Lee v District Court at Auckland

Link copied
Case Copied 6 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF NEW ZEALAND
SC 56/2014
[2014] NZSC 130
BETWEEN

YOON LEE
Applicant

AND

DISTRICT COURT AT AUCKLAND
First Respondent

ZHI HONG GAO AND LIN GE
Second Respondents

JOHN CARTER, BRENT O'CALLAHAN AND TIMOTHY UPTON SLACK
Third Respondents

Court:

McGrath, Arnold and O'Regan JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in person
G J Luen for Second Respondents
A C Challis and K J M Robinson for Third Respondents

Judgment:

24 September 2014

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The application for leave to appeal is dismissed.

BThe applicant must pay the second and third respondents costs on an indemnity basis, plus reasonable disbursements.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

  1. The applicant, Mr Lee, is a solicitor.  In 2005 he acted for the second respondents, Ms Gao and Mr Ge (the Gaos), on their intended purchase of a section in a subdivision from Pro Rata Investments Ltd (Pro Rata).  The third respondents, Carter & Partners (Carters), acted for Pro Rata on the transaction.  The agreement provided that the purchase price was $275,000, a deposit of $27,500 would be paid on signing, a further $137,500 would be paid several months later and the balance would be paid on settlement.  The Gaos had not taken legal advice before signing the agreement and paying the initial deposit, but the agreement was conditional on the Gaos’ solicitor approving its form within three working days.  The Gaos instructed Mr Lee and later went ahead with the contract, paying the additional $137,500 when it fell due. 

  2. Pro Rata did not have title to the section when the agreement was executed.  It had agreed to purchase several sections in the subdivision from a group of companies trading as Coastal Land Developments (Coastal).  In fact, Pro Rata was unable to complete the purchase of the section from Coastal, and Coastal resold it.  The Gaos were unable to obtain the return of any of their deposit from Pro Rata, which had used the funds for other purposes and subsequently went into liquidation.

  3. In January 2007, the Gaos issued proceedings against Mr Lee in negligence seeking to recover the lost deposits.  Mr Lee denied liability and, in the alternative, alleged contributory negligence on the part of the Gaos.  Shortly before trial, Mr Lee joined Carters to the proceedings, alleging that an employee of the firm had given him an oral undertaking that the second deposit would not be released to Pro Rata.   This led the Gaos to bring an alternative claim against Carters as second defendant, alleging breach of the oral undertaking and seeking damages of $137,500.  The Gaos also included a wasted costs claim against Mr Lee for $60,000 in respect of legal fees unnecessarily incurred due to Mr Lee failing to disclose the alleged oral undertaking from Carters.  Ultimately, then, the Gaos brought five causes of action, four against Mr Lee for varying amounts – $165,000, or $137,500 plus general damages; and $60,000 for wasted costs alongside the alternative claim against Carters for $137,500.[1] 

    [1]We have summarised only the claims that are relevant for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v District Court at Auckland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZSC 130
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Lee v District Court at Auckland, Yoon Lee, a solicitor, sought leave to appeal against a decision of the Court of Appeal which had dismissed his appeal against a damages award made in the District Court in a negligence claim brought by Zhi Hong Gao and Lin Ge (the Gaos). The Gaos had engaged Mr Lee to act for them in the purchase of a section in a subdivision from Pro Rata Investments Ltd, but the transaction failed when Pro Rata did not have title to the section. The Gaos brought claims against Mr Lee in negligence and against the firm of Carter & Partners, who acted for Pro Rata, for breach of an alleged oral undertaking. The District Court found Mr Lee negligent and awarded the Gaos $165,000 in damages, a decision upheld on appeal but with the damages reduced to $68,750. Mr Lee’s application for leave to appeal to the Supreme Court was dismissed, with the Court finding that the appeal did not raise any matters of general or public importance. The Gaos and Carter & Partners were awarded indemnity costs.

The primary legal issues before the Court were whether the appeal raised matters of general or public importance sufficient to warrant leave to appeal to the Supreme Court. The first issue was whether the District Court had jurisdiction over the Gaos’ claims, given that the total amount claimed exceeded the $200,000 jurisdictional limit of the District Court. The second issue was whether the Gaos should have pursued their claim against Coastal Land Developments, to whom Pro Rata had assigned its interests, rather than Mr Lee. The third issue was whether the costs awards made against Mr Lee were justified. The Court found that none of these issues raised matters of general or public importance. The Court upheld the findings of the lower Courts on the jurisdictional issue, finding that the Gaos could not succeed on all their claims and that the total amount recoverable was well within the District Court’s jurisdictional limit. The Court also found that the issues regarding the assignment and costs did not raise any matters of general or public importance and that the costs awards were justified.

