Cooper-Davies Trustees Number 6 Ltd v Cooper Trustees Number 11 Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2012-409-000409 [2013] NZHC 3526

BETWEEN  COOPER-DAVIES TRUSTEES NUMBER 6 LIMITED

Plaintiff

AND  COOPER TRUSTEES NUMBER 11

LIMITED

First Defendant

LILLY JESSICA COOPER Second Defendant

Hearing:                   24, 29, 30, 31 October & 1 November 2013

Appearances:           G M Brodie for Plaintiff

G K Riach and M Crimp for Defendants

Judgment:                20 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF D GENDALL J

Table of Contents

Para No Introduction   [1] Background facts  [6] The transaction in question  [16] The claim       [17] First cause of action  [18]

Second cause of action  [20] Third cause of action  [22] Fourth cause of action  [25] Fifth cause of action  [27]

Sixth cause of action  [29]

General background to earthquake status of the Madras Street building and dealings between the parties

[31]

COOPER-DAVIES TRUSTEES NUMBER 6 LIMITED v COOPER TRUSTEES NUMBER 11 LIMITED [2013] NZHC 3526 [20 December 2013]

Re-opening of share sale and demolition of the Madras Street building                  [71]

Third cause of action – s 149 Companies Act 1993  [78]

Did  Ms  Cooper have  relevant  price-sensitive information that she  did  not disclose?

[93]

Issues as to share valuation  [103]

-     Mr Medlicott  [104]

-     Mr Hadlee  [105]

-     Mr Munn  [115] My decision on “fair value”  [132] Contractual Mistakes Act 1977 – mutual mistake  [140] Contractual Mistakes Act 1977 – unilateral mistake  [142] Contractual Remedies Act 1979  [144] Fair Trading Act 1986  [146] Breach of Fiduciary Duty  [148] Conclusion  [152] Costs  [153]

Introduction

[1]      This  proceeding  rather  sadly  involves  an  acrimonious  dispute  between members of the Cooper family over a share transaction.   On the one side is the second defendant, Lillie Jessica Cooper (Ms Cooper), and her family interests including   the   first   defendant.      On   the   other   side   is   Ms   Cooper’s   sister, Amanda Cooper-Davies (Ms Cooper-Davies), and her husband James Christopher Davies (Mr Davies) and their family interests.  Together Ms Cooper and her interests as to a 50% share and Ms Cooper-Davies, Mr Davies and their interests as to the other  50%  share  were  shareholders  in  various  companies  which  carried  out numerous commercial property developments in Christchurch.   In the main those development   projects   were   broadly   successful   until   around   2010   when, unfortunately, these members of the Cooper family fell out in a major way.

[2]      This culminated in Mr Davies and Ms Cooper-Davies indicating that they wished to sell to Ms Cooper their 50% shareholding in one of the development companies, Madras Street 323 Limited (the company).  Negotiations for the sale of these shares took place on the basis of a broad assessment of value at the time.  This

basis was that the major asset of the company, an earthquake damaged commercial building at 323 Madras Street, Christchurch (the Madras Street building), was to be repaired in terms of the insurance policy held over the building.  Given this, a sale price for the 50% shareholding of Ms Cooper-Davies and Mr Davies’ interests in the company was agreed at $150,000 and the sale of the shares was completed.

[3]      Subsequently, it transpired that…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cooper-Davies Trustees Number 6 Ltd v Cooper Trustees Number... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3526
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Cooper-Davies Trustees Number 6 Ltd v Cooper Trustees Number 11 Ltd is a dispute between family members over the sale of shares in a Christchurch-based company involved in property development. The plaintiff, Cooper-Davies Trustees Number 6 Limited, was a trustee company for Ms Cooper-Davies, Mr Davies, and their family. The defendant, Cooper Trustees Number 11 Limited, was a trustee company for Ms Cooper and her family. The dispute arose from the sale of a 50% shareholding in the company to Ms Cooper, which was agreed at $150,000 based on the assumption that the primary asset, an earthquake-damaged commercial building, would be repaired. However, it later transpired that the building would be demolished and rebuilt, significantly increasing its value. The plaintiff sued for $728,000, claiming that Ms Cooper had acquired the shares at less than fair value.

The court found that Ms Cooper, as a director of the company, had specific information regarding the future of the building that she did not disclose to the plaintiff. This information was material to the assessment of the value of the shares and, according to the Companies Act 1993, she was required to acquire the shares at fair value. The court determined that the fair value of the shares was $463,582, and since Ms Cooper had paid only $150,000, she was liable to pay the difference of $313,582 to the plaintiff. The court rejected the plaintiff's other claims based on mutual and unilateral mistake, misrepresentation, misleading or deceptive conduct, and breach of fiduciary duty. The court ordered that the defendants pay the plaintiff $313,582, representing the difference between the amount paid for the shares and their fair value. Costs were reserved pending an agreement between the parties.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established