unable to obtain reimbursement from that source.

[5]       Mr Walker claimed against Mr Todd for the amount he had paid to the IRD.  AMP accepted liability under the insurance policy for his claim and settled with him for $27,000.  But it has refused to indemnify the firm for the payment made to the IRD on behalf of Mr Todd.

[6]       The firm and Mr Todd claimed in this proceeding against AMP that if Mr Todd had appreciated in April 1995, as he should have done, that the trustees were personally liable for GST, and had given the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Macalister Todd Phillips Bodkins v AMP General Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2006] NZSC 105
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerned an appeal by AMP General Insurance Limited against a decision of the Court of Appeal which held that the insurer was liable to indemnify Macalister Todd Phillips Bodkins (the firm) and Graeme Morris Todd (Mr Todd) for a payment made to the Inland Revenue Department (IRD) on behalf of Mr Todd. The appeal was allowed. The central issue in the case was whether the firm was entitled to seek indemnity under the policy for the payment made to the IRD on behalf of Mr Todd. The Supreme Court held that the claim fell within the operative clause of the policy, which provided for indemnity in respect of claims arising out of the conduct of the Professional Services of the Insured for claims made against the Insured arising out of civil liability. The Court rejected AMP's argument that Mr Todd's personal loss arising from his negligence was not covered by the policy because neither he nor the firm could be liable on a claim brought by him for such a loss. The Court held that Mr Todd's negligence created a liability claimable against the partnership, and that it was appropriate to bear the consequences of such negligence through the partnership's insurance arrangements. The Court also held that the claim did not arise from any trading loss or liability of the trust, but rather from Mr Todd's negligent omission to advise the trustees of their personal liability for GST, and thus of the need to act to secure indemnity for that liability from trust assets still under their control. Finally, the Court held that the firm had not shown that the trustees could have rescued their position if Mr Todd had informed them of their personal liability for the Towne Place GST. The Court concluded that AMP had already discharged its obligation under the policy by accepting Mr Walker's claim for reimbursement of GST which was compromised at a figure of $27,000, a sum greater than the loss actually claimable under the policy, resulting from the negligence. Judgment was entered for AMP on the respondents’ claim and no award of costs was made.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.