Hayes v Family Court

Link copied
Case Copied 30 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA604/2012
[2015] NZCA 470

BETWEEN

M HAYES
Appellant

AND

FAMILY COURT
First Respondent

 JUDITH GUERIN
Second Respondent

Hearing:

10 June 2015

Court:

Randerson, Wild and Cooper JJ

Counsel:

Appellant in person
No appearance for Respondents

Judgment:

2 October 2015 at 3 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

B        The appellant must may costs to the second respondent in the sum of   $500.  

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Cooper J)

  1. The appellant, Ms M Hayes, appeals a judgment of Dobson J in the High Court at Gisborne striking out her application for judicial review of a decision of the Family Court.[1]

    [1]Hayes v Family Court [2012] NZHC 2088 [Judgment under appeal].

  2. In her application for review the principal claim advanced by Ms Hayes was that the Family Court acted without jurisdiction when it determined a claim by the appellant’s half sister, Mrs Judith Guerin, under the Family Protection Act 1955 (the FPA) against the estate of their mother, Elizabeth Hayes.  The Family Court awarded Mrs Guerin the sum of $80,000.[2]  Ms Hayes also claimed in the proceeding that is the subject of this appeal that the Family Court wrongly declined the appellant’s application for the transfer of the proceeding to the High Court.

    [2]JH v MH FC Gisborne FAM-2008-016-88, 12 December 2008.

  3. The jurisdictional challenge to the Family Court’s decision was advanced for the first time in the present proceeding, which was commenced in the High Court in February 2012.  Ms Hayes says the Family Court lacked jurisdiction because proceedings relating to the estate had previously been commenced in the High Court.  She invokes s 3A(2) of the FPA, which provides that the Family Court does not have jurisdiction in respect of an application under the FPA if, at the date of filing the application, “proceedings relating to the same matter have already been commenced in the High Court.”

  4. Mrs Guerin, who was the second respondent in the High Court, applied to strike out the application for review, claiming the allegation that the Family Court lacked jurisdiction was not reasonably arguable, or alternatively was an abuse of process, in terms respectively of r 15.1(1)(a) and (d) of the High Court Rules.  Dobson J granted Mrs Guerin’s application, and the present appeal has followed.

  5. The first respondent abides this Court’s decision.  Although she was represented and successful in the High Court, the second respondent Mrs Guerin has not taken part in the hearing in this Court following assurances given by Ms Hayes that the relief she now seeks is not intended to disturb the award made to Mrs Guerin out of the estate.

  6. Before dealing with the substantive issues, it is appropriate to set out, briefly, some of the history of this long-running dispute.  The following account is based largely on a summary given by Miller J in Hayes v Guerin and on various relevant minutes of the High Court.[3]

Procedural history

Probate proceedings

[3]Hayes v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hayes v Family Court and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZCA 470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Ms M Hayes appeals a judgment of the High Court at Gisborne striking out her application for judicial review of a decision of the Family Court, which awarded her half sister, Mrs Judith Guerin, the sum of $80,000 under the Family Protection Act 1955. Ms Hayes claims the Family Court lacked jurisdiction because proceedings relating to the estate had previously been commenced in the High Court. The Family Court declined Ms Hayes' application for the transfer of the proceeding to the High Court. The Court of Appeal dismisses the appeal and orders Ms Hayes to pay costs of $500 to Mrs Guerin. The Court considers the principal issue raised by Ms Hayes' claims is the extent, and effect in the present case, of the statutory bar in s 3A(2) of the Family Protection Act, which provides that a Family Court shall not have jurisdiction in respect of any application under this Act if, at the date of the filing of the application, proceedings relating to the same matter have already been commenced in the High Court. The Court of Appeal is not persuaded by the alternative approach that found favour with the High Court, which would limit the scope of s 3A(2) to proceedings brought against the relevant estate, as opposed to proceedings that might have the result of enlarging it. The Court of Appeal holds that if there are proceedings on foot in the High Court that could have the consequence of either decreasing or increasing the size of an estate, then s 3A(2) will operate to prevent a claim in the Family Court being advanced under the Family Protection Act in relation to the estate. The Court of Appeal is satisfied the High Court was right to reject the jurisdiction argument. The Court of Appeal also considers whether the claim should be struck out as an abuse of process. The Court of Appeal holds that the Court was correct to strike out as an abuse of process those parts of the claim not based on the Family Court's claimed lack of jurisdiction. The Court of Appeal holds that the other claims dealt with issues already resolved against Ms Hayes by the High Court, whose judgment survived attempts to appeal.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established