Jabbara v Southern Cross Benefits Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA194/2023
 [2023] NZCA 401

BETWEEN

STEWAR SINGH JABBARA
Applicant

AND

SOUTHERN CROSS BENEFITS LIMITED
Respondent

Court:

Gilbert and Goddard JJ

Counsel:

Applicant in person
C M Brick and T L Utama for Respondent

Judgment:
(On the papers)

28 August 2023 at 9.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe application for leave to appeal is declined.

BThere is no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Goddard J)

Background

  1. This application arises out of a proceeding that Mr Jabbara filed in the District Court against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd (Southern Cross), claiming an indemnity under a travel insurance policy issued by Southern Cross. 

  2. Mr Jabbara lives in India.  He purchased travel insurance from Southern Cross for a holiday visit to New Zealand.  While he was in New Zealand he underwent heart bypass surgery in Auckland.  He claimed some $105,000 from Southern Cross by way of indemnity for the costs of that surgery.  Southern Cross declined to indemnify Mr Jabbara.  Southern Cross says that cover for the surgery is precluded or limited by an exclusion clause and a stand-down limit in the Southern Cross standard policy terms.  Mr Jabbara’s position is that these clauses were not disclosed to him prior to purchasing the policy, and do not apply to him.

  3. Ms Khanna is Mr Jabbara’s daughter.  She lives in New Zealand.  On behalf of her father, for whom she holds a power of attorney, she prepared various documents and participated in case management hearings before the District Court. 

  4. It appears that the question of whether Ms Khanna was entitled to appear in court on behalf of Mr Jabbara arose at a case management conference before Judge D J Clark on 19 October 2022.  Judge Clark issued a minute dated 19 October 2022 recording (among other matters) that Mr Jabbara/Ms Khanna would need to file an application for leave for Ms Khanna to appear on Mr Jabbara’s behalf.

  5. Any such application would fall to be decided under s 107 of the District Court Act 2016, which provides:

    107     Right to appear

    (1)A natural person who is a party to a proceeding in the court may—

    (a)appear and act for himself or herself; or

    (b)be represented by a lawyer.

    (2)A corporation may—

    (a)appear and act through any officer or attorney of the corporation; or

    (b)be represented by a lawyer.

    (3)In special circumstances and with the permission of the court, a person (P), whether a natural person or a corporation, may be represented—

    (a)by an agent authorised in writing by P, if P is in New Zealand or carries on business in New Zealand; or

    (b)if P is not in New Zealand or does not carry on business in New Zealand, by an agent authorised by a person holding P’s power of attorney to become a party to the proceeding in P’s name.

    (4)An agent who represents a person under subsection (3) is not entitled…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jabbara v Southern Cross Benefits Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 401
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In Jabbara v Southern Cross Benefits Limited, the applicant, Stewart Singh Jabbara, sought to appeal against a decision by Lang J in the High Court, which dealt with the issue of representation in a proceeding concerning a travel insurance claim. The primary dispute was whether Ms Khanna, the applicant's daughter and attorney, could represent him in the High Court proceedings. Southern Cross Benefits Limited opposed the application on the basis that the High Court does not permit representation by agents, unlike the District Court under section 107 of the District Court Act 2016.

The legal issues before the Court of Appeal were twofold. Firstly, whether there was a decision by Lang J in the High Court that could be appealed. Secondly, whether section 107 of the District Court Act applied to the High Court, permitting representation by an agent. The Court of Appeal found that Lang J had not made a final decision on the issue of representation, deferring the decision to the judge presiding over the hearing on 23 March 2023. Additionally, the Court held that section 107 of the District Court Act only applies to the District Court and not to the High Court, thereby rejecting the applicant's argument.

The Court of Appeal concluded that the application for leave to appeal was misconceived as there was no appealable decision by Lang J, and the statutory provision cited by the applicant did not apply to the High Court. Furthermore, the Court noted that Southern Cross had incurred costs in responding to the application, but decided against awarding costs given the minimal costs and the absence of a request from Southern Cross. The Court of Appeal dismissed the application for leave to appeal, with no order as to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Stewart Singh Jabbara, residing in India, filed a claim in the District Court against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd for an indemnity under a travel insurance policy. While visiting New Zealand, Jabbara underwent heart bypass surgery in Auckland and claimed approximately $105,000 from Southern Cross for the surgery costs. Southern Cross declined the claim, asserting that the surgery was precluded or limited by exclusion clauses and a stand-down limit in the policy terms. Jabbara argued that these clauses were not disclosed to him before purchasing the policy and should not apply to him. Jabbara's daughter, Ms Khanna, who holds a power of attorney for him, participated in case management hearings on his behalf in the District Court. An issue arose regarding Ms Khanna's entitlement to represent Jabbara in court, leading to an application for permission, which was not pursued. Instead, Jabbara applied to transfer the proceedings to the High Court. In a minute dated 16 February 2023, Lang J allocated a fixture for the transfer application and noted that Jabbara would need to attend the hearing personally or be represented by a lawyer, as agents are not permitted in the High Court. Jabbara then applied to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal against Lang J's minute.

The application for leave to appeal arose from a proceeding initially filed by Jabbara in the District Court against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd. The matter was later transferred to the High Court, where an application was made to transfer the proceedings to the High Court. The High Court judge, Lang J, issued a minute on 16 February 2023 addressing the issue of representation and noting that agents are not permitted in the High Court. Jabbara then applied to the Court of Appeal for leave to appeal against Lang J's minute. The Court of Appeal heard the application on the papers and delivered its judgment on 28 August 2023.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the Court of Appeal should grant leave to appeal against the decision in Lang J's minute of 16 February 2023.
2. Whether the provisions of s 107 of the District Court Act 2016 apply to the High Court.

Held
1. The Court of Appeal declined the application for leave to appeal against the decision in Lang J's minute of 16 February 2023.
2. The Court of Appeal found that the provisions of s 107 of the District Court Act 2016 do not apply to the High Court.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered that there was no decision by Lang J in the minute of 16 February 2023 to appeal against. Lang J had clearly stated in subsequent minutes that the question of whether Ms Khanna could represent Mr Jabbara was to be determined by the judge presiding at the hearing of the transfer application on 23 March 2023. Therefore, no final decision was made in the 16 February minute that could be the subject of an appeal. Furthermore, the Court of Appeal held that s 107 of the District Court Act 2016 applies only to hearings before the District Court, and not to the High Court. The Court noted that there are limited circumstances in which a superior court may exercise discretion to allow an unqualified advocate to appear before it, but this was not one of those circumstances given the nature of the proceeding. The Court concluded that the application for leave to appeal was misconceived and declined the application without awarding costs.