Gibbston Downs Wines Ltd v Property Ventures Ltd (in rec and liq)

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA82/2013
[2013] NZCA 546

BETWEEN

GIBBSTON DOWNS WINES LIMITED
Appellant

AND

PROPERTY VENTURES LIMITED

(IN RECEIVERSHIP AND LIQUIDATION)
Respondent

CA83/2013

AND BETWEEN

SPINACH DESIGN LIMITED
Appellant

AND

PROPERTY VENTURES LIMITED

(IN RECEIVERSHIP AND LIQUIDATION)
Respondent

Hearing:

25 July 2013 (further memoranda received on 2 August and 7 August 2013)

Court:

O’Regan P, French and Winkelmann JJ

Counsel:

K W Clay for Appellants
T G H Smith for Respondent

Judgment:

7 November 2013 at 11.30 am

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeals are dismissed.

B        No order as to costs.

____________________________________________________________________

REASONS OF THE COURT

(Given by Winkelmann J)

  1. At issue in both appeals is whether a liquidator may issue a statutory demand for a debt owed to a company in liquidation at a time when a receiver has been appointed by a secured creditor, the debt forms part of the secured assets, and the secured creditor has not surrendered the security. 

  2. Property Ventures Ltd (Property Ventures) is one of a large number of companies associated with Mr David Henderson.  Receivers were appointed to Property Ventures on 5 March 2010 pursuant to a general security agreement, and the company was then put into liquidation on 27 July 2010.  Mr Simon Thorn and Mr Timothy Downes were its receivers, and Mr Robert Walker, its liquidator.[1] 

    [1]After the hearing, we were informed that Messrs Thorn and Downes had given a notice on 6 August 2013 (after the hearing) that they had ceased to act as receivers on 27 June 2013.  We were also told that their appointer had assigned its general security agreement and that the new secured party supported the actions of the liquidator.  We have not, however, taken into account these post-hearing developments in this judgment.

  3. The receivers had difficulty in obtaining the full accounting records of Property Ventures, and it was the liquidator, Mr Walker, who was ultimately able to obtain them.  Utilising the information extracted from those records, he issued statutory demands in relation to particular payments.  One demand was to the appellant Gibbston Downs Wines Ltd (Gibbston) for $1,520,123.03.  The other was to the appellant Spinach Design Ltd (Spinach Design) in relation to a debt of $12,206.25. 

  4. Both Gibbston and Spinach Design applied to set aside the statutory demands on grounds that there was a substantial dispute as to whether the debt specified in the demand was due and owing, and that the liquidator of Property Ventures had no authority to issue the statutory demand because of the receivership.  Gibbston advanced an additional ground ― that there was misconduct on the part of the liquidator which justified setting aside the statutory demand. 

  5. In the High Court, Associate Judge Osborne issued separate judgments contemporaneously, dismissing Gibbston’s and Spinach Design’s applications.[2]   Both Gibbston and Spinach Design appeal the finding that the liquidator had power to issue the statutory demands.  Spinach Design also appeals the finding that there was no genuine or substantial dispute of the debt. 

First ground of appeal: liquidator’s…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gibbston Downs Wines Ltd v Property Ventures Ltd (in rec and... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] NZCA 546
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeals were brought by Gibbston Downs Wines Limited and Spinach Design Limited against the liquidator of Property Ventures Limited, a company that had been placed into liquidation following the appointment of receivers. The receivers had been appointed by a secured creditor, and the debts in question formed part of the secured assets. The appellants challenged the liquidator's authority to issue statutory demands for the debts, arguing that the receivers had control over the charged assets and should have been pursuing the debts. They also argued that there was a genuine or substantial dispute as to the existence of the debt in the case of Spinach Design.

The Court of Appeal considered the liquidator's authority to issue statutory demands and concluded that the liquidator did have the authority to do so, even when a receiver had been appointed. The Court found that the liquidator's discretion to act in relation to charged property, as provided for in section 254 of the Companies Act 1993, was a residual power that could be exercised in certain circumstances, such as when the secured creditor had not taken any steps to realise the asset. The Court also found that the receivers' attitude towards the liquidator's actions was relevant and that the liquidator was not acting officiously in this case.

In relation to Spinach Design's argument that there was a genuine or substantial dispute as to the existence of the debt, the Court found that the Associate Judge had correctly concluded that Spinach Design had failed to provide sufficient evidence to support its claim. The Court held that the bank statements and other evidence did not support Spinach Design's contention that the payment had been made for the benefit of third parties.

The appeals were dismissed, and no order was made as to costs due to the significance of the late filed evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established