Hargreaves v The Radio Network Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 31 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2002-409-000725 [2012] NZHC 2311

BETWEEN  PENELOPE ANN HARGREAVES Plaintiff

ANDTHE RADIO NETWORK LIMITED First Defendant

ANDTHE RADIO NETWORK OF NEW ZEALAND LIMITED

Second Defendant

Hearing:         30 August 2012

Appearances: Plaintiff in Person

P R Jagose and C E Deans for Defendants

Judgment:      7 September 2012

RESERVED JUDGMENT OF ASSOCIATE JUDGE MATTHEWS

Introduction

[1]      In this judgment I determine six interlocutory applications:

1.Applications by Mrs Hargreaves dated 3 August and 26 August 2012 to stay the timetable ordered by Chisholm J on 4 July 2012, which are effectively one application.

2.Application  by  Mrs  Hargreaves  for  a  High  Court  Judge  to  quash directions given by Associate Judge Osborne, dated 13 April 2012.

3.     Application  by Mrs  Hargreaves  dated  30  July 2012  “to  view  their

informed and written consent giving authority for Chapman Tripp to act in these proceedings from all the past and present directors of the Radio

PENELOPE ANN HARGREAVES V THE RADIO NETWORK LIMITED HC CHCH CIV-2002-409-000725 [7

September 2012]

Network  Limited  and  the  new  owners  who  purchased  the  Ouruhia

Transmission site ... in 2008 ...”.

4.Application  by Mrs  Hargreaves  to  order the attendance of Norman Collison  to  be  cross-examined  on  the  contents  of  his  affidavits  in support of the first defendant and second defendant, dated 14 May

2012.

5.     Application  by  Mrs  Hargreaves  dated  28  February  2012  called

“Statement of Claim Application”.

6.Interlocutory  application  on  notice  by  the  defendants  for  orders dismissing the proceeding, and ancillary orders, dated 16 March 2012.

Background

[2]      Chisholm J issued a judgment in this proceeding on 16 March 2010.  In that judgment ([6] to [28]) the Judge set out a brief summary of the facts which gave rise to this litigation, and a summary of the principal steps in the litigation up to that time.    The  judgment  dealt  with  an  application  for  review  of  a  decision  of  an Associate Judge striking out the fourth amended statement of claim.  The Judge set aside  the  orders  made  by  the Associate  Judge  and  reinstated  the  claim.    It  is unnecessary in this judgment to repeat the background facts and history of the case recorded in that judgment.

[3]      After release of the judgment of 16 March 2010 an Associate Judge directed that an amended statement of claim be filed by 28 January 2011 (a date which was later extended) and a fifth amended statement of claim was filed and served on 29

April 2011.   This was met with an application by the defendants under r 7.52 for leave to obtain orders striking out all the causes of action and dismissing the proceeding, or alternatively making an unless order dismissing the proceedings.

[4]      On 19 October 2011 Chisholm J issued a judgment on these applications.  In that  judgment  the  Judge  recorded  that  although  there  was  no  direction  in  his judgment of 16 March 2010 that the statement of claim would need to be amended,

that was the view adopted by Associate Judges who had subsequently handled the

case, and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hargreaves v The Radio Network Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] NZHC 2311
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case involved a plaintiff who was pursuing a claim against two companies, The Radio Network Limited and The Radio Network of New Zealand Limited. The plaintiff alleged that the companies' radio transmission activities had caused her harm. The case had been ongoing for over a decade and had involved multiple amendments to the plaintiff's statement of claim. The defendants sought to have the proceeding dismissed, while the plaintiff made several interlocutory applications, including requests to stay the timetable set by the Court, to cross-examine a witness, and to view documents demonstrating the authority of the defendants' legal representatives.

The Court considered the plaintiff's applications for a stay and to quash directions, and found that the plaintiff's allegations against the defendants' legal representatives were unsubstantiated and without merit. The Court dismissed the applications for a stay and to quash directions, noting that the plaintiff's reasons for seeking a stay were ill-founded and based on a misunderstanding of the facts.

The Court also considered the plaintiff's application to view documents demonstrating the authority of the defendants' legal representatives, and dismissed the application, finding that there was no proper basis for making the order sought by the plaintiff.

The Court then considered the plaintiff's application to cross-examine a witness, and found that the application did not meet the requirements for leave to cross-examine on interlocutory matters. The Court dismissed the application, noting that the proposed cross-examination did not relate to the issues arising on the interlocutory applications before the Court.

Finally, the Court considered the plaintiff's application to restore her original statement of claim, and found that the application was without foundation. The Court dismissed the application, noting that the plaintiff had not taken advantage of an opportunity to file an amended statement of claim which would not be statute-barred.

The Court also considered the defendants' application to strike out the proceeding, and found that the application met the test for leave to bring the application. The Court dismissed the proceeding, noting that the plaintiff had not taken advantage of opportunities to plead her case correctly, and that there was no tangible indication that given more time the pleadings would be remedied. The Court found that the proceeding was frivolous and vexatious, and an abuse of the process of the Court.