IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND AUCKLAND REGISTRY
CIV2012-404-003789 [2013] NZHC 104
BETWEEN INSUREGO LIMITED First Plaintiff
ANDPACIFIC TRUSTEES & NOMINEES LIMITED
Second Plaintiff
ANDPETER ALLAN HARRIS First Defendant
ANDALISTAIR LEIGHTON HUTCHISON Second Defendant
Hearing: 4 February 2013
Appearances: A R Gilchrist for the Plaintiffs
R E Harrison QC for the Defendants
Judgment: 7 February 2013
JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE CHRISTIANSEN
This judgment was delivered by me on
07.02.13 at 4:30pm, pursuant to
Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.
Registrar/Deputy Registrar
Date……………
Solicitors/Counsel:
A Gilchrist, Auckland – Andrew@gilchrist.co.nz / nseebold@blackwells-law.co.nz
R Harrison, Auckland – rehqc@xtra.co.nz / Geoff.turner@fortunemanning.co.nz
INSUREGO LIMITED V PETER ALLAN HARRIS HC AK CIV 2010-404-003789 [7 February 2013]
Background
[1] The plaintiffs between them owned 32 per cent (8 million shares) of the share capital of CBL Insurance Limited (CBL). Of those shares 2,500,000 were sold in October 2007 for $500,000 equating to a price of 20 cents per share. The plaintiffs were interests in the control of Mr Thomas, a lawyer.
[2] The defendants each controlled interests which also owned 32 per cent of the share capital of CBL. The interests of the defendants and of Mr Thomas acquired their shares in CBL in 1996. Then, its business constituted primarily the provision of bonds to the building and construction industry. Since, its range of insurance and bonding business expanded significantly but that notwithstanding, as at 2007 it remained a relatively small insurer underwriting financial risk. It took on the risk, that if capital eroded through any losses, then it would be for the shareholders to put in further capital.
[3] In the latter part of 2007 and into 2008 a number of issues affected the relationship between Mr Thomas and the defendants. Mr Thomas expressed a desire to exit CBL.
[4] It appears that by August 2008 an agreement was reached for the payment of
23 cents each for those shares retained by the plaintiffs. As Mr Harris deposed the share price was reached with little argument. It appears at that time that Mr Thomas accepted (indeed the defendants say he proposed) that 23 cents was fair value on the basis of the 2007 published and audited accounts and taking into account also the factoring in of a number of off balance sheet items including potential liability in the face of threatened litigation.
[5] The agreement for the sale of the plaintiffs remaining 5,500,000 shares was settled on 23 December 2008 when a total price of $1,265,000 was paid by interests of the defendants.
[6] The plaintiffs proceeding is brought because it is claimed the defendants interests paid too little for those shares transferred on 23 December 2008. It is claimed the shares were worth 72 cents each and therefore the plaintiffs have sustained losses totalling $2,695,000 in the outcome.
[7] The defendants are sued in their capacities as directors of CBL at the time of sale, and because the agreements for sale and purchase identified the defendants as well as their purchasing entities as…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Insurego Ltd v Harris and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2013] NZHC 104
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues in the case included whether the defendants, as directors, had access to material non-public information that would have affected the fair value of the shares, and if the share purchase agreement constituted a "share dealing by directors" under Section 149 of the Companies Act 1993. Additionally, the court needed to determine if the share purchase price was less than the fair value of the shares and whether the Settlement Agreement influenced the share valuation.
The court found that the plaintiffs' claims were contested both factually and legally. There were many unresolved factual issues, such as the exact nature and extent of the defendants' knowledge of CBL’s financial position, which required further evidence. The court also expressed concerns about the applicability of Section 149 in the context of a closely held private company where shareholders were also directors. Furthermore, the valuation evidence provided by the plaintiffs was questioned due to its reliance on unverified assumptions and potentially outdated financial information. Consequently, the court dismissed the application for summary judgment and reserved costs pending further evidence and resolution of the case.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi