Heyward Holdings Limited (in liquidation) v Booth

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA ŌTEPOTI ROHE

CIV-2018-412-000003

[2018] NZHC 1339

BETWEEN

HEYWARD HOLDINGS LIMITED (In

Liquidation) Plaintiff

AND

MAITLAND COLIN BOOTH

Defendant

Hearing:

25 May 2018

Submissions: 22 June 2018

Appearances:

D M Lester for Plaintiff

D J Ballantyne for Defendant

Judgment:

3 July 2018


JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS


[1]                 Heyward Holdings Limited (Heyward) was placed into liquidation by order of the High Court at Dunedin on 5 May 2016. Heyward sues Mr Booth to recover from him the sum of $556,940, which is the sum shown as owing to Heyward by Mr Booth in its annual accounts to 31 March 2014, as an associated party loan account. At that time, Mr Booth was Heyward’s sole director.

[2]                 In the same set of annual accounts a company called Heyward Trustees Limited (HTL) is shown as owing $145,230 to Heyward. HTL was the sole shareholder in Heyward. It is a corporate trustee.

[3]                 In the 2015 annual accounts Mr Booth is not shown as owing anything to Heyward by way of an associated party loan, but HTL is shown as owing $755,490. In the general ledger for Heyward for the period 1 April 2014 to 31 March 2015, there

HEYWARD HOLDINGS LTD (In Liquidation) v BOOTH [2018] NZHC 1339 [3 July 2018]

is an entry on 31 March 2015, described as a journal entry, and noted as “assign AP advance to trust”. The sum to which this notation relates is $543,223.24. There is then a further notation on the same day “transfer to 500/001” and by this notation a credit of $543,223 is referred to. The effect of these entries is that the debt shown was recorded as assigned by Mr Booth to HTL and consequently transferred in the ledger to that entity.

[4]                 This accounts for the bulk of the difference between the sum shown as owing by Mr Booth as at 31 March 2014, $556,940, and zero shown as owing in the balance sheet as at 31 March 2015. It also accounts for the majority of the difference in the balances shown as owing to Heyward by HTL, as set out above.

[5]                 Heyward does not accept that the sum initially shown as owing by Mr Booth was at any point owing by any party other than him, and does not accept that an assignment of Mr Booth’s debt took place. It therefore applies for summary judgment on its claim.

[6]                 Mr Booth says that the associated party advances shown in the accounts as owing by him are not, and never have been, owing by him. He says there is a sum, as shown in the 2015 accounts, owing by HTL which had at all times been the recipient of the goods, services and cash for which debits are shown in Mr Booth’s name up to 31 March 2014.

Principles to be applied

[7]                 Rule 12.2 of the High Court Rules provides that the Court may give…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heyward Holdings Limited (in liquidation) v Booth and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1339
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Heyward Holdings Limited, a New Zealand-based company that was in liquidation, brought an action against Mr. Maitland Colin Booth for the recovery of the sum of $556,940, which was shown as owing by Mr. Booth in the annual accounts to 31 March 2014. Mr. Booth, who was the sole director of Heyward at the relevant time, denied that he owed this sum, and argued that the debt was instead owed by Heyward Trustees Limited, a company of which he was a shareholder. The High Court of New Zealand was required to determine whether Mr. Booth had a valid defence to the claim and whether he was liable for the debt.

The Court found that Mr. Booth's defence was of no merit. The Court rejected Mr. Booth's assertion that the debt was not his liability but rather the liability of Heyward Trustees Limited. The Court found that there was no evidence to support Mr. Booth's claim that the debt was owed by Heyward Trustees Limited, and that the debt was, in fact, his personal liability. The Court also found that the purported assignment of the debt recorded in Heyward's ledger was of no legal effect, as liability for a debt cannot be assigned. Finally, the Court rejected the contention that there was a novation, as there was no evidence of consideration or a deed of novation.

The Court found that Mr. Booth's evidence was inconsistent with contemporaneous documents and was, at best, unreliable. The Court concluded that there was no defence to Heyward's claim and that Mr. Booth was liable for the debt shown in the 2014 accounts. The Court entered judgment for Heyward against Mr. Booth for the sum of $556,940, with interest running from the date on which demand was first made. Heyward was also awarded costs on a 2B basis and disbursements fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established