Hotchin v KA No 4 Trustee Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 47 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND WELLINGTON REGISTRY

CIV-2013-485-007919 [2014] NZHC 878

BETWEEN  LAMBTON QUAY PROPERTIES NOMINEE LIMITED

Appellant

ANDWELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL Respondent

NEW ZEALAND HISTORIC PLACES TRUST (POUHERE TAONGA)

Section 274 Party

Hearing:                   31 March 2014 and 1 April 2014

Counsel:                  C Anastasiou for Appellant

S F Quinn for Respondent

R M Devine and K M Krumdiek for Section 274 Party

Judgment:                2 May 2014

JUDGMENT OF COLLINS J

Introduction

[1]      Lambton  Quay  Properties  Nominee  Ltd  (the  building  owner)  wishes  to demolish its building on the corner of Lambton Quay and Grey Street in central Wellington. The building is known as the “Harcourts Building”.

[2]      The Harcourts Building has been assessed by the Wellington City Council

(the Council) as being an earthquake-prone building under the Building Act.1    It is also listed as a category 1 heritage building under the Historic Places Act.2

1 Building Act 2004, s 122.

2      Historic Places Act 1993, s 22(3)(a)(i).

LAMBTON QUAY PROPERTIES NOMINEE LIMITED v WELLINGTON CITY COUNCIL [2014] NZHC

878 [2 May 2014]

[3] After the Council assessed the Harcourts Building as being earthquake-prone it issued the building owner with a notice in July 2012 under s 124 of the Building Act requiring the building owner to either strengthen the building or demolish it by

27 July 2027.

[4]      After   conducting   investigations   and   consultations   the   building   owner concluded that it was not economically viable to strengthen the Harcourts Building. On 4 September 2012  it  applied to the Council for resource consent  under the Resource Management Act for permission to demolish the building.3   However, even though the Council had required the building owner to either strengthen or demolish the  building,  the  consent  authority declined  the  building  owner’s  application  to

demolish the building.  The consent authority’s decision was primarily based upon its interpretation and application of the heritage provisions of the Council’s District Plan created under the Resource Management Act.4

[5]      The  building  owner  appealed  the  consent  authority’s  decision  to  the Environment  Court.    The  Environment  Court  dismissed  the  building  owner’s appeal.5   The building owner has now lodged 15 grounds of appeal in this Court.  I will explain each of the building owner’s grounds of appeal in paragraphs [68] to [110] of this judgment.   For convenience I set out the 15 grounds of appeal in Appendix 1 to this judgment.

[6]      Determining the fate of the Harcourts Building has brought into focus a number of competing considerations, the most significant of which are:

(1)       the safety of the public;

(2)       the risk of damage to buildings which are in close proximity to the

Harcourts Building;

(3)       the public interest in preserving heritage buildings;  and

3      Resource Management Act 1991, s 88.   I refer in this judgment to the body that heard the

resource consent application as the “consent authority”.

4      Sections 31, 72 to 77D.

5      Lambton Quay Properties Nominee Ltd v Wellington City Council [2013] NZRMA 39 (EC).

(4)the  private,  financial  and  property interests  of owners of heritage buildings.

[7]      While I am…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hotchin v KA No 4 Trustee Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] NZHC 978
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Lambton Quay Properties Nominee Ltd (the building owner) sought to demolish a building it owned in Wellington. The building had been assessed as earthquake prone and the Wellington City Council (the Council) required the building owner to either strengthen the building or demolish it by 27 July 2027. The building owner applied to the Council for resource consent to demolish the building. However, the Council declined the building owner’s application for resource consent to demolish the building. The building owner appealed the consent authority’s decision to the Environment Court. The Environment Court dismissed the building owner’s appeal. The building owner appealed the Environment Court’s decision to the High Court. The High Court found the Environment Court had made two errors of law when it dismissed the building owner’s appeal. The High Court allowed the appeal and remitted the case back to the Environment Court for rehearing. The High Court held that the Environment Court had erred when it had said the onus on the building owner was to establish that alternatives to demolishing the building had been “exhaustively and convincingly excluded”. The High Court also held that the Environment Court had erred when it had concluded that the relevant provisions of the Resource Management Act and the Building Act could not be reconciled, and in doing so, failed to give adequate consideration to the risk to public safety and surrounding buildings if the Harcourts Building remains as it is. The High Court dismissed the majority of the building owner’s grounds of appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.