Herbert v New Zealand Guardian Trust Co Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read
IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND
CA701/2011
[2012] NZCA 442

BETWEEN  SUSAN NANETTE HERBERT
Appellant

AND  NEW ZEALAND GUARDIAN TRUST COMPANY LIMITED & ORS
Respondents

Hearing:         18 September 2012

Court:             Randerson, Stevens and Miller JJ

Counsel:         A Barker for Appellant
B J Upton and B J Steed for Fourth Respondent Westpac New Zealand Limited
No appearance for First, Second, Third, Fifth and Sixth Respondents

Judgment:      27 September 2012 at 11.30 a.m.

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe applications by both parties to adduce further evidence on appeal are granted.

B        The appeal is dismissed.

C        There is no order for costs.
____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Randerson J)

Introduction

  1. The appellant Mrs Herbert and her husband became involved in a property development at Pauanui on the Coromandel Peninsula.  The project involved the construction of a golf course, the subdivision of residential land and the sale of sections and villas to be constructed.  The development was described by the Judge in the Court below as a spectacular financial failure. 

  2. Five other persons who had joined Mr Herbert in the venture were adjudicated bankrupt.  Applications to have Mr and Mrs Herbert adjudicated bankrupt were filed in late 2010.  Shortly before the hearing date for these applications, both Mr and Mrs Herbert separately applied for approval of creditors’ proposals under s 333 of the Insolvency Act 2006 (the Act).  In a judgment delivered on 26 September 2011, Associate Judge Doogue declined both applications.[1]  Mrs Herbert now appeals against the Court’s refusal to approve her creditors’ proposal.  No appeal has been brought by Mr Herbert.

    [1]Herbert v Allied Nationwide Finance HC Auckland CIV-2010-404-8294, 26 September 2011.

  3. Although five creditors appeared in the High Court when the proposals were considered, the only creditor appearing to contest the appeal is the fourth respondent Westpac New Zealand Ltd (Westpac). 

  4. Initially, it appeared that the appeal would not be opposed by any creditor.  However, that position changed when, on 5 September 2012, Westpac filed an application for leave to adduce further evidence on the appeal and indicated that it would be appearing to oppose the appeal despite earlier advice that it would not do so.  This led to a very late application by Mrs Herbert for leave to file further evidence on appeal disputing aspects of the evidence that Westpac sought to advance.  This gave rise to several preliminary issues we now address.

Preliminary issues

  1. The first preliminary issue is whether the respective applications for leave to adduce further evidence on appeal ought to be granted.  We indicated during the hearing of the appeal that we would grant both applications and we now do so.  The further evidence from Westpac was an affidavit from Ms Gellert, a solicitor employed by Westpac’s legal advisers, Simpson Grierson.  She deposed that Westpac had not received notice of the creditors’ meeting as required by s 330 of the Act, to be held in order to consider the creditors’ proposals.  In consequence, Westpac had not voted on the proposals.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Herbert v New Zealand Guardian Trust Co Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZCA 442
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the Court of Appeal of New Zealand, Susan Nanette Herbert appealed against the decision of the Associate Judge Doogue to decline both applications for approval of creditors' proposals under s 333 of the Insolvency Act 2006. The appeal was dismissed. Mrs Herbert and her husband were involved in a property development that ended in a spectacular financial failure. Applications to have them adjudicated bankrupt were filed in late 2010. Shortly before the hearing date for these applications, both Mr and Mrs Herbert separately applied for approval of creditors' proposals. However, Associate Judge Doogue declined both applications. The Court of Appeal agreed with the Associate Judge that the proposals were essentially jointly presented and that Mrs Herbert's proposal was wholly inadequate, not in the interests of the body of creditors as a whole, and not reasonable. The amount offered was wholly inadequate, offering little material return in comparison to what creditors could expect to recover if Mrs Herbert were bankrupted. The proposal that the mortgagees of the Albany property would continue to receive interest payments represented a clear preference in favour of the secured creditors. The Court was not told how these payments were to be funded, who would be making them, or for what reason. The circumstances of the case warranted review by the Official Assignee.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established