Background

Background to the litigation

Yoon Lee, a solicitor, acted for Zhi Hong Gao and Lin Ge (the Gaos) in 2005 for their intended purchase of a section in a subdivision from Pro Rata Investments Ltd. The agreement stipulated a purchase price of $275,000, with a deposit of $27,500 upon signing, a further $137,500 several months later, and the balance on settlement. Pro Rata did not have title to the section at the time of agreement execution, as it had agreed to purchase several sections from Coastal Land Developments. Pro Rata ultimately failed to purchase the section from Coastal, who resold it, and the Gaos lost their deposit. In January 2007, the Gaos initiated proceedings against Lee in negligence for the lost deposit, also alleging contributory negligence. They further alleged that Lee failed to disclose an oral undertaking from Carter & Partners, Pro Rata's solicitors, that the second deposit would not be released to Pro Rata. The Gaos sought to recover their lost deposits and additional costs from Lee and also brought an alternative claim against Carter & Partners for breach of the alleged oral undertaking. The Gaos were successful in the District Court against Lee, but Lee's appeal to the High Court resulted in a reduction of damages and costs.

The case began with proceedings initiated by the Gaos against Lee in the District Court in 2007. The District Court found Lee negligent and awarded damages of $165,000 and costs of $44,965.61. Lee appealed to the High Court, which reduced the damages to $68,750 and costs to $15,000. Further appeals by Lee to both the High Court and the Court of Appeal were dismissed, as was an application for judicial review of the District Court decision. Lee now seeks leave to appeal to the Supreme Court of New Zealand.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Was the District Court's decision made without jurisdiction as the Gaos' various claims exceeded $200,000 in total, which is the monetary limit of the District Court's jurisdiction?
2. Should the Gaos have claimed against Coastal rather than Lee as a result of a deed of assignment between Pro Rata and Coastal?
3. Were the costs award against Lee in respect of the District Court hearing and the award of indemnity costs made against him in the High Court on the judicial review application unjustified?

Held
1. The application for leave to appeal was dismissed by the court, as it was not considered necessary in the interests of justice to hear and determine the appeal. The court was not satisfied that the grounds raised by the applicant, Mr Lee, involved matters of general or public importance, or that there was a risk of a substantial miscarriage of justice.
2. The court did not need to address the issue of whether the District Court's decision was made without jurisdiction as the Gaos' claims exceeded the monetary limit of the District Court's jurisdiction. The court concluded that it was clear that the Gaos' claims were within the District Court's jurisdiction.
3. The court did not need to address the issue of whether the Gaos should have claimed against Coastal rather than Mr Lee as a result of a deed of assignment between Pro Rata and Coastal. The court concluded that this issue did not raise any matter of general or public importance.
4. The court upheld the costs awards against Mr Lee in respect of the District Court hearing and the award of indemnity costs made against him in the High Court on the judicial review application. The court agreed with the Courts below that costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, as the challenge by way of judicial review proceedings was a collateral challenge to the earlier decisions of the Courts, and was meritless and vexatious.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Supreme Court of New Zealand dismissed the application for leave to appeal by Mr Lee, finding that it was not necessary in the interests of justice to hear and determine the appeal. The court examined the grounds raised by Mr Lee, including the jurisdictional issue, the issue of whether the Gaos should have claimed against Coastal rather than Mr Lee, and the costs awards. The court concluded that none of the grounds raised matters of general or public importance, or involved a risk of a substantial miscarriage of justice. With regard to the jurisdictional issue, the court found that the Gaos' claims were within the District Court's jurisdiction, as the total amount they could have been awarded was within the $200,000 limit. The court also found that the issue of whether the Gaos should have claimed against Coastal rather than Mr Lee did not raise any matter of general or public importance. Lastly, the court upheld the costs awards against Mr Lee, agreeing with the Courts below that the costs should be awarded on an indemnity basis, as the challenge by way of judicial review proceedings was a collateral challenge to the earlier decisions of the Courts, and was meritless and vexatious. The ratio decidendi of this case is that the Supreme Court will not hear an appeal if it is not necessary in the interests of justice to do so, and that the costs awards against Mr Lee were justified.