Isac (NZ) Limited v Managh

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV 2011-441-396 [2014] NZHC 2898

IN THE MATTER OF the Companies Act 1993

IN THE MATTER OF

the liquidation of GAMBLING HELPLINE LIMITED (in liquidation)

BETWEEN

ISAC (NZ) LIMITED Applicant

AND

JOHN MANAGH Respondent

On the papers

Judgment:

20 November 2014

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J (Costs)

[1]      I refer  to  my judgment  delivered  on  5  December 2013.1     The  applicant applied  under s  284  of the Companies Act  1993  for an  order setting  aside  the liquidator’s decision to reject the applicant’s proof of debt and a direction that the debt as claimed for the sum of $178,802 be paid.  I held that the grounds on which the liquidator rejected the claim were wrong.  I directed that the liquidator reconsider the proof of debt.  I made associated directions as to how that reconsideration was to occur.

[2]      I also directed that brief memoranda could be filed within three months of the date of that judgment if the parties were not able to resolve costs as part of the liquidation.  I have since received reasonably substantial memoranda (two from each party) on various dates outside that time frame.  That was because the parties were

considering whether the issue of costs might be resolved as part of the resolution of

1 Isac New Zealand Ltd v Managh [2013] NZHC 3242.

ISAC (NZ) LIMITED v MANAGH [2014] NZHC 2898 [20 November 2014]

the substantive claim.    That  was  not  achieved  by the time the last  of the four memoranda had been filed.

[3]      The applicant seeks indemnity costs in the sum of $101,525.86 (inclusive of

GST) or alternatively increased costs.  It contends:

(a)       it was the successful party (it succeeded in having the liquidator’s

decision set aside);

(b)the liquidator pursued  every conceivable,  but  meritless,  ground in opposition;

(c)      the liquidator’s without prejudice settlement offer of $50,000 is not relevant because it has not been shown to be better than that achieved by the judgment;

(d)      an order should be made under cl 16(a) or (b) of the Companies Act

1993 Liquidation Regulations 1994 (which relate to the manner and source of the payment).

[4]      The respondent contends that:

(a)      the  applicant  failed  in  its  claim  for  payment  of  $178,802,  its application  was  misconceived,  and  the  applicant  ought  to  have brought its claim in the ordinary way with the leave of the Court;

(b)the  liquidator’s  without  prejudice  offer  was  fair  given  that  the applicant did not provide information to the liquidator to enable him to assess the applicant’s loss, and it remains to be seen whether the applicant will establish any loss and, if it does, whether any loss will exceed the liquidator’s offer;

(c)      costs should await the outcome of the assessment of the applicant’s loss and that assessment is yet to occur because relevant discovery has not been provided;

(d)if costs are to be ordered now the usual High Court Rules should apply, there is no basis for indemnity or increased costs, the legal costs…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Isac (NZ) Limited v Managh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 2898
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Isac (NZ) Limited v Managh involves a dispute regarding the rejection of a creditor's proof of debt in the liquidation of Gambling Helpline Limited. The applicant, Isac (NZ) Limited, sought an order to set aside the liquidator's decision to reject its claim for $178,802 and to direct that the debt be paid. The matter was heard by Mallon J in the High Court of New Zealand.

The primary legal issue was whether the liquidator's decision to reject the applicant's proof of debt was justified, and if not, what costs should be awarded to the successful party. The applicant argued that it was entitled to indemnity costs because it was the successful party and the liquidator had pursued meritless defences. The respondent, the liquidator, contended that the applicant should not receive indemnity costs and that the costs incurred by the applicant were unreasonable.

The court found that the applicant was the successful party, albeit only partially, because the liquidator's decision was set aside, but the quantum of the debt remained to be determined. The court ruled that the appropriate category of costs was 2B under the High Court Rules, taking into account the meritless defences raised by the liquidator but also the applicant's initial procedural error. The court rejected the respondent's objections to certain costs and ordered the applicant's costs with a slight adjustment for double counting. The court also decided not to make an order under the Companies Act 1993 Liquidation Regulations 1994 at that stage, as the loss had not yet been established.

The final orders made by the court were for the applicant to receive category 2B costs as claimed, with adjustments for double counting, and no order was made under the Companies Act 1993 Liquidation Regulations 1994. The applicant was left to claim further costs in the liquidation if it established its claim.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established