Inland Revenue Department v Kamal

Link copied
Case Copied 12 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CRI-2013-485-0058 [2013] NZHC 3474

INLAND REVENUE DEPARTMENT

v

IMRAN MOHAMMED KAMAL

Hearing:                   12 December 2013

Counsel:                  D La Hood and M Ferrier for Applicant

W T Nabney for Respondent

Judgment:                19 December 2013

JUDGMENT OF WILLIAMS J

Introduction

[1]      Mr Kamal pleaded guilty in the District Court to six counts of knowingly providing false tax returns under s 143A of the Tax Administration Act 1994.   He was sentenced to three months’ home detention and 150 hours’ community work.  He sought name suppression under s 200 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 (the Act), which the District Court denied.

[2]      On  appeal,  Mr  Kamal  applied  for  leave  to  adduce  two  items  of  further evidence.   The first was an affidavit from Mr Kamal, in which he deposed that Mrs Kamal had attempted suicide when she heard about the District Court decision declining  name  suppression.   The second  item  was  a  report  from  a  counsellor, Ms Tanielu-Etuale, which stated Mrs Kamal was at risk of suicide if Mr Kamal’s

name were to be released.

INLAND REVENUE DEPARTMENT v KAMAL [2013] NZHC 3474 [19 December 2013]

[3]      I granted name suppression on the basis that there was a clear link between publication and the danger to Mrs Kamal, in terms of s 200(e) of the Act.  I reasoned that:1

... there is independent clinical evidence that indicates publication could well lead to a second and perhaps successful suicide attempt by Mrs K.  This case is distinguishable from other situations where there was a risk of suicide but no attempt had actually been made.  The Crown (understandably) makes no argument that the first suicide attempt was other than genuine.   Nor is it argued that there was no causal nexus between the prospect of publication and the suicide attempt.

...

In the end, I am persuaded by a clear margin that in the exceptional circumstances of this case, the need to protect Mrs K’s wellbeing outweighs the strong public interest in revealing the appellant’s name.

[4]      Since that decision, the Crown has unearthed information that casts doubt on the  accuracy  and  authenticity  of  Mr  Kamal’s  affidavit  and  the  report  from Ms Tanielu-Etuale.    Unsurprisingly,  the Crown  now applies  to  revoke the name suppression order.

[5]      The situation is complicated by the additional factor that Mr Kamal has filed

a report from an experienced consultant psychiatrist on Mrs Kamal’s mental health.

Mr Kamal’s affidavit

[6]      Mr Kamal’s affidavit upon which I relied in my first decision, said:

... on the evening of 25 July 2013 ... [Mrs Kamal] started having anxiety attacks.  She started shivering, shaking and sweating.  I comforted her and gave her support and tried to give her assurance that things would be all fine.

Later on that evening and after the conversation referred to above, she tried to overdose herself with sleeping tablets and commit suicide.

Once I became aware that she had taken an overdose of sleeping tablets, I immediately called an ambulance.   I was asked…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inland Revenue Department v Kamal and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 3474
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Inland Revenue Department sought to revoke a suppression order that protected the identity of Imran Mohammed Kamal, who had pleaded guilty to six counts of knowingly providing false tax returns. Kamal had been sentenced to three months' home detention and 150 hours of community work. The District Court had denied Kamal's application for name suppression under s 200 of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011, but the suppression order was later granted by the High Court. The Crown subsequently sought to revoke the order, casting doubt on the accuracy and authenticity of the evidence upon which the original suppression order was based.

The legal issues the court had to decide included whether the suppression order should be revoked due to the unreliability of the evidence supporting it and whether the risk of harm to Mrs Kamal, if any, could be mitigated by other means. The court had to weigh the importance of open justice against the need to protect Mrs Kamal's wellbeing.

The court found that the evidence supporting the suppression order was unreliable. The affidavit from Kamal describing his wife's suicide attempt was found to be inconsistent with the hospital records. The report from Ms Tanielu-Etuale, a counsellor, was also found to be unreliable as it was based on Kamal's story about his wife's attempted suicide and the counsellor was not qualified to give an opinion about the risk of suicide. The report from Dr Vijayasenan, a consultant psychiatrist, was found to be based on a self-report and the psychiatrist's impression during a 45-minute consultation, without a detailed analysis. The court concluded that the risk of harm to Mrs Kamal could be mitigated by familial support and appropriate professional help. The court revoked the suppression order but agreed to lift the order on a future date to allow the Kamal family time to prepare for the consequences of publication.

The final orders of the court were that the suppression order be revoked on Friday, 10 January 2014, to allow the Kamal family time to prepare for the consequences of publication.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established