Herbert Construction Company Limited v Carter Holt Harvey Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 34 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND NAPIER REGISTRY

CIV-2012-441-368 [2013] NZHC 780

BETWEEN  HERBERT CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED

Applicant

ANDCARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED Respondent

Hearing:         23 August 2012

Appearances: D J O'Connor for Applicant

J D McBride and A G Skinner for Respondent

Judgment:      16 April 2013

JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE BELL

This judgment was delivered by me on 16 April 2013 at 4:00pm

pursuant to Rule 11.5 of the High Court Rules.

...................................

Registrar/Deputy Registrar

Solicitors:

Lunn and Associates Limited, P O Box 846 Napier 4140, for Applicant

Email:    steve@lunns.co.nz

Copy for:

D J O’Connor, P O Box 137 Napier 4140, for Applicant

Email:    david@davidoconnor.co.nz

Josh McBride, P O Box 1008 Auckland 1140, for Respondent

Email:    josh@joshmcbride.co.nz

Carter Holt Harvey Ltd (A G Skinner) Private Bag 94027 Manukau 2241 (Respondent) Email:           Andrew.skinner@carters.co.nz

HERBERT CONSTRUCTION COMPANY LIMITED V CARTER HOLT HARVEY LIMITED HC NAP CIV-

2012-441-368 [16 April 2013]

[1]      Carter Holt Harvey Ltd, a builders’ merchant, served a statutory demand for

$404,317.64 on Herbert Construction Company Ltd.  Herbert applied to set aside the demand on the grounds that there is a substantial dispute whether or not the debt is owed and that it has a counterclaim for damages which exceeds the amount specified in the demand.1

[2]      The debt in the statutory demand is for money payable for building products supplied.  Most of the debt is for the supply of “Ampelite” roofing material made up of an invoice of 7 February 2012 for $265,926.59 and an invoice of 27 February

2012 for $72,790.14, a total of $338,716.73.  The rest of the demand, for $65,600.91, is  for  other  building  materials.    The  argument  is  over  the  “Ampelite”  roofing material.   Herbert says that the product supplied was defective and that it faces a demand from its customer for which it faces a liability for more than the statutory demand.  It says that it is not liable to pay for the price and that it has a claim against Carters for indemnity for an amount more than $403,370.642  – its counterclaim. Carters’ answer is that its terms of trade stop Herbert running those arguments.

[3]      These questions arise:

(a)       Does Herbert have a defence to liability and a counterclaim without the terms of trade?

(b)      Do the terms of trade apply?

(c)       What is the effect of clause 12.1 of the terms of trade?

(d)Do  the  terms  of  trade  take  away  or  reduce  any  defence  or counterclaim available to Herbert?

(e)       How should the court exercise its discretion under s 290(4)?

1   The grounds under s 290(4)(a) and (b) of the Companies Act 1993.

2   The formula under s 290(4)(b) is that an eligible counterclaim is one where the statutory demand less the amount of the counterclaim is less than the prescribed amount of $1,000.

Background

[4]      Herbert had the contract to build the canopy and rock store building for Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-Operative Company Ltd at Awatoto.   It bought the “Ampelite” roofing material for that contract.  Herbert entered into the contract with…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Herbert Construction Company Limited v Carter Holt Harvey Li... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZHC 780
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Carter Holt Harvey Ltd served a statutory demand for $404,317.64 on Herbert Construction Company Ltd. Herbert applied to set aside the demand, claiming there is a substantial dispute as to whether the debt is owed and it has a counterclaim which exceeds the amount of the demand. The dispute centred on the quality of roofing material supplied by Carter Holt to Herbert. Herbert argued that the material was defective and that it faced a liability to its customer Ravensdown Fertiliser Co-Operative Company Ltd for more than the statutory demand. Carter Holt argued that Herbert had no defence because of its terms of trade. The court held that Herbert had an arguable case that the material supplied did not meet the required standards, and that the implied condition as to merchantability was breached. The terms of trade did not negate the implied condition as to merchantability, but did exclude the right to abate the price and the right to claim damages. However, the court held that the terms did not exclude the right to claim damages, as it was contrary to the commercial purpose of the agreement. The court exercised its discretion to set aside the statutory demand for the amount of the disputed roofing materials, but not for the other building materials supplied.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established