Gemmell v Department of Corrections

Link copied
Case Copied 8 min read

IN THE HIGH COURT OF NEW ZEALAND HAMILTON REGISTRY

I TE KŌTI MATUA O AOTEAROA KIRIKIRIROA ROHE

CRI-2018-419-000029 [2018] NZHC 1918

BETWEEN

MYCHAL SEAMUS GEMMELL

Appellant

AND

DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS Respondent

Hearing: 31 July 2018

Appearances:

J Alchin-Boller for Appellant
A Pell for Respondent

Judgment:

31 July 2018

ORAL JUDGMENT OF GORDON J

Solicitors:           Crown Solicitor, Hamilton

Grantham Law, Hamilton

GEMMELL v DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS [2018] NZHC 1918 [31 July 2018]

Introduction

[1]      Mr Gemmell appeals a sentence of seven months’ imprisonment and an order to pay $200, imposed by Judge PS Rollo in the Hamilton District Court on 7 June

2018.1   The sentence arose from two charges of breaching a condition of parole and

one charge of wilful damage.  Mr Gemmell pleaded guilty to all three offences at an early stage. The issue on appeal is whether that sentence is manifestly excessive.

Background and facts of the offending

[2]      Mr Gemmell was released from prison on parole in June 2017.  He had been imprisoned for offences committed in August and September 2014.  His offending included a violent assault, and wilfully damaging the victim’s cellphone.  On release, the appellant was under a parole condition not to associate with the victim.

[3]      On 12 May 2018, Mr Gemmell confirmed to Police that the victim had been present at his address. A verbal altercation had occurred. The appellant was sentenced to come up if called upon for a period of six months.  This was the first charge for breach of parole conditions.

[4]      On 7 June 2018, Mr Gemmell went to the victim’s address.  He wanted his gang vest, which was in the victim’s vehicle.  She refused to give Mr Gemmell her keys and locked herself in her house.  He broke a car window and obtained his vest before leaving.  This resulted in the second breach of parole conditions and wilful damage charges.

Sentencing decision

[5]      Sentencing before the District Court took place in the absence of a pre-sentence report at the request of Mr Gemmell. The Judge described the breaches of parole as a serious matter.  He relied on several High Court decisions, from which he reasoned

1      Police v Gemmell [2018] NZDC 11525.

that a breach of parole conditions goes to the heart of rehabilitating offenders and protecting the community.2

[6]      The Judge did not adopt discrete starting points for each offence but noted that he had taken into account the early guilty pleas.  On the wilful damage charge the Judge imposed a sentence of one month’s imprisonment and reparation in the sum of

$200 to be paid in $25 instalments on release. For the first breach of parole conditions, he sentenced Mr Gemmell to two months’ imprisonment, and for the second breach of parole conditions the Judge imposed a sentence of four months’ imprisonment.  The three sentences were imposed cumulatively, resulting in a final sentence of seven months’ imprisonment along with the reparation payment.

Approach on appeal

[7]      Section 250(2) of the Criminal Procedure Act 2011 provides:

(2)      The…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gemmell v Department of Corrections and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NZHC 1918
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Mychal Seamus Gemmell appeals against a sentence of seven months' imprisonment and an order to pay $200 imposed by the District Court. The sentence arose from two charges of breaching a condition of parole and one charge of wilful damage, to which Gemmell pleaded guilty. The appeal focuses on whether the sentence is manifestly excessive. Gemmell was released from prison on parole in June 2017, following imprisonment for a violent assault and wilful damage. His parole conditions included not associating with the victim. However, Gemmell breached these conditions twice: first, by confirming the victim's presence at his address, and second, by breaking a car window to retrieve his gang vest from the victim's vehicle. The District Court imposed a sentence of one month for wilful damage, two months for the first breach of parole, and four months for the second breach, all to be served cumulatively, resulting in a total of seven months' imprisonment.

The High Court considered whether the sentence was manifestly excessive, focusing on the end sentence rather than the process used to reach it. The Court determined that the second breach of parole was more serious than the breaches in comparable cases, warranting a starting point of six months' imprisonment. The first breach was less serious, leading to an uplift of only one month. The Court did not impose an additional uplift for the wilful damage charge, considering it concurrent with the second breach. After accounting for Gemmell's criminal history, the Court arrived at a starting point of eight months' imprisonment. Applying a 25% reduction for early guilty pleas, the Court determined the appropriate sentence to be six months' imprisonment.

The appeal was allowed, and the original sentence of seven months' imprisonment was quashed. The High Court imposed a sentence of six months' imprisonment, reflecting the totality principle and the specific circumstances of the case.