Ibrahim v Associate Minister of Immigration

Link copied
Case Copied 14 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA746/2011
[2012] NZCA 229

BETWEEN  DEMYSSA AHMED IBRAHIM
Appellant

AND  THE ASSOCIATE MINISTER OF IMMIGRATION
Respondent

Counsel:         F Cooke QC and M Smith for Appellant
I C Carter for Respondent

Judgment:      6 June 2012

JUDGMENT OF ARNOLD J

AThe application for review of the Acting Registrar’s decision not to dispense with security for costs is declined.

BThe amount of security required is reduced from $5,560 to $1,390, which must be paid into Court within 20 working days of the date of this judgment.

_______________________________________________________________

REASONS

Introduction

  1. Mr Ibrahim has appealed a decision of MacKenzie J ordering him to pay security for costs in the High Court on his application for judicial review.[1]  Security for costs on the appeal was set at $5,560.  On 29 November 2011, Mr Ibrahim applied for dispensation from the requirement to pay security.[2]  The respondent opposed the application.  In a letter dated 20 December 2011, the Acting Registrar declined to dispense with security.  This is an application for review of that decision.

Background

[1]Ibrahim v Associate Minister of Immigration HC Wellington CIV-2011-485-1142, 18 October 2011.

[2]      Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005, r 35(6)(c).

  1. Mr Ibrahim is from Ethiopia and of Oromo ethnicity.  He is a member of the Oromo Liberation Front party, which is in opposition to the current government of Ethiopia.  He is presently resident in Egypt, where he fled to escape the violence directed toward the Oromo people generally and toward himself in particular as a result of his political beliefs.  Mr Ibrahim’s wife, Hajera, is a New Zealand citizen and lives in Wellington.  She moved to New Zealand with family members in 2004 and was granted citizenship in 2008.  In her original residency application, Hajera declared that she was not married and had no children.  In fact, Mr Ibrahim and Hajera had two children together.  The children stayed in Ethiopia with Mr Ibrahim.  One of them died in a fire in 2010 and the other suffered burns but survived and is still in Ethiopia with family friends.

  2. Mr Ibrahim applied for a residence class visa for himself and the two children in 2006, with Hajera as their sponsor.  In 2009 that application was declined on the ground of the original declaration by Hajera that she was unmarried and childless.  Mr Ibrahim’s appeal against that decision was dismissed by the Residence Review Board, which determined that an exception to policy was not justified.

  3. In November 2010, shortly after Mr Ibrahim’s son died in the fire, a local Member of Parliament made a submission to the Associate Minister of Immigration.  The appellant, who was unaware of that submission, also made his own more comprehensive submission to the Associate Minister in February 2011 for a special declaration under s 378 of the Immigration Act 2009.  The application was supported by extensive evidence that had not been presented with the earlier submission by the MP.  In May 2011 the Associate Minister declined to intervene. 

  4. Mr Ibrahim issued…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Ibrahim v Associate Minister of Immigration and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 229
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal in Ibrahim v Associate Minister of Immigration, heard in the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, involved Demyssa Ahmed Ibrahim, an Ethiopian national of Oromo ethnicity residing in Egypt, challenging the Associate Minister of Immigration's decision to not grant him and his children a residence class visa. Ibrahim had applied for the visa in 2006, with his wife Hajera, a New Zealand citizen, as the sponsor. However, the application was declined in 2009 due to Hajera's original declaration that she was unmarried and childless. After a failed appeal, Ibrahim made a submission to the Associate Minister for a special declaration under s 378 of the Immigration Act 2009, which was also declined. Ibrahim then sought judicial review of the Associate Minister's decision, arguing that the materials provided to the Minister for consideration did not include his application and accompanying evidence. MacKenzie J ordered Ibrahim to pay security for costs in respect of his application for judicial review, which he appealed to the Court of Appeal.

The legal issues the court had to decide were whether the Acting Registrar's decision not to dispense with the security for costs requirement was correct and whether the amount of security required should be reduced. The court considered the general principles of security for costs and the exceptional circumstances required for its waiver. It also examined the merits of Ibrahim's appeal, the importance of the issues raised, and the public interest in having them determined.

The court found that the Acting Registrar's decision not to dispense with security for costs was correct as the appeal was unlikely to succeed, and the Minister should be protected against unjustified litigation. However, given Ibrahim's impecuniosity and the context of the appeal, the court reduced the amount of security required by 75%, from $5,560 to $1,390. The court declined to order costs on the application.

In conclusion, the Court of Appeal declined the application for review of the Acting Registrar's decision not to dispense with security for costs but reduced the amount of security required to $1,390, which must be paid within 20 working days of the judgment date. There was no order for costs on the application.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established