Cargill Contracting Limited v Heyward Holdings Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 10 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND DUNEDIN REGISTRY

CIV-2015-412-000115 [2016] NZHC 351

UNDER the Companies Act 1993

BETWEEN

CARGILL CONTRACTING LIMITED Plaintiff

AND

HEYWARD HOLDINGS LIMITED Defendant

Hearing: 1 March 2016

Appearances:

L A Andersen for Plaintiff
J Moss for Defendant

Judgment:

4 March 2016

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

[1]      Cargill Contracting Limited (Cargill) is seeking an order putting Heyward Holdings Limited (Heyward) into liquidation.   It pleads that Heyward is insolvent and unable to pay its debts.  On 25 September 2015, Cargill served Heyward with a demand under s 289 of the Companies Act 1993 in respect of a claimed debt of

$82,676.74.  Heyward neither met the debt, nor applied to set aside the notice.  As a result it is now presumed to be unable to pay its debts.   Therefore, a ground for placing Heyward into liquidation has been established.

[2]      Heyward, however, challenges the debt which was the subject of the notice. It applies for an order staying Cargill’s proceeding, and restraining advertising of the application under r 31.9 of the High Court Rules.  Initially it also sought an order setting aside the statutory demand, but it accepts that the application was made outside the time limit imposed by s 290, and that s 290(3) provides that an extension of time for such an application cannot be granted.  Accordingly, it does not pursue

this aspect of its application.

CARGILL CONTRACTING LTD v HEYWARD HOLDINGS LTD [2016] NZHC 351 [4 March 2016]

[3]      The  remaining  two  aspects  of  the  application  are  interrelated.     If  the proceeding  is  stayed,  the  application  would  not  be  advertised.     Conversely, advertising is a necessary procedural step on an application for liquidation, so would not  be  stayed  unless  the  proceeding  itself  was  stayed.    These  applications  are therefore considered together.

[4]      In Nemisis Holdings Limited v North Harbour Industrial Holdings Limited, Wallace J summarised the principles to be applied by the Court on applications for a stay:1

(a)     The Court has an inherent jurisdiction to stay winding-up proceedings where  the  debt  upon  which  such  proceedings  are  founded  is  the subject of genuine dispute.  In those circumstances the plaintiff cannot show it has the status of a creditor or that there has been neglect by the company to pay.

(b)The jurisdiction is an inherent one to prevent abuse of process.  There is no inflexible rule.

(c)   The governing consideration is whether the proceedings suggest unfairness or undue pressure.

(d)It is a serious matter to stay winding-up proceedings, so the decision to do so is never made lightly.  The onus is on the applicant and it is normally necessary to demonstrate “something more” than the balance of convenience considerations which are usually considered on an application for interim injunction.  If the defendant company has had an opportunity to file appropriate affidavits, such defendant is required to establish a strong prima facie case of the existence of a genuine dispute  on  substantial  grounds,  or  show  that  there  are  clear  and

persuasive grounds for a stay.

1      Nemisis Holdings…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Cargill Contracting Limited v Heyward Holdings Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 351
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Cargill Contracting Limited, the plaintiff, sought to put Heyward Holdings Limited, the defendant, into liquidation, alleging insolvency. The plaintiff claimed that the defendant was unable to pay its debts, as evidenced by a statutory demand under section 289 of the Companies Act 1993 for a debt of $82,676.74, which the defendant did not meet or apply to set aside. The defendant contested the debt and sought to stay the liquidation proceedings and restrain advertising of the application, arguing that there was a genuine dispute over the quality of the work done by the plaintiff. The court had to determine whether the defendant had established a strong prima facie case of a genuine dispute on substantial grounds, or clear and persuasive grounds for a stay of the liquidation proceedings.

The court examined the claims made by the defendant and identified several difficulties with the case. The defendant expressly claimed in another proceeding that the plaintiff was contractually obliged to complete works to standards sufficient for titles to issue, which had occurred. The defendant also expressly accepted that it required the plaintiff to complete the works to a minimum standard acceptable to the Dunedin City Council. The court found that it was not established on the evidence that the work proposed by the defendant was work which the plaintiff was required to do under its contract but did not do. Additionally, the defendant did not turn to another contractor for an independent quote until after it had received a demand for payment from the plaintiff. By the time the defendant sought a quote from another contractor, it had sold the final block of land to a related company, which had then sold it to independent parties. Therefore, the defendant no longer owned any land on the subdivision, and had no right to carry out any work on the access. The court also noted that the evidence from the registered valuer, which was not sworn and therefore not admissible, did not substantiate the defendant’s claim that the condition of the roadway had caused the lower achieved sale prices. The court found that the defendant had not shown that there was a genuine dispute on substantial grounds, or clear and persuasive grounds for a stay of the liquidation proceedings.

The court dismissed the defendant’s application to stay the liquidation proceedings and restrain advertising of the application. The court extended the time for compliance with the statutory demand to 4.00 pm on Thursday, 24 March 2016. The court also ordered that the proceeding be adjourned to the List on 7 April 2016 at 10.00 am, and that the defendant pay the plaintiff costs on a 2B basis with disbursements fixed by the Registrar.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established