Lee v Gao

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2010-404-3599 [2012] NZHC 3310

BETWEEN  YOON LEE Appellant

ANDZHI JONG GAO AND LIN GE First Respondents

ANDJOHN CARTER, BRENT O'CALLAGHAN AND TIMOTHY UPTON SLACK

Second Respondents

Hearing:         (on the papers) Counsel:  Appellant in person

P J McPherson for First Respondents
A C Challis and K J M Robinson for Second Respondents

Judgment:      7 December 2012

COSTS JUDGMENT OF PETERS J

This judgment was delivered by Justice Peters on 7 December 2012 at 5 pm pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Date: ...................................

Solicitors:

Y Lee, Auckland:  lee1955@gmail.com

Hesketh Henry, Auckland:  patrick.mcpherson@heskethhenry.co.nz

McElroys, Auckland:  andrea.challis@mcelroys.co.nz / karl.robinson@mcelroys.co.nz

LEE V GAO HC AK CIV-2010-404-3599 [7 December 2012]

Introduction

[1]      This decision follows a judgment I gave in May 2011.  My judgment was on appeal from a judgment of Judge Gittos in the District Court at Auckland, given in May 2010.[1]

[1] Gao v Lee & Ors DC Auckland CIV-2007-004-2591, 14 May 2010.

[2]      The case before the District Court was brought by the First Respondents, Zhi Gao and Lin Ge (“Gaos”), against the Appellant (“Mr Lee”).  Mr Lee joined the Second Respondents (“Carter & Partners”) as a party to the District Court proceedings.

[3]      The Gaos’ proceedings  arose out  of an  agreement  for sale and  purchase between the Gaos as purchasers and a third party as vendor.  Mr Lee is a solicitor and he acted for the Gaos on the proposed purchase.  The agreement for sale and purchase did not settle, as the vendor was not able to transfer title.

[4]      Prior to settlement, the Gaos had paid two deposits to the vendor, one of

$27,500 and the other of $137,500, the two deposits totalling $165,000.  The Gaos could not recover these deposits from the vendor.

[5]      The Gaos sued Mr Lee in negligence, claiming as damages the sum of two deposits that they had paid to the vendor.

[6]      Mr Lee denied liability but, if wrong in that, alleged contributory negligence on the part of the Gaos.   Mr Lee also joined the Second Respondents (“Carter & Partners”) as a party to the District Court proceedings.  Carter & Partners acted for the vendor under the agreement.  Mr Lee joined Carter & Partners very late in the piece, alleging that an employee of that firm had given him an oral undertaking not to release the second deposit to their client, the vendor.  Mr Lee’s allegation against

Carter & Partners led the Gaos to join them as Second Defendants.

[7]      Judge Gittos:

(a)       Found that Mr Lee had been negligent and dismissed Mr Lee’s claim

that the Gaos had been contributorily negligent.

(b)      Awarded  damages  of  $165,000  and  interest  to  the  Gaos,  against

Mr Lee.

(c)      Found  on  the  facts  that  Carter  &  Partners  had  not  given  the undertaking that Mr Lee alleged and so dismissed all claims against that firm.

[8]      In a subsequent judgment dated 24 August 2010, Judge Gittos determined matters as to interest and as to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Gao and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 3310
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lee v Gao, the High Court of New Zealand considered an appeal from a District Court judgment. The appellant, Mr. Lee, a solicitor, was sued by the respondents, Zhi Gao and Lin Ge (the "Gaos"), for negligence in handling their real estate purchase agreement. The Gaos claimed damages for two deposits they had made to the vendor which they could not recover. The District Court found Mr. Lee liable for negligence and awarded the Gaos $165,000 in damages plus interest, but dismissed their claim against Carter & Partners, a firm that acted for the vendor. Mr. Lee appealed the District Court's decision on several grounds, including the amount of damages awarded and the refusal to find Carter & Partners liable. The High Court allowed part of Mr. Lee's appeal, reducing the damages to $68,750, and dismissed his appeal against the findings regarding Carter & Partners. The High Court also considered Mr. Lee's application for orders regarding interest on the damages and costs in both the District Court and the High Court.

The High Court addressed the issue of interest on the damages, varying the District Court's order to reflect the reduced amount of damages. The Court also upheld the District Court's orders regarding costs between Mr. Lee and Carter & Partners, rejecting Mr. Lee's contention that the Gaos should contribute to Carter & Partners' costs. In terms of costs between Mr. Lee and the Gaos, the High Court decided not to alter the District Court's order for costs on the application for a stay of proceedings, but varied the order regarding costs in the District Court itself. The Court found that each party had achieved some measure of success, leading to a reduced award of $15,000 in costs and disbursements to the Gaos against Mr. Lee. The Court also noted that it had no jurisdiction to alter an earlier award of costs in the High Court.