Graham v Arena Capital Limited (in liquidation)

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-404-1500 [2016] NZHC 194

BETWEEN

ROBERT GRANT GRAHAM AND

NEALE JACKSON Plaintiffs

AND

ARENA CAPITAL LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) Defendant

Hearing: 5 February 2016

Appearances:

G Colson and L W Brazier for Plaintiffs
M J Borcoski and T J Brown for Defendants

Judgment:

17 February 2016

JUDGMENT OF MANDER J

[1]      The liquidators of Arena Capital Ltd (in liquidation) (Arena) have applied for directions under the Companies Act 1993 in relation to a category of deposits made to the company’s bank account.1   These deposits were made by investors on or after the date on which the Financial Markets Authority (FMA) was granted initial asset preservation orders (APOs) over Arena’s assets.

[2]      The liquidators seek directions that these funds form part of the assets of Arena and be treated in the liquidation in the same way as any other funds held in Arena’s bank account prior to 15 May 2016.  The liquidator’s application is resisted by the post-APO depositors.   Ancillary orders are also sought which are not the

subject of contest.

1      Companies Act 1993, s 284(1)(a).

GRAHAM  v ARENA CAPITAL LIMITED (IN LIQUIDATION) [2016] NZHC 194 [17 February 2016]

Background

[3]      Arena purported to operate a foreign exchange trading business.   Despite deposits being received from clients for the purpose of investment, the company did not conduct any foreign exchange trading nor any other form of investment activity. A single  bank  account  was  operated  by Arena  into  which  these  deposits  were received.   “Profits” the clients were led to believe existed were in fact fictitious. Monies disbursed to clients to maintain the façade of an active operation were paid out from deposits from other clients.  Arena was operating in essence a simple Ponzi scheme.

[4]      The FMA obtained initial interim APOs over Arena’s assets on 15 May 2015. The terms of the APO prohibited Arena from transferring, charging or otherwise dealing with money, including the bank account. There was, however, no prohibition on deposits continuing to be received into the account.  It does not appear that any media release or publicity was given to the making of the APOs until 21 May 2015. In the interim, the bank account continued to receive investors’ deposits.

[5]      Seventeen Arena clients made deposits into the account on or after 15 May

2015 to a total sum of $249,000.  Up until that date, the pattern of activity of the account involved a large number of deposits by investors, some payments out to investors and those associated with the management and ownership of the company, and payments of wages and transfers to third parties usually related to Arena.

[6]      Of the seventeen post-APO depositors, eleven had previously made deposits to Arena prior to 15 May and two received withdrawals before the APOs were in place, although for lesser sums than they had deposited.  One post-APO depositor had deposited a sum and withdrawn a greater sum prior to the APOs being in place (the  greater  sum  presumably  being  a  “profit”…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Graham v Arena Capital Limited (in liquidation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] NZHC 194
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Graham v Arena Capital Limited (in liquidation) involved a dispute between the liquidators of Arena Capital Limited and post-APO depositors over the distribution of funds deposited into Arena's bank account after the imposition of asset preservation orders (APO) by the Financial Markets Authority (FMA). The liquidators sought directions to treat the post-APO deposits as part of the assets of Arena and distribute them in the same manner as any other funds held in the bank account before the APOs were imposed. The post-APO depositors, however, claimed a proprietary interest in their deposits, asserting they were entitled to priority over other Arena investors. The court had to decide whether the funds deposited by investors were held on trust and if the post-APO depositors were entitled to priority in the distribution of the assets. The court found that the post-APO depositors' funds were subject to a statutory trust, but due to the intervention of the FMA and the imposition of the APOs, these funds were readily identifiable and could be traced. The court concluded that the post-APO depositors' funds should be paid in priority to any other distribution, declining the liquidators' application for orders directing that such funds be treated in the same way as any other funds held in the bank account prior to the APOs. The court also made orders regarding the payment of legal costs and the confidentiality of the depositors' identities and amounts deposited.