Krishnayya v Forest Owner Marketing Services Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2011-441-000017 [2013] NZHC 514

BETWEEN  GORINOORI RAMA KRISHNAYYA Plaintiff

ANDFOREST OWNER MARKETING SERVICES LIMITED

Defendant

Hearing:         25-28 February 2013

Counsel:         J G Krebs for Plaintiff

T J Castle and T A Castle for Defendant

Judgment:      18 March 2013

In accordance with r 11.5 I direct the Registrar to endorse this judgment with the delivery time of 4.45pm on the 18th day of March 2013.

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... [1] Breach of contract .......................................................................................................................... [6] Misrepresentation ........................................................................................................................... [7]

Fair Trading Act 1986 .................................................................................................................. [10] Counterclaim ................................................................................................................................ [13] Issues ................................................................................................................................................ [14] Preliminary matters ........................................................................................................................ [16] Economic risks associated with harvesting and marketing pine forests in New Zealand ......... [17] General assessment of key witnesses ............................................................................................. [21] Narrative .......................................................................................................................................... [33] Background................................................................................................................................... [33] Events leading to the contract ...................................................................................................... [35] The contract ..................................................................................................................................... [50] Clause 3 Standard of Care............................................................................................................ [51] Clause 6 Manager’s Obligations .................................................................................................. [52] Clause 11 Term and Termination .................................................................................................. [53]

Was Dr Krishnayya induced to enter into the contract because of misrepresentations made by

FOMS about the returns he could expect to return from his forest? .......................................... [55]

What did FOMS tell Dr Krishnayya about anticipated returns? .................................................. [61]

Was Dr Krishnayya misled by FOMS’ representations?............................................................... [68] What did FOMS intend? ............................................................................................................... [71] Events leading up to the commencement of harvesting ............................................................... [75]

KRISHNAYYA V FOREST OWNER MARKETING SERVICES LIMITED HC NAP CIV-2011-441-000017 [18

March 2013]

Advice to Dr Krishnayya’s financiers ........................................................................................... [76] Advances to Dr Krishnayya .......................................................................................................... [78] TPT Reports.................................................................................................................................. [82] Preparing for harvesting .............................................................................................................. [83] Did FOMS prepare an appropriate harvesting and marketing plan? ........................................ [91] Assessment of work necessary to harvest and market the forest................................................... [94] Estimates of the quantities and grades of logs that would be yielded .......................................... [95] Anticipated markets ...................................................................................................................... [98] Estimates of production costs and returns .................................................................................... [99] Health and safety policy ............................................................................................................. [102] Harvesting and marketing by FOMS .......................................................................................... [104] Overview..................................................................................................................................... [104] Logging crews ............................................................................................................................ [105] Did FOMS fail to ensure appropriate roads were constructed? ............................................... [107]

Did FOMS breach the contract by using gravel/rocks from Dr Krishnayya’s property to repair

a neighbour’s road? .......................................................................................................................[112] Felling and removing of native trees .............................................................................................[116]
Did FOMS leave unacceptable quantities of slash in water courses? ....................................... [124] Did FOMS harvest the forest in a haphazard and inefficient way? .......................................... [129] Did FOMS fail to report to Dr Krishnayya in a timely and meaningful way? ........................ [134]

(i)      What reports did Dr Krishnayya receive? ........................................................................ [136]

(ii)     What information did Dr Krishnayya receive? ................................................................. [140]

Events leading to cancellation of the contract ............................................................................ [146]

Cancellation of the contract ....................................................................................................... [147]

No basis for cancelling contract ................................................................................................... [153] Fair Trading Act 1986 ................................................................................................................... [154] Counterclaim ................................................................................................................................. [157] Conclusions .................................................................................................................................... [158] Costs ............................................................................................................................................... [163]

Introduction

[1]      Dr Krishnayya owns a forestry block at Te Haroto which is approximately halfway between Napier and Taupo.  Forest Owner Marketing Services Ltd (FOMS) is a forestry harvesting and marketing company.

[2]      In  January  2009  Dr  Krishnayya  and  FOMS…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Krishnayya v Forest Owner Marketing Services Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 514
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The plaintiff, Dr Krishnayya, brought an action against the defendant, Forest Owner Marketing Services Limited (FOMS), for breach of contract, misrepresentation and breaches of the Fair Trading Act 1986. FOMS counterclaimed for the sums it lost as a result of Dr Krishnayya cancelling the contract. FOMS was engaged by Dr Krishnayya to harvest and market pine trees growing on his forestry block. The contract was cancelled by Dr Krishnayya in January 2010. FOMS was subsequently engaged by another company, Forest Management Limited (FML), to complete the harvesting and marketing of Dr Krishnayya’s forest. FOMS sought an order that Dr Krishnayya pay it $91,742.04 for the losses it suffered as a result of Dr Krishnayya cancelling the contract. Dr Krishnayya reduced his claim for damages from $710,934.72 to $293,626. The Court held that Dr Krishnayya was not induced to enter into the contract because of misrepresentations made by FOMS about the returns he could expect to return from his forest. The Court found that FOMS did not breach the contract in any material way. The Court also held that Dr Krishnayya had no valid reason to cancel the contract. The Court found that FOMS did not mislead or deceive Dr Krishnayya into continuing to harvest and market his forest. The Court concluded that FOMS’ counterclaim succeeded. FOMS was awarded costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.