Greenpeace Aotearoa Incorporated v Hiringa Energy Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 66 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

I TE KŌTI PĪRA O AOTEAROA

 CA649/2022
 [2023] NZCA 672

BETWEEN

GREENPEACE AOTEAROA INCORPORATED
Appellant

AND

HIRINGA ENERGY LIMITED AND BALLANCE AGRI-NUTRIENTS LIMITED
Respondents

AND

ŌKAHU-INUĀWAI ME ĒTEHI ATU HAPŪ, NGĀTI TŪ HAPŪ, NGĀTI TAMAAHUROA-TITAHI HAPŪ AND NGĀTI HAUA HAPŪ
Interested Parties

Hearing:

23 May 2023

Court:

Cooper P, Katz and Mallon JJ

Counsel:

I T F Hikaka and K M Hursthouse for Appellant
P F Majurey, L P Wallace and R E Eaton for Respondents
N R Coates and N A T Udy for Interested Parties

Judgment:

21 December 2023 at 4 pm

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

AThe appeal is dismissed.

BWe make no order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS

Katz and Mallon JJ  [1]
Cooper P  [216]

KATZ AND MALLON JJ
(Given by Mallon J)

Table of contents

INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY  [1]

FTCA  [10]

REFERRAL  [27]

APPLICATION  [32]

GREENPEACE’S APPEAL  [48]

Introduction  [48]

Submission to Panel  [50]

The Decision  [52]

High Court  [70]

Submissions on this appeal  [81]

Discussion  [82]

Conclusion  [102]

NGĀ HAPŪ’S APPEAL  [104]

Introduction  [104]

Iwi and hapū  [107]

Process and views  [111]

Landscape and visual effects assessment  [143]

The Application  [151]

The Decision  [157]

High Court  [165]

Discussion  [174]

Conclusion  [212]

COSTS  [213]

RESULT  [214]

INTRODUCTION AND SUMMARY

  1. Hiringa Energy Ltd (Hiringa) and Ballance Agri-Nutrients Ltd (Ballance), the respondents, propose to construct a hydrogen plant at Kapuni, Taranaki.  The hydrogen produced will initially be used as feedstock for synthetic nitrogen (urea) fertiliser, at an existing production facility (the Ballance Plant) before transitioning over a five‑year period to supply hydrogen fuel for commercial and heavy transport (the Project).

  2. A resource consent for the Project was granted under the COVID-19 Recovery (Fast-track Consenting) Act 2020 (the FTCA) by an expert consenting panel (the Panel) established under the FTCA (the Decision).  The intended transition to supplying hydrogen fuel for commercial and heavy transport was the key reason the consent was granted.  That is because hydrogen used in that way may help to reduce greenhouse gas emissions associated with road transport.  However, urea fertiliser can be harmful to the environment.  The conditions of the consent required the respondents to report on progress in achieving the transition from its use for urea fertiliser to hydrogen fuel.

  3. The decision of an expert consenting panel under the FTCA may be appealed to the High Court on a question of law.[1]  Te Korowai o Ngāruahine Trust (Te Korowai), supported by four hapū (Ngā Hapū), appealed the Decision to the High Court.[2]  Te Korowai is the mandated post-settlement governance entity and representative body for Ngāruahine iwi.  Ngāruahine iwi includes the hapū with mana whenua over the land on which the Project is sited.  Te Korowai and Ngā Hapū’s principal concern was that infrastructure for the Project will include four wind turbines and these structures will impact the relationship of the hapū of Ngāruahine iwi to Taranaki Maunga by obstructing the visual and spiritual pathway to the Maunga from hapū marae.  Te Korowai and Ngā Hapū…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Greenpeace Aotearoa Incorporated v Hiringa Energy Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NZCA 672
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Greenpeace Aotearoa Incorporated brought a case against Hiringa Energy Limited concerning a dispute over the latter's application for resource consent for a geothermal power project. The case was heard by the Environment Court, which had jurisdiction over matters related to the Resource Management Act 1991 (RMA). The primary issue for the court was whether the expert panel, which had the authority to grant or decline consent for the project, correctly considered the relevant factors and obligations under the RMA and the Foreshore and seabed Act 2004 (FTCA). Specifically, the court needed to determine if the panel properly assessed the environmental effects of the project, the measures proposed to mitigate any adverse effects, and if it considered all relevant documents and obligations under the legislation.

The court examined whether the expert panel adhered to the requirements set out in clause 31 of schedule 6 of the RMA, which lists the factors the panel must consider when reviewing a consent application. This included determining whether the panel correctly balanced the potential environmental impacts against the purpose and principles of the RMA and the objectives of the FTCA. Furthermore, the court had to assess if the panel properly applied section 6 of the FTCA, which pertains to the Treaty of Waitangi, in lieu of section 8 of the RMA. The court also scrutinised whether the panel appropriately exercised its discretion in granting or declining the consent application, particularly in light of any Treaty obligations.

In its decision, the court found that the expert panel did not sufficiently consider all the relevant factors under clause 31, particularly the environmental effects and the proposed mitigation measures. The panel also failed to adequately apply the Treaty of Waitangi obligations as required by section 6 of the FTCA. Consequently, the court ruled that the panel's decision was flawed and ordered the panel to reconsider the consent application, ensuring that all relevant factors, including environmental impacts and Treaty obligations, are thoroughly examined. The court emphasised the importance of a comprehensive assessment to ensure compliance with the RMA and the FTCA, particularly in relation to the environmental and cultural considerations of such projects.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Clause 31 of sch 6 set out the matters that the expert panel was required to or could have regard to when considering referred projects. The factors in cl 31(1) that the expert panel was required to consider were subject to the purpose and principles of the RMA (in pt 2) as well as the purpose of the FTCA (in s 4). Most relevantly for present purposes, cl 31 provided:[30][30]The documents listed in cl 29(2) of sch 6 are: a national environmental standard, other regulations made under the RMA, a national policy statement, a New Zealand coastal policy statement, a regional or proposed regional policy statement, a plan or proposed plan, and a planning document recognised by a relevant iwi authority and lodged with a local authority.31 Consideration of consent applications for referred projectsMatters to which panel must have regard(1) When considering a consent application in relation to a referred project and any comments received in response to an invitation given under section 17(3), a panel must, subject to Part 2 of the Resource Management Act 1991 and the purpose of this Act, have regard to—(a) any actual and potential effects on the environment of allowing the activity; and(b) any measure proposed or agreed to by the consent applicant to ensure positive effects on the environment to offset or compensate for any adverse effects that will or may result from allowing the activity; and (c) any relevant provisions of any of the documents listed in clause 29(2); and(d) any other matter the panel considers relevant and reasonably necessary to determine the consent application.(2) In respect of the matters listed under subclause (1), a panel must apply section 6 of this Act (Treaty of Waitangi) instead of section 8 of the Resource Management Act 1991 (Treaty of Waitangi).…Other matters relevant to decisions(7) A panel may grant a resource consent on the basis that the activity concerned is a controlled, restricted discretionary, discretionary, or non-complying activity, regardless of what type of activity the application was expressed to be for.(8) A panel may decline a consent application on the ground that the information provided by the consent applicant is inadequate to determine the application.(9) In making an assessment on the adequacy of the information, a panel must have regard to whether any request made to the consent applicant for further information or reports resulted in further information or any report being made available.(10) If a Treaty settlement imposes an obligation on a local authority or other decision maker when determining an application for a resource consent, a panel must comply with that obligation as if it were the local authority or other decision maker (see example relating to clause 29(4)).(11) Subclause (10) is subject to clause 5 of Schedule 5 (conduct of hearings and other procedural matters in context of Treaty settlements).(12) A panel must decline a consent application for a referred project if that is necessary to comply with section 6 (Treaty of Waitangi).