Lee v Composite Cladding and Signage Manufacture and Installations Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY

CIV-2012-404-5491 [2013] NZHC 354

UNDER  s 72 of the District Court Act 1947

IN THE MATTER OF     an appeal from the decision of the District

Court dated 16 August 2012

BETWEEN  OLIVIA LEE Appellant

ANDCOMPOSITE CLADDING AND SIGNAGE MANUFACTURE AND INSTALLATIONS LIMITED Respondent

Hearing:         18-20 February 2013

Counsel:         G J Beresford and A Gormack for the Appellant

D L Marriott and R G Espie for the Respondent

Judgment:      28 February 2013

JUDGMENT OF WOODHOUSE J

This judgment was delivered by me on 28 February 2013 at 3:00 p.m. pursuant to r 11.5 of the High Court Rules 1985.

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

……………………………………

Counsel / Solicitors:

Mr G J Beresford and Mr A Gormack, Grimshaws, Solicitors, Auckland
Mr D L Marriott, Barrister, Auckland

Mr R G Espie, Solicitor, Whangaparaoa

LEE V COMPOSITE CLADDING AND SIGNAGE MANUFACTURE AND INSTALLATIONS LIMITED HC AK CIV-2012-404-5491 [28 February 2013]

[1]      In 2007-2008 the appellant, Ms Lee, had a house built for herself and her family at Ruakaka.  The external walls are clad in aluminium panels which are fixed to what is called pre-cladding.   The pre-cladding for Ms Lee’s house is plywood fixed to timber framing.  The cladding was installed by the respondent, to whom I will refer as CCS.   CCS also manufactured the individual aluminium panels by cutting them to appropriate dimensions and folding them.  The aluminium itself was supplied to CCS by Ms Lee who had purchased aluminium sheets from a manufacturer in China.

[2]      In proceedings in the District Court Ms Lee claimed that CCS had carried out its work in breach of various obligations owed to her, that these breaches required the complete recladding of the house, together with other remedial work, and she was entitled to damages in excess of $520,000.

[3]      By judgment dated 16 August 2012 Ms Lee’s claim was dismissed.[1]   Ms Lee appeals against that judgment.

The issues

[1] Composite Cladding and Signage Manufacture and Installations Ltd v Lee DC Auckland CIV-2008-

088-000562, 16 August 2012.

[4]      In her District Court claim Ms Lee alleged 21 different “defects” in the work carried out by CCS.  The hearing in the District Court took eight days.  A total of 28 grounds of appeal were advanced in the notice of appeal.  Although these matters, and the written submissions on appeal, indicated that a large number of issues might require consideration, I was materially assisted by the oral submissions of Mr Beresford for Ms Lee in which a small number of issues were identified as the central issues.

[5]      The pivotal issue is whether Ms Lee established her primary contention that CCS is liable for the cost of removing all of the aluminium cladding, the cost of manufacturing  and  reinstalling  new  cladding,  and  various  associated  costs.    If

liability for the cost of complete recladding is not established on the evidence Ms

Lee cannot succeed to  any lesser extent.   This is because there is no evidence enabling a conclusion as to the cost of any…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lee v Composite Cladding and Signage Manufacture and Install... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 354
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, Ms Lee, the appellant, sought to appeal a decision from the District Court dismissing her claim against the respondent, Composite Clading and Signage Manufacture and Installations Ltd (CCS). Ms Lee alleged that CCS had carried out its work in breach of various obligations owed to her, resulting in her house being defective and requiring extensive remedial work, including complete recladding, along with other remedial works. She sought damages in excess of $520,000. CCS argued that they were not liable for the cost of complete recladding and other remedial work. The pivotal issue was whether CCS was liable for the cost of removing all of the aluminium cladding, the cost of manufacturing and reinstalling new cladding, and various associated costs. The High Court was assisted by the oral submissions of Mr Beresford for Ms Lee, who identified a small number of issues as central. One such issue was defect Q, which concerns the use of plywood packers by CCS. If CCS was not liable for using plywood packers, Ms Lee's contention that CCS was liable for complete recladding would not be made out. The Court concluded that CCS was not liable for using plywood packers as they were approved by the District Council, there was no design fault on the part of CCS, and it was not established that plywood packers resulted in moisture getting into the framing of the house. Additionally, even if there were breaches by CCS, Ms Lee failed to establish any cost associated with the relatively minor work required to rectify the defective work on the part of CCS. The Court also found that it was not appropriate to provide Ms Lee with an opportunity to adduce further evidence of quantum related to the limited liability of CCS or in some other way rectify the failure to prove damages. The appeal was dismissed, and the respondent was entitled to costs.