Lowrie v Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TE WHANGANUI-A-TARA ROHE

CIV-2018-485-212

[2019] NZHC 1030

IN THE MATTER OF a judicial review; Bill of Rights Damages

BETWEEN

PETER EDWIN WILLIAM LOWRIE

Plaintiff

AND

HUTT CITY TE AWA KAIRANGI

Defendant

On papers

Judgment:

10 May 2019


JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J

[Costs]


Introduction

[1]    Following a two day hearing of this judicial review in February 2019, my judgment was delivered on 6 March 2019. Having rejected a number of the important aspects of Mr Lowrie’s factual criticisms against the respondent, Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi (the Council), I found that none of his grounds for judicial review were made out.1

[2]    Although advised that Mr Lowrie was legally aided, I allowed the Council  15 working days from delivery of the judgment to file a memorandum in relation to costs.2 The Council, as the successful party, seeks costs against Mr Lowrie or, in the alternative, an order that costs would have been awarded on a 2B basis but for the fact that Mr Lowrie was legally aided in these proceedings.


1      Lowrie v Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi [2019] NZHC 359.

2 At [80].

LOWRIE v HUTT CITY TE AWA KAIRANGI [2019] NZHC 1030 [10 May 2019]

Relevant law

[3]    Under s 45 of the Legal Services Act 2011 (the Act), an order for costs may not be made against a legally aided person in civil proceedings unless the Court is satisfied that there are exceptional circumstances.3 Section 45(3) of the Act sets out the following non-exhaustive list of exceptional circumstances:

(a)any conduct that causes the other party to incur unnecessary cost:

(b)any failure to comply with the procedural rules and orders of the court:

(c)any misleading or deceitful conduct:

(d)any unreasonable pursuit of 1 or more issues on which the aided person fails:

(e)any unreasonable refusal to negotiate a settlement or participate in alternative dispute resolution:

(f)any other conduct that abuses the processes of the court.

[4]    The test for exceptional circumstances is a broad one. It takes into account the means of all the parties and their conduct and, to qualify, the circumstances must be “quite out of the ordinary”.4 In Reid v Castleton-Reid, it was noted:5

[52]      Subsection 3(d) makes it clear that the issues on which the plaintiff failed must have been such that the legally aided person behaved in an unreasonable fashion. Unreasonable conduct could arise in a number of ways. It might be considered that the plaintiff had acted unreasonably by insisting that a claim be brought in the first place. The court making a decision under s 45(2) would have to try and place itself in the position of the party at the time when the decision was made to initiate or continue a proceeding. Retrospective reasoning based only on the fact that the case turned out to be an unsuccessful one would not be enough on its own to attract the operation of s 45. It…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lowrie v Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] NZHC 1030
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lowrie v Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi, the plaintiff, Peter Edwin William Lowrie, sought a judicial review and damages under the New Zealand Bill of Rights Act against Hutt City Te Awa Kairangi. The plaintiff alleged that the defendant had breached his rights by refusing him entry to the Hutt City Community Centre. The legal issues before the court involved determining whether the plaintiff's conduct constituted exceptional circumstances warranting an order for costs against him, despite his status as a legally aided person. This determination hinged on whether any of the circumstances outlined in section 45(3) of the Legal Services Act 2011 applied.

The court found that there were exceptional circumstances as defined by the Act. The plaintiff's conduct was deemed unreasonable given the significant divergence between his evidence and that of the defendant's witnesses, and the lack of corroboration of his claims. Additionally, the plaintiff admitted during cross-examination that he intended to make the proceedings as costly as possible for the defendant. The court concluded that the plaintiff's use of legal aid should not protect him from the consequences of his conduct, which was considered to be quite out of the ordinary. Despite the plaintiff's limited means, the court ordered him to pay a nominal amount of $500 towards the defendant's costs, calculated on a 2B basis at $29,547.

The court's decision highlighted the importance of balancing the objective of promoting access to justice with the potential misuse of legal aid funding. It underscored that the grant of legal aid does not exempt a party from costs when their conduct is found to be unreasonable and exceptional. The final orders confirmed that while the plaintiff would have been liable for the full costs had section 45 of the Act not applied, his limited means necessitated a nominal personal costs order of $500.