Jabbara v Southern Cross Benefits Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 26 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA193/2023
 [2024] NZCA 370

BETWEEN

STEWAR SINGH JABBARA
Appellant

AND

SOUTHERN CROSS BENEFITS LIMITED
Respondent

Hearing:

13 May 2024

Court:

Thomas, Fitzgerald and Osborne JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in person
T L U Utama for Respondent

Judgment:

5 August 2024 at 3.30 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

B    The appellant must pay the respondent’s costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis and usual disbursements. 

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Fitzgerald J)

Introduction

  1. In late 2021, Mr Stewar Singh Jabbara, a retiree residing in India, commenced proceedings in the District Court against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd (Southern Cross) seeking $105,000 in damages.  This followed Southern Cross declining to indemnify Mr Jabbara under an insurance policy he took out with the company for costs associated with heart surgery he underwent in December 2020, while he was visiting New Zealand.

  2. In November 2022, Mr Jabbara filed an application in the High Court, seeking the transfer of his proceedings from the District Court to the High Court.  Jagose J declined that application.[1]  Mr Jabbara, who has represented himself throughout the proceedings, now appeals against Jagose J’s decision.

Background to the appeal

The policy and each party’s position in the proceedings

  1. Mr Jabbara, who was in New Zealand visiting family members, took out a health insurance policy with Southern Cross on the morning of 17 December 2020.  Later that day, he was admitted to Auckland City Hospital requiring urgent treatment for triple artery (coronary) disease.  He was subsequently invoiced approximately $116,000 for the treatment he received, of which $105,000 remains outstanding.  This is the amount claimed against Southern Cross in the underlying proceedings.

  2. Mr Jabbara says that the costs of his treatment are covered by the insurance policy he took out with Southern Cross.  He argues that the exclusion clauses upon which Southern Cross relies in declining his claim are not enforceable against him, as they were not disclosed to him prior to purchasing the policy online.   

  3. Southern Cross says that it was entitled to decline Mr Jabbara’s claim under the policy, referring in particular to two exclusion clauses:

    (a)First, that Mr Jabbara’s treatment was required because of a pre‑existing medical condition, and thus the costs associated with his treatment are excluded by the policy wording.  At the time he took out the policy, Mr Jabbara had a medical history and/or symptoms which indicated he may have a coronary medical condition and, in the months prior to taking out the policy, he had been seeking and receiving medical treatment for that condition.

    (b)Second, even if Mr Jabbara’s claim was not excluded by the pre‑existing medical condition exclusion, its liability to Mr Jabbara is limited to $5,000.  The policy provides that, if the insured is over 65 years old (as Mr Jabbara is), and an “Unexpected Event” (as defined in the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jabbara v Southern Cross Benefits Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NZCA 370
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Stewar Singh Jabbara, a retiree residing in India, commenced proceedings in the District Court against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd (Southern Cross) seeking $105,000 in damages. The claim followed Southern Cross declining to indemnify Mr Jabbara under an insurance policy he took out with the company for costs associated with heart surgery he underwent in December 2020, while he was visiting New Zealand. In November 2022, Mr Jabbara filed an application in the High Court, seeking the transfer of his proceedings from the District Court to the High Court. Jagose J declined that application. Mr Jabbara now appeals against Jagose J’s decision.

The appeal raised a number of issues, including whether the Court of Appeal should approach the appeal in the manner suggested by Southern Cross, and whether the appeal proceeded by way of an appeal against the exercise of a discretion. The appeal also raised issues as to whether the Judge erred in his assessment of the statutory factors to be considered pursuant to s 89 of the District Court Act, and whether the Judge erred in failing to take into account any further matters arising from Mr Jabbara’s grounds of appeal and written submissions.

The Court of Appeal approached the appeal by reference to the statutory factors to be considered pursuant to s 89 of the District Court Act, and then with reference to any further matters arising from Mr Jabbara’s grounds of appeal and written submissions. As to the statutory factors, the Court of Appeal considered that there was nothing in the underlying nature of the case which suggested it ought to be heard in the High Court rather than in the District Court. The Court of Appeal also did not consider the Judge erred in his assessment of the complexity of the case, the general or public importance of the case, the amount in issue, the likely length of the hearing, or the financial resources of the parties. The Court of Appeal also considered that the Judge was right to conclude that it was not otherwise in the interests of justice to make the order. The Court of Appeal considered that Mr Jabbara’s concerns as to what he characterised as “procedural unfairness” in the District Court fell to be considered under this factor, and concluded that there was no procedural unfairness. Further, the Court of Appeal considered that transfer to the High Court was not likely to be a step that would bring about procedural clarity and speed.

