Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Limited

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND CHRISTCHURCH REGISTRY

CIV-2015-409-000010 [2015] NZHC 945

BETWEEN

BRIAN ARTHUR GOSNEY AND

AUDREY LAURA EDWARDS Appellants

AND

NGAI TAHU PROPERTY LIMITED Respondent

Hearing: Dealt with on the papers

Judgment:

6 May 2015

JUDGMENT OF GENDALL J (As to Costs)

The Gosneys seek costs

[1]      On 17 March 2015 in this proceeding I allowed an appeal by Mr Gosney and Ms Edward (who I refer to as “the Gosneys”) from a decision of the District Court in relation to what was essentially a fencing dispute.1   The background facts are set out in that judgment and  I need not repeat them here.   In that decision however I recorded the following on the issue of costs:

[37]     I now turn to the issue of costs.   Costs here are reserved.   As I understand  it  from  earlier  submission,  there  is  a  suggestion  that  the appellants, the Gosneys, may wish to seek indemnity costs on this appeal and in the District Court proceeding. As the Gosneys have succeeded on this appeal, costs will follow the event in the absence of compelling reasons to the contrary.   Memoranda on costs are to be filed by the appellants, the Gosneys, within 10 working days of the date of this judgment, with the respondent, Ngai Tahu, following not later than 10 working days thereafter. Memoranda on costs are limited to five pages in length.  I will then deal with the matter of costs on the papers in the absence of either party indicating they wish to be heard on the matter.

1      Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Ltd [2015] NZHC 515.

GOSNEY v NGAI TAHU PROPERTY LIMITED [2015] NZHC 945 [6 May 2015]

[2]      Memoranda from counsel for the parties have duly been filed.  The positions taken by the parties can be summarised succinctly.   The Gosneys seek indemnity costs, or, in the alternative, increased costs here, while the respondent, Ngai Tahu Property Ltd (Ngai Tahu), accepts it is to pay costs but considers that 2B scale costs only would be appropriate.

[3]      The basis on which the Gosneys seek indemnity or increased costs here as they contend is as follows:

(a)      Ngai Tahu acted improperly or unnecessarily in commencing and continuing with the proceeding.   In essence, the Gosneys say that Ngai Tahu’s argument pursuant to s 22 of the Fencing Act 1978 was misconceived and clearly contrary to the plain meaning of s 8.

(b)The result of Ngai Tahu’s plainly incorrect legal interpretation of the Fencing Act 1978 was that it was entirely incorrect for it to seek an injunction.

(c)      Ngai Tahu did not seek to explain its position to the Gosneys in the face  of  Ngai  Tahu  unlawfully  entering  the  land  owned  by  the Gosneys.    There  was  therefore  no  opportunity  for  the  parties  to engage in discussions.

(d)Prior to the Gosneys commencing their appeal, they sent an open letter to Ngai Tahu, proposing terms of settlement, namely that Ngai Tahu agree to the District Court order being set aside and the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Limited and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] NZHC 945
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the High Court of New Zealand, the case of Gosney v Ngai Tahu Property Limited involved a dispute over fencing between the Gosneys, the appellants, and Ngai Tahu Property Limited, the respondent. The dispute arose out of an initial decision by the District Court which the Gosneys appealed. The primary issue before the Court was the allocation of costs between the parties. The Gosneys sought indemnity costs, or alternatively, increased costs on the basis that Ngai Tahu had acted improperly in commencing and continuing the proceeding. Conversely, Ngai Tahu argued that it was appropriate for the Gosneys to pay only 2B scale costs.

The Court considered the principles governing indemnity costs, noting that such costs are only justified in exceptional circumstances and are not the norm in New Zealand’s party-party costs system. The Court found that Ngai Tahu’s actions in bringing and sustaining the proceeding were indeed improper and unnecessary, primarily due to its misunderstanding of the relevant statutory provisions and failure to engage in dialogue with the Gosneys. The Court concluded that Ngai Tahu’s conduct warranted indemnity costs, and awarded the Gosneys the full amount of $29,592.80 claimed for costs and disbursements. This decision highlights the importance of proper legal interpretation and the potential consequences of pursuing meritless litigation.