Geddes v New Zealand Dairy Board

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

IN THE COURT OF APPEAL OF NEW ZEALAND

CA180/03

BETWEENJAMES JEFFREY GEDDES as representative of the CONCERNED DAIRYMEN'S ASSOCIATION


First Appellant

ANDLEVELS GENTECH LIMITED


Second Appellant

ANDBRENCO LIVESTOCK LIMITED


Third Appellant

ANDNEW ZEALAND DAIRY BOARD


First Respondent

ANDLIVESTOCK IMPROVEMENT CORPORATION LIMITED


Second Respondent

Hearing:26-29 July 2004

Court:Anderson  P, Hammond and Chambers JJ

Counsel:G J Judd QC and F M R Cooke QC for Appellants


L J Taylor, S D Galloway and A L Sherriff for Respondents

Judgment:20 June 2005 

JUDGMENT OF THE COURT

A        The appeal is dismissed. 

BThe appellants must pay costs to the respondents in the sum of $25,000, plus usual disbursements.  The liability of the first, second, and third appellants is joint and several.  We make no determination as to the entitlements of the first and second respondents as between themselves.

REASONS

(Given by Chambers J)

Table of Contents

Para No
A new animal evaluation system for the dairy industry               [1]
Issues on the appeal  [11]

Farmer plaintiffs’ fiduciary cause of action  [18]

Levels Gentech’s and Brenco’s fiduciary cause of action             [60]
Fair Trading Act  
           Overview  [65]
           The alleged representations  [67]
           Applicable legal principles  [77]
           First core representation  [82]
           First core representation: an offshoot  [100]
           Second core representation  [113]
           Third core representation  [129]
Costs  [153]
A final word  [154]

A new animal evaluation system for the dairy industry

[1]        Mr James Geddes, a dairy farmer from Christchurch, and a number of other dairy farmers formed the Concerned Dairymen’s Association (“CDA”) in 1996 following the introduction of a new animal evaluation system by Livestock Improvement Incorporation Limited (“LIC”), at that time a wholly owned subsidiary of the New Zealand Dairy Board (“the Board”).  Mr Geddes and his cohorts believed that their herds had been devalued through the introduction by LIC of a flawed animal evaluation system.  When the Board and LIC refused to meet the CDA concerns, the CDA sued the Board and LIC in the High Court in Wellington.

[2]        Later they were joined by two other companies who had similar concerns, Levels Gentech Limited and Brenco Livestock Limited.  Levels Gentech and Brenco were importers and sellers of bovine genetic material. 

[3]        The dispute finally came to hearing before Wild J in April 2003.  The hearing continued through to July that year.  There were no fewer than seven causes of action against the Board and LIC.  Wild J delivered a reserved decision on 27 August 2003: Geddes v The New Zealand Dairy Board HC WN CP52/97 and CP30/02 (“judgment”).  The plaintiffs failed on all causes of action.

[4]        The seven causes of action represented different challenges to a core complaint.  The essence of the complaint is this.  In 1996, LIC implemented a new system for the genetic and productive evaluation of dairy stock for use in New Zealand.  The new system replaced an earlier evaluation system which had been in use since the 1960s.  The new Animal Evaluation System (“AES”) comprised an animal model and an economic model, together producing a single index, purportedly ranking dairy stock…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Geddes v New Zealand Dairy Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NZCA 159
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The appeal was brought by James Geddes and others, including two companies, against the New Zealand Dairy Board and Livestock Improvement Corporation, in relation to a new animal evaluation system (AES) implemented by Livestock Improvement Corporation. The plaintiffs claimed that the AES was flawed and that its implementation had caused them harm, either because it devalued their herds or because it had reduced their ability to sell bull semen. The trial judge rejected all claims. The appeal before the Court of Appeal was limited to two claims, one based on breach of fiduciary duty and one under the Fair Trading Act 1986. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal, finding in favour of the respondents on both claims. The fiduciary claim was rejected because Livestock Improvement Corporation did not owe fiduciary duties to the plaintiffs, whether they were dairy farmers or companies selling semen. The Court found that the plaintiffs had failed to demonstrate that Livestock Improvement Corporation had acted in breach of any legal duty to them. The claim under the Fair Trading Act was also rejected, as the Court found that Livestock Improvement Corporation had not made any misleading or deceptive representations in relation to the AES. The Court of Appeal also dismissed the appeal on costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established