| IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND |
| CA45/2015 [2016] NZCA 434 |
| BETWEEN | HAWKE'S BAY TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMITED AND RICHARD WILLIAM HODGKINSON AS TRUSTEES OF THE RICHARD HODGKINSON TRUST |
| AND | MICHELLE KERRIAN JUDD |
| Hearing: | 28 April 2016 |
Court: | Ellen France P, Harrison and Kós JJ |
Counsel: | M E J Macfarlane for Appellants |
Judgment: | 12 September 2016 at 2.30 pm |
JUDGMENT OF THE COURT
(COSTS)
The respondent is awarded costs of $11,700 and disbursements of $709.30.
____________________________________________________________________
REASONS OF THE COURT
(Given by Kós J)
This judgment addresses whether and to what extent a Calderbank offer made by a successful respondent should affect costs on the appeal.
To orientate matters, we will repeat paragraph 1 of our judgment of 17 August 2016:[1]
[1] Richard Hodgkinson and Michelle Judd were married for six and a half years. Over that period they lived in a property in Lane Road, Havelock North, which was owned by the Richard Hodgkinson Trust (the Trust). After the couple separated, Ms Judd made a claim that the Trust held a share in the property on constructive trust for her, reflecting her contributions to the property. After trial, Williams J found Ms Judd had established a beneficial interest in the property and awarded her $65,000 to reflect her contributions. The appellants, the trustees of the Trust, appeal against that award.
Our judgment upheld the trial Judge and dismissed the appeal. Costs were reserved because counsel indicated that there had been a prior exchange of correspondence which might affect the usual disposition of such matters.
The respondent now seeks costs uplifted from $7,805 for a standard appeal on a band A basis to $14,375 — an increase of some 85 per cent — together with disbursements of $709.30. The latter sum is not contested. The uplift is sought under r 53E(2)(b)(iv) of the Court of Appeal (Civil) Rules 2005: i.e. the failure to accept a settlement offer without reasonable justification.
A Calderbank offer to settle the proceeding for $60,000 (plus costs awarded in the High Court) was made by the respondent shortly after the filing of the appeal. As noted earlier, Williams J awarded $65,000. As at the date of the offer Judicature Act interest on that sum would be a further $1,083.
The appellant opposes an uplift of costs on the basis that this was “an all or nothing appeal”. Mr Macfarlane submits that while it was possible the Court might have allowed the appeal only on quantum so as to reduce the award, the notice of appeal was drafted principally to aim at reversing the High Court judgment.
There is one prior decision by this Court under r 53E(2)(b)(iv). That is Powell v Hally Labels Ltd.[2] It is not entirely on point; the appeal in that case was not dispositive of the ultimate merits. In the High Court there are a number of authorities in which…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Hawke's Bay Trustee Company Limited v Judd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] NZCA 434
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The appeal was deemed to lack fundamental merit as the amount awarded to Judd was modest, and the primary aim of the appeal was to reverse the High Court judgment. A Calderbank offer, made by Judd shortly after the appeal was filed, proposed settling the proceeding for $60,000 plus costs awarded in the High Court. The trustees opposed an uplift in costs, arguing that the appeal was an "all or nothing" situation. The court considered the precedent set in Powell v Hally Labels Ltd and several High Court decisions that had awarded increased costs following the making of a Calderbank offer.
The Court of Appeal held that the refusal to accept the Calderbank offer was unreasonable given the modest award, the reasonable settlement offer made, and the fundamental lack of merit in the appeal. The court deemed it reasonable for the successful respondent to bear a greater proportion of costs than the standard scale, to reflect the circumstances of the case. The court awarded Judd an increase of 50% above the standard scale, resulting in costs of $11,700, plus disbursements of $709.30.
The court's final orders awarded Judd costs of $11,700 and disbursements of $709.30. The trustees were directed to pay the awarded costs and disbursements to Judd within 28 days of the date of the judgment.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi