ISAC New Zealand Limited v Managh

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV 2011-441-396 [2013] NZHC 3242

IN THE MATTER OF       the Companies Act 1993

AND IN THE MATTER     the liquidation of Gambling Helpline

Limited (in Liquidation)

BETWEEN  ISAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED Applicant

ANDJOHN MANAGH Respondent

Hearing:                   5-7 August 2013

Closing submissions received on 13, 20 and 26 August 2013 (Heard at Wellington)

Counsel:                  R Hucker for the Applicant

M MacFarlane for the Respondent

Judgment:                5 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF MALLON J

Table of Contents

Introduction ....................................................................................................................................... [1] The evidence ...................................................................................................................................... [3] Claim for future debt ...................................................................................................................... [65] Claim under clause 11.2 ..................................................................................................................  [74] Authority to contract ...................................................................................................................... [83] Lost data......................................................................................................................................... [100] Penalty............................................................................................................................................ [109]

Relief............................................................................................................................................... [125]

ISAC NEW ZEALAND LIMITED v MANAGH [2013] NZHC 3242 [5 December 2013]

Introduction

[1]      ISAC1  seeks payment of $178,802 for early termination of an IT services contract  with  GHL.2      The  contract  came  to  an  early  end  when  GHL’s  parent company, Lifeline,3 put GHL into voluntary liquidation without warning or notice to GHL or ISAC.  Under the contract GHL was required to pay a monthly charge for

the IT services provided over the term of the contract.  If the contract was terminated early in certain circumstances, a provision in the contract required GHL to pay those monthly charges as if the contract had not been terminated.  ISAC filed a proof of debt in the liquidation pursuant to this provision. The liquidator rejected the proof of debt.

[2]      ISAC’s  claim  is  brought  by  way  of  an  application  under  s 284  of  the Companies Act 1993 seeking an order setting aside the liquidator’s decision to reject ISAC’s proof of debt and a direction that the debt as claimed by ISAC be paid.  The issues are:

(a)       whether   the   liquidator   was   required   to   accept   ISAC’s   claim

irrespective of the termination provisions in the contract;

(b)if not, whether ISAC terminated the contract in circumstances which enabled it to claim the $178,802 under the contract;

(c)       if  it  did,  whether  the  contract  was  entered  into  by  GHL’s  chief

executive officer (CEO) without actual or apparent authority;

(d)whether there is any substance to a claim that ISAC breached the contract;

(e)       whether  the  clause  under  which  the  payment  was  sought  was  an unenforceable penalty;

(f)       whether relief under s 284 is appropriate.

1      ISAC New Zealand Limited.

2      Gambling Helpline Limited.

3      Lifeline Auckland trading as Lifeline Aotearoa.

The evidence

The background

[3]      Lifeline is a charitable trading trust.   It provides free confidential helpline counselling services and face to face counselling.   Its wholly owned subsidiary, GHL, provided problem gambling counselling services via telephone, text and email. GHL’s main source of funding was under a contract with the Ministry of Health.  Up until November 2008 the Ministry contracted directly with GHL for the provision of those services.  After that, the Ministry awarded the contract to Lifeline who then subcontracted with GHL for the provision of services.

[4]      GHL initially managed its own IT services.   In 2004 it was proposed that ISAC would provide IT services.…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ISAC New Zealand Limited v Managh and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3242
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

ISAC New Zealand Limited sought a review of the liquidator's decision to reject its proof of debt in the liquidation of Gambling Helpline Limited. ISAC argued that it was owed $178,802 for the early termination of an IT services contract. The contract had been terminated when Gambling Helpline's parent company, Lifeline, put Gambling Helpline into voluntary liquidation without warning. The liquidator rejected ISAC's proof of debt. The central issue was whether the contract was valid and enforceable and, if so, whether clause 11.2, which required payment if the contract was terminated early, was a penalty or a genuine pre-estimate of loss. The court found that clause 11.2 was not a genuine pre-estimate of loss and therefore unenforceable. The court also found that the contract was valid and enforceable and that ISAC had the right to terminate the contract. The court ordered the liquidator to reconsider ISAC's proof of debt, but only if ISAC provided information showing that clause 11.2 reflected a genuine pre-estimate of its loss if the 2011 contract was terminated prior to 30 June 2013. Alternatively, ISAC was to provide information to the liquidator setting out its loss from early termination. The liquidator could request access to information from ISAC in relation to this, but must act reasonably in making any such request. The court considered it appropriate to direct the parties to co-operate and act reasonably to finalise the amount that ISAC was entitled to receive. The court considered that it was not appropriate to reserve leave for the parties to seek further directions if they were unable to resolve matters. If the parties were unable to resolve matters, a further application may need to be made under s 284 on the issue that had arisen.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established