Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-409-000010 [2015] NZHC 515

BETWEEN

BRIAN ARTHUR GOSNEY AND

AUDREY LAURA EDWARDS Appellants

AND

NGAI TAHU PROPERTY LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: 17 March 2015

Appearances:

R Armstrong for Appellant
A Riches and J Taylor for Respondent

Judgment:

17 March 2015

ORAL JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J

Introduction

[1]      Mr  Brian  Gosney  and  Ms Audrey  Edwards  (who  I will  refer  to  in  this judgment  as  “the  Gosneys”)  appeal  against  a  decision  of  Judge  Crosbie  in  the District Court at Christchurch dated 2 December 2014 granting an interim injunction in favour of Ngai Tahu Property Limited (who I will refer to as Ngai Tahu) making the following interim orders:1

(a)      Preventing the Gosneys from interfering with the plaintiff’s erection of a fence along the western boundary of their property where it meets the  eastern  boundary,  a  property  owned  by  Ngai  Tahu,  and  in particular preventing the damage or removal of posts made to enable the erection of the fence.

(b)Allowing Ngai Tahu to  go on to the  Gosneys' property to enable erection of the fence.

1      Ngai Tahu Property Ltd v Gosney DC Christchurch CIV-2014-009-2307, 2 December 2014.

GOSNEY v NGAI TAHU PROPERTY LIMITED [2015] NZHC 515 [17 March 2015]

(c)       Preventing  the  defendants,  the  Gosneys  from  interfering  with  the

plaintiffs’ cadastral survey pegs.

[2]      Ngai  Tahu  resist  the  appeal  on  the  basis  that  the  decision  reached  by

Judge Crosbie in the District Court was correct.

Background facts

[3]      Ngai Tahu purchased a parcel of land in the north east of Christchurch, which it  has  been  developing  into  a  residential  subdivision  known  as  “Prestons”. Ngai Tahu said it wished to build a fence along the western boundary of the Gosneys' property.2   Indeed, Ngai Tahu is required to do so as a result of Plan Change 30 in the Christchurch District Plan.

[4]      In  anticipation  of  the  fence  being  constructed,  Ngai  Tahu  contracted surveyors to survey the boundaries of the new fence.   Ngai Tahu then employed fencing contractors to begin constructing the fence in March 2014, which was confirmed to be on the boundary line.  However, the Gosneys took objection to this and began removing the fence as it was being constructed. As a result, Ngai Tahu by its solicitors, on 10 October 2014, sent a letter to the Gosneys stating that if they further interfered with the construction of the fence then Ngai Tahu would apply for an injunction.

[5]      Unfortunately, no amicable solution was able to be reached.   Ngai Tahu therefore applied to the District Court for the orders which I have set out above.  The Gosneys opposed the orders sought in the District Court on the basis that:

(a)       They were entitled to interfere with the applicant Ngai Tahu’s erection of a fence on their land because Ngai Tahu’s actions constituted a

trespass on the Gosneys' land.

2      The Gosneys claim however that the western boundary of their property borders Marshlands

Road and they assume Ngai Tahu are actually referring to the eastern…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 515
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of New Zealand heard an appeal by Brian Arthur Gosney and Audrey Laura Edwards (the Gosneys) against a decision of the District Court granting an interim injunction to Ngai Tahu Property Limited (Ngai Tahu). The injunction allowed Ngai Tahu to erect a fence along the boundary of their properties and prohibited the Gosneys from interfering with the construction of the fence. The Gosneys appealed, arguing that the District Court's decision was incorrect, as Ngai Tahu had not followed the required procedure under the Fencing Act 1978 and had trespassed on their property by constructing the fence without consent. The legal issue before the Court was whether the Fencing Act 1978 applied to the case and whether Ngai Tahu had the right to construct the fence without the Gosneys' consent or a court order. The Court held that the Fencing Act 1978 applied to the case and that Ngai Tahu could not construct a fence without the Gosneys' consent or a court order, even if they were not seeking contribution from the Gosneys for the cost of the fence. The Court quashed the District Court's decision and made no order in its place. However, the interim injunction granted by the District Court would remain in full force and effect until 4 p.m. on 31 March 2015, with an amendment to its terms to refer to the eastern boundary of the Gosneys' property rather than the western boundary. The Court reserved costs, with the Gosneys to file memoranda on costs within 10 working days of the date of the judgment.

The Gosneys appealed against a decision of the District Court granting an interim injunction to Ngai Tahu Property Limited. The injunction allowed Ngai Tahu to erect a fence along the boundary of their properties and prohibited the Gosneys from interfering with the construction of the fence. The Gosneys argued that the District Court's decision was incorrect, as Ngai Tahu had not followed the required procedure under the Fencing Act 1978 and had trespassed on their property by constructing the fence without consent. The Court held that the Fencing Act 1978 applied to the case and that Ngai Tahu could not construct a fence without the Gosneys' consent or a court order, even if they were not seeking contribution from the Gosneys for the cost of the fence. The Court quashed the District Court's decision and made no order in its place. However, the interim injunction granted by the District Court would remain in full force and effect until 4 p.m. on 31 March 2015, with an amendment to its terms to refer to the eastern boundary of the Gosneys' property rather than the western boundary. The Court reserved costs, with the Gosneys to file memoranda on costs within 10 working days of the date of the judgment.