Hayes v Family Court

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND GISBORNE REGISTRY

CIV 2012-416-82 [2012] NZHC 2088

UNDER  the Judicature Amendment Act 1972

BETWEEN  MARTA HAYES Applicant

ANDFAMILY COURT First Respondent

ANDJUDITH GUERIN Second Respondent

Hearing:         10 August 2012

Counsel:         Applicant in person

J C Bunbury and N Witters for second respondent

Judgment:      16 August 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF DOBSON J (Application for strike out)

Immediate issue, and test for strike out

[1]      This judgment deals with an application brought on behalf of the second respondent (Mrs Guerin) to strike out the claim brought by the applicant (Ms Hayes) as an application for judicial review. The essential point on which the application for judicial review depends is Ms Hayes’ contention that the Family Court wrongly declined her request to transfer to the High Court a claim against their mother’s estate by Mrs Guerin under the Family Protection Act 1955 (the FPA).  The Family Court proceeded to  find in favour of  Mrs Guerin’s  claim against  their mother’s estate, such orders operating to the detriment of Ms Hayes as the beneficiary in their

mother’s estate.

HAYES v FAMILY COURT HC GIS CIV 2012-416-82 [16 August 2012]

[2]      Ms Hayes now claims that the Family Court did not have jurisdiction to hear the FPA claim because other requisite proceedings had already been commenced in the High Court.  The concurrent jurisdiction of the High Court and the Family Court in respect of proceedings under the FPA was introduced in s 3A in 1992 on the following terms:

3A      Courts to have concurrent jurisdiction

(1)       Subject to the succeeding provisions of this section, the High Court and a Family Court shall each have jurisdiction in respect of proceedings under this Act.

(2)       A  Family  Court  shall  not  have  jurisdiction  in  respect  of  any application under this Act if, at the date of the filing of the application, proceedings relating to the same matter have already been commenced in the High Court.

…

[3]      Ms Hayes did not cite s 3A(2) to the Family Court, when her application was made to transfer the proceedings to the High Court.   Nor was the alleged lack of jurisdiction raised on subsequent opportunities in the protracted litigation between the step-sisters.  Mrs Guerin contends that an application for judicial review on this basis is not a reasonably arguable cause of action under r 15.1(a) of the High Court Rules, and alternatively is an abuse of process under r 15.1(d).  She therefore seeks to have it struck out.

[4]      The onus on a party seeking to have proceedings struck out is a relatively high one.   If strike out is sought on the basis of the untenability of the causes of action, then the Court must be persuaded that they are untenable in the sense that the causes of action could not possibly succeed.1

[5]      Generally, such applications are to be considered on the assumption that facts pleaded in the statement of claim will be made out by the plaintiff.  That approach must  be subject  to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hayes v Family Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2088
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns an application brought by Marta Hayes to the High Court for judicial review of a Family Court decision. Hayes claimed that the Family Court wrongly declined her request to transfer to the High Court a Family Protection Act 1955 claim by Judith Guerin against their mother’s estate. The Family Court had found in favour of Guerin’s claim against the estate, to the detriment of Hayes as the beneficiary. Guerin sought to have Hayes’ application struck out. The Court had to decide whether the Family Court had jurisdiction to hear Guerin’s claim against the estate, and if Hayes’ application for judicial review was tenable. The Court found that the claim of illegality depending on the Family Court not having jurisdiction was untenable, as there were no applications under the Family Protection Act or other statutes that provided for claims against the estate that had been commenced in the High Court, so as to operate as a bar to the Family Court exercising jurisdiction. The Court also found that even if the claim could have been made out, the application for judicial review would constitute an abuse of process. The Court granted Guerin’s application to strike out the judicial review proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established