Lewis v Hamilton Cosmopolitan Club Incorporated

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA126/2023
 [2023] NZCA 484

BETWEEN

LISA ROCHELLE LEWIS
Applicant

AND

HAMILTON COSMOPOLITAN CLUB INCORPORATED
Respondent

Court:

French and Brown JJ

Counsel:

F A King for Applicant
T C Tran for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

5 October 2023 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal is declined.

BThe applicant must pay the respondent costs for a standard application on a band A basis and usual disbursements.  This costs order has no effect if the applicant is in receipt of a grant of legal aid for the purposes of this application.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by French J)

Introduction

  1. Ms Lewis obtained a damages award of $10,000 in the District Court against her neighbour, Hamilton Cosmopolitan Club Inc (the Club), for nuisance.[1]  The Club appealed to the High Court.  The appeal was allowed by Brewer J who quashed the judgment in favour of Ms Lewis and upheld the Club’s counterclaim against her for trespass.[2]  The Judge subsequently declined Ms Lewis leave to appeal his decision.[3]

    [1]Lewis v Hamilton Cosmopolitan Club Inc [2022] NZDC 1569 [District Court decision].

  2. Ms Lewis now seeks leave from this Court to bring her proposed appeal under s 60(1) of the Senior Courts Act 2016.  Leave is required because the appeal would be a second appeal.  In order to obtain leave, Ms Lewis must satisfy us that her proposed appeal raises some seriously arguable question of law or fact, of sufficient private or public importance to warrant the cost and delay of a further appeal.[4]

Background

[4]Waller v Hider [1998] 1 NZLR 412 (CA) at 413, citing Rutherfurd v Waite [1923] GLR 34 and Cuff v Broadlands Finance Ltd [1987] 2 NZLR 343 at 346–347.

  1. Since 2013, Ms Lewis has occupied a rental property situated adjacent to the Club’s car park.  The property she rents was previously owned by the Club before being subdivided off and sold to a third party.  Due to various impediments including a lamp post, a power pole and bollards, vehicular access to the property is only possible via the Club’s car park.

  2. The Club had no objection to Ms Lewis accessing her property via the car park until 2017 when her relationship with the Club deteriorated following the appointment of a new manager.  There were numerous incidents, complaints and counter-complaints.  These events culminated in the service of a trespass notice on Ms Lewis in September 2020 and then the erection of a large metal fence preventing her from accessing her property in November 2020.  Police were involved and brokered an agreement that Ms Lewis could access her property via a slightly different route than before but still involving the car park. 

  3. However, the problems continued. 

  4. In December 2020, Ms Lewis filed proceedings in…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lewis v Hamilton Cosmopolitan Club Incorporated and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 484
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lisa Rochelle Lewis applied for leave to appeal the decision of Brewer J, which had dismissed her appeal against the decision of the District Court. The District Court had found that the Hamilton Cosmopolitan Club Inc (the Club) was liable to pay Ms Lewis $10,000 in damages for nuisance, but the High Court had quashed that decision and found the Club's counterclaim for trespass against Ms Lewis was successful. Ms Lewis sought leave to appeal to the Court of Appeal under s 60(1) of the Senior Courts Act 2016, which requires her to demonstrate that her appeal raises a seriously arguable question of law or fact, of sufficient private or public importance to warrant the cost and delay of a further appeal. The Court of Appeal found that Ms Lewis' appeal did not raise any new arguable issues of law or fact that were not considered in the High Court. The Court found that the issue of an equitable easement over the Club's land was a new argument that had not been raised previously, but the Court would not consider new arguments on a second appeal unless there were exceptional circumstances. The Court found that the validity of the trespass notice was not of sufficient public importance to warrant a second appeal. The Court of Appeal declined Ms Lewis' application for leave to appeal and ordered her to pay the Club's costs of the application. The order will not take effect if Ms Lewis is in receipt of a grant of legal aid for the purpose of the application.

The Court of Appeal was not persuaded that Ms Lewis' appeal raised any new arguable issues of law or fact that warranted a second appeal. The Court found that the argument about an equitable easement was a new argument that had not been raised previously, but the Court would not consider new arguments on a second appeal unless there were exceptional circumstances. The Court found that the validity of the trespass notice was not of sufficient public importance to warrant a second appeal. The Court also found that it would not be in the interests of justice for a second appeal to be used as an opportunity to revive an argument that Ms Lewis had deliberately chosen to abandon in the High Court. For all these reasons, the Court of Appeal declined Ms Lewis' application for leave to appeal.

The Court of Appeal ordered Ms Lewis to pay the Club's costs of the application on a band A basis and usual disbursements. The Court made the costs order contingent on Ms Lewis not being in receipt of a grant of legal aid for the purpose of the application. The Court had not been advised that Ms Lewis had been granted legal aid, but her counsel had advised that legal aid had been obtained in the High Court. The Court made the conditional costs order in order to preserve the position.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established