Accordingly, the appeal was dismissed. The appellant must pay the respondent’s costs for a standard appeal on a band A basis, together with usual disbursements.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Stewar Singh Jabbara, a retiree residing in India, commenced proceedings against Southern Cross Benefits Ltd (Southern Cross) in the District Court seeking $105,000 in damages. The claim arose after Southern Cross declined to indemnify Mr Jabbara under an insurance policy he took out with the company for costs associated with heart surgery he underwent in December 2020 while visiting New Zealand. Mr Jabbara argued that the exclusion clauses upon which Southern Cross relied in declining his claim were not disclosed to him prior to purchasing the policy online. Southern Cross maintained that the exclusion clauses formed part of the binding contract between it and Mr Jabbara and were available on its website at the time the policy was purchased. Mr Jabbara subsequently filed an application in the High Court seeking the transfer of his proceedings from the District Court to the High Court. This application was declined by Jagose J. Mr Jabbara now appeals against Jagose J’s decision.

Mr Jabbara commenced his proceedings in the District Court in late 2021. Southern Cross filed its statement of defence in May 2022. Following a series of case management conferences, Mr Jabbara filed a substantive application for summary judgment and a second amended statement of claim in November 2022. Southern Cross objected to the application for summary judgment and did not file a statement of defence to the second amended statement of claim. Mr Jabbara then filed an interlocutory application in the High Court seeking the transfer of his proceedings from the District Court to the High Court. This application was declined by Lang J. Mr Jabbara now appeals against Lang J’s decision.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the appeal is properly before the Court and if the Court should allow the appeal on the basis that the Judge made an error of law or principle.
2. Whether the Judge erred in failing to recognise the potential precedent value of the case.
3. Whether the Judge failed to acknowledge the complexity of the case, especially with regard to the interpretation of s 11 of the Insurance Law Reform Act 1977.
4. Whether the Judge overlooked the procedural unfairness experienced by Mr Jabbara, arising from the procedural inconsistencies in the District Court.
5. Whether the Judge erred in not considering the likelihood of an appeal from the District Court.
6. Whether the Judge misapplied or neglected the considerations set out in Kensington Developments Ltd (in rec) v Commissioner of Inland Revenue, which is relevant to removal applications.
7. Whether the Judge erred in “fully grasping or applying the tenets related to the formation of online contracts”.
8. Whether the Judge failed to address the broader public interest of the case, and in particular “how large insurance entities interact with individual policyholders and nuances of online contractual agreements”.

Held
1. Whether the appeal is properly before the Court and if the Court should allow the appeal on the basis that the Judge made an error of law or principle.
The Court found that the appeal is properly before the Court but dismissed the appeal as it was not made out that the Judge made an error of law or principle.

2. Whether the Judge erred in failing to recognise the potential precedent value of the case.
The Court found that the Judge did not err in failing to recognise the potential precedent value of the case.

3. Whether the Judge failed to acknowledge the complexity of the case, especially with regard to the interpretation of s 11 of the Insurance Law Reform Act 1977.
The Court found that the Judge did not err in his assessment of the complexity of the case.

4. Whether the Judge overlooked the procedural unfairness experienced by Mr Jabbara, arising from the procedural inconsistencies in the District Court.
The Court found that the Judge did not overlook any procedural unfairness experienced by Mr Jabbara.

5. Whether the Judge erred in not considering the likelihood of an appeal from the District Court.
The Court found that the likelihood of an appeal was not a material factor in deciding whether the proceedings should be transferred.

6. Whether the Judge erred in not considering the likelihood of an appeal from the District Court.
The Court found that the Judge did not err in not considering the principles in Kensington Developments Ltd (in rec) v Commissioner of Inland Revenue.

7. Whether the Judge erred in “fully grasping or applying the tenets related to the formation of online contracts”.
The Court found that the Judge was not required to fully grasp or apply the tenets related to the formation of online contracts in the context of the transfer application.

8. Whether the Judge failed to address the broader public interest of the case, and in particular “how large insurance entities interact with individual policyholders and nuances of online contractual agreements”.
The Court found that the Judge properly considered the broader public interest in the context of the transfer application.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Court of Appeal considered the appeal under a two-stage approach in accordance with Fuehrer v Thompson. The first stage involved a threshold determination of whether removal to the High Court was desirable. The Court found that the Judge correctly assessed that removal was not desirable. The second stage involved a discretionary assessment of whether removal should in fact be ordered, considering the factors set out in s 89 of the District Court Act. The Court found that the Judge properly exercised his discretion and considered all relevant factors in declining the transfer application.

The Court found that the Judge did not err in his assessment of the complexity of the case, the general or public importance of the case, the amount in issue, the likely length of the hearing, or the financial resources of the parties. The Court also found that the Judge properly considered whether it was otherwise in the interests of justice to make the order, and did not overlook any procedural unfairness experienced by Mr Jabbara.

The Court noted that the procedural delays and complexity in the District Court arose from the manner in which the claim had been progressed, rather than any sinister conduct by Southern Cross. The Court found no error in the Judge's assessment and dismissed the appeal, ordering the appellant to pay the respondent's costs.