IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA TĀMAKI MAKAURAU ROHE
CIV-2018-404-2541
[2019] NZHC 752
IN THE MATTER OF the liquidation of KELSTWORURAL LIMITED (In Liquidation ) BETWEEN
KELSTWORURAL LIMITED
(In Liquidation) First Plaintiff
MALCOLM GRANT HOLLIS and CRAIG ALEXANDER SANSON,
Liquidators Second Plaintiffs
AND
KELLY MICHELLE MOUNSEY-ROSS
First Defendant
KELLY WILLIAM ROSS
Second Defendant
Hearing: 9 April 2019 at 10:00am Appearances:
S Farnell and K Morrison for the Plaintiffs Deep Purusram for the Defendants
Judgment:
9 April 2019
ORAL JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE R M BELL
Solicitors:
Meredith Connell (Kathleen Morrison/Sarah Farnell), Auckland, for the Plaintiffs Victorian Lawyers (Deep Purusram), Papakura, Auckland, for the Defendants
KELSTWORURAL LIMITED (In Liquidation) v MOUNSEY-ROSS [2019] NZHC 752 [9 April 2019]
[1] Kelstworural Ltd ran the Red Fox Tavern at Maramarua. The company was put into liquidation on 13 July 2018 on the application of the Commissioner of Inland Revenue. The second plaintiffs are the liquidators of the company.
[2] There are two claims in this proceeding. The company sues the defendants, the directors of the company, for $326,219.86 as money owing under their joint current account. The second cause of action is a claim for breach of directors’ duties brought under s 301 of the Companies Act 1993. The company is the plaintiff for the first cause of action. The liquidators are the plaintiffs for the second cause of action. The company applies for summary judgment for its cause of action. There is no application for summary judgment on the second cause of action.
[3] The principles on which plaintiffs’ summary judgment applications are decided are now well settled. The Court of Appeal re-stated them in Krukziener v Hanover Finance Ltd:1
[26] The principles are well settled. The question on a summary judgment application is whether the defendant has no defence to the claim; that is, that there is no real question to be tried. … The Court must be left without any real doubt or uncertainty. The onus is on the plaintiff, but where its evidence is sufficient to show there is no defence, the defendant will have to respond if the application is to be defeated. … The Court will not normally resolve material conflicts of evidence or assess the credibility of deponents. But it need not accept uncritically evidence that is inherently lacking in credibility, as for example where the evidence is inconsistent with undisputed contemporary documents or other statements by the same deponent, or is inherently improbable: … In the end the Court’s assessment of the evidence is a matter of judgment. The Court may take a robust and realistic approach where the facts warrant it. …
[27] Under r 141A, the defendant need not file a statement of defence. The onus remains on the plaintiff, and summary judgment will be denied if on the hearing of the application it appears that there is an issue worthy of trial.
(Citations omitted)
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Kelstworural Ltd (In liq) v Mounsey-Ross and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2019] NZHC 752
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court's task was to determine whether the defendants had any defence to the claim for the money owed under the joint current account, thereby justifying the granting of summary judgment. The principles governing summary judgment applications were reiterated, emphasising that the court must be left with no real doubt or uncertainty about the absence of a defence. The onus is on the plaintiff to demonstrate that there is no defence, though the court may not resolve material conflicts of evidence or assess the credibility of deponents, unless the evidence is inherently lacking in credibility. The court must consider the evidence realistically and robustly where the facts warrant it.
The liquidators presented financial statements showing that the defendants' drawings from the company, along with interest charged on their account, exceeded the funds they had contributed to the company, resulting in an indebtedness of $326,219.86 as of March 2017. Despite the defendants' general denials and assertions that the claimed amount was exaggerated, they failed to provide any specific evidence challenging the accuracy of the financial statements. The court found that the financial statements, signed by the defendants and prepared by professional accountants, were reliable and sufficient to meet the summary judgment standard. Consequently, the court granted summary judgment in favour of the company against both defendants for the amount of $326,219.86, with interest accruing from the date of the demand for repayment.
The liquidators were awarded costs under the District Court scale for the claim on which summary judgment was granted, while the court instructed the liquidators to confer with counsel regarding the calculation of those costs. The liquidators were also directed to consider whether to pursue the second claim for breach of directors’ duties and to notify the court if they wished to proceed with that claim. If they did, the matter would be listed on a companies’ liquidation day before an associate judge.